I am sure the experts will weigh in but that doesn't look like any mitered edge I have seen. Here a a couple google images that illustrate a mitered edge.

That's not a miter, it's a rabbet with a poorly color matched adhesive. It would look better with a larger edge profile

My mitered edges look like badgergal's drawings. No seam is visible.

Sorry, I can't post pictures. I am a total luddite.

A mitered edge seam is at the edge, like in the above drawings, and hardly noticeable. Did your granite guy show you any examples of edges? Often mitered edges are charged extra so check on this. Hope you can get this resolved.

snookers1999:

How long was your sink clamped as shown in the picture? I ask because guys that don't mechanically fasten sinks clamp them like that overnight or so. I clamp them like that for about 10 minutes while I tighten the Hercules Universal Sink Harness. Check your sink for mechanical fasteners, please.

definitely NOT a mitered edge. can't see the staining you mention because picture is too small for me.

I am a fabricator.

Thats not a mitered edge ... and not a particularly good example of a laminated drop edge. The "stain" looks like a repair of a chipped edge that was done poorly.

This is what a good mitered edge looks like:

Nope, that is definitely not a mitered edge!

I have a question - why would someone want/need an edge in granite such as the OP posted?

blfenton, it's needed when the granite is 2 cm and they want the edge to be thicker.

sjhockeyfan - sorry I guess I wasn't exact enough in my question. I was wondering why the seam was set so high. Our bathroom granite was built up but the seam is at the midway point and you can't even see it. Perhaps it depends on the type of granite.

blfenton:

It does depend on the type of granite; the movement and the particulates. Too many fabricators don't test joints, profiles, and adhesives for color match.

We had the granite guys over last night and they said that they miter the edge but then they cut of the ends of each edge because according to them where the granite the meets on the edge that is mitered it is to chipped up to look good. So what they do is miter the edges but then go along each edge and cut it occ so that the "chipped" edge is taken off the granite and leaves it looking smoother. However, as you can obviously tell from the picture, this leaves you with a seam slightly down from the edge of the granite. According to them, granite of any type cannot have a true miter do to the corners becoming chipped in the process. Only engineered stone, marble, etc. can be truly mitered and have the seem in the edges and corners. Are they pulling my leg?

I'm not a professional but have seen enough botched mitered edges on this forum to know they are pulling your leg. As the professionals said & your granite guys said "it's not a mitered edge." It's too bad they didn't tell you that before they fabricated your tops. A sample of what they were going to do would have given you the option of a different edge profile. What now? Is it too unsightly to live with (hard to tell from your pics)? Are they offering any fixes for the "stained" chip repairs?

I have no clue as to how this could be fixed but I would want the edge I asked for. I would make them take out all the counters in question and do it properly. If they can't, get your money back and hire someplace else.

"Are they pulling my leg?"

Concentrate and you will feel them tugging.

Their "reasoning" makes little sense. If they want proof, I can take them to hundreds of granite shops that fabricate true miters.

I'd put a bevel or rounded edge profile on a sample of your material and adhesive to see if this is salvageable. The profile must stop just before the glue line or you risk elongation which will make things worse.

BS! Here is a closeup I just took of mine:

"Concentrate and you will feel them tugging."

Perfect!

" According to them, granite of any type cannot have a true miter do to the corners becoming chipped in the process"

this is just incorrect. See my pic above. That is a 4" mitered drop edge with a mitered corner to boot. you can't even see the seam where the mitered pieces meet up close in person. Properly done a mitered joint looks like solid stone except for a possible grain transition (which is minimized if the sawing is done properly)

If they don't have the proper equipment and or experience then it probably is impossible for them.

The should have told you up front that they have problems with mitered edges and let you decide what you want to do.

I'd have them bring you a check and remove their shoddy work.

firstmmo I have a question on the photo you shared — beautiful countertop and cabinets BTW! For your mitered edge, were those specially ordered cabinets for the countertop, or did you have to raise the countertops up a bit? (Or you wouldn't be able to open the drawer) Thanks!

Danielle Sopko I was getting ready to ask this same question before I saw that you did already! I'd love to know the answer to this too- let me know if you find out!

snookers1999 thank you so much! Did everything work out for you in the end? (I know this is a super old thread)

Yes, they put in an extra piece of plywood because I chose such a thick edge, but we actually factored in the extra 5/8" plywood when we designed the height of the cabinets too, so that the final counter height was the height that we wanted--I am only 5'2" so my counters would usually be shorter but I designed them for a taller (average) person so they have a finished height of 37.5".

snookers1999 UGH, I'm always blown away by companies that are ok with negative reviews being left rather than just doing the right thing. Word of mouth/reviews are so important these days- especially with everything so easily accessible online... You would think they'd care. I'm glad they at least gave you some of your money back. The least they could do.

LVasquez:

It isn't getting a bad review that's bad, it's how the company responds to the bad review that can be. I've get a few every now and then and I wouldn't remove them even if I could. If you read a bad review of me and don't want to do business with me after hearing my response, I'm glad we found out we weren't right for each other ahead of time.

Joseph Corlett, LLC A very good point. I wonder what the company that snookers1999 dealt with says to people when they're asked about the bad review. I'm sure they just explain it away somehow. Really unfair. :(

They did a standard square edge. The mitered edge cost more. My kitchen company suggested I do that one because with mitered edge i would not have warranty because it chips easily.

It only chips easily if you don't pick a more rounded edge profile. Mitering or stacking has nothing to do with chipping.