Option 1: Just paint the bump out/Subway tile and Marble threshold.

Option 2: Bullnose/subway tile and marble threshold.

Option 3: Bullnose stopping at subway tile/marble threshold

Any other suggestions?

p.s. The construction can not change at this point, so although I appreciate your input, please comment only on the dilemma. Thank you!

Thank you for your response! I am doing 1x6 wood baseboard thought the rest of the room. Do you think I should add bullnose to the area I show in green? Are you saying the front face of the curb should be carrara going all the way to the wall? The other option is to remove the tile that is on the inside part of the shower and do bullnose there. This is the room layout. (The only change is I removed the front facing knee wall.

Thank you for your response! I am doing 1x6 wood baseboard thought the rest of the room. Do you think I should add bullnose to the area I show in green? Are you saying the front face of the curb should be carrara going all the way to the wall? The other option is to remove the tile that is on the inside part of the shower and do bullnose there. This is the room layout. (The only change is I removed the front facing knee wall.

{{gwi:2133835}}

This is my vanity:

I'm a little confused. If the bullnose isn't already installed, how will you be able to install it? - it doesn't seem like there is enough room.

I apologize for the confusion. There is 2" of space on the outside wall of the bump out. You can see that area in the first photo I posted and I colored it in green. That is the area I'm considering adding a 2" piece of bullnose to. I could also leave it as it. The challenge is that we are ending the tile in the other side above the knee wall with bullnose.

What kind of waterproofing system did you use on your walls? Imo, the shower floor and curb should have been prepared before you started the final tiling of the walls. I think your biggest problem is might be that you started tiling before you were ready to tile. All these things you are asking really have to be decided before you lay down your first tile and not "on the fly".

I would do the bullnose on the outside of the bump-out.

I would do a piece of marble or solid surface. No bullnose.

I'm sorry that you feel that you have no options but to accept the job that you've been given. You DO have options. If you want to exercise them.

Thank you Green.

Initially my contractor told me he could fix it (meaning put the support behind the wall) for a fee. I will be traveling to my house this weekend. I told my contractor to hold off on doing anything else to the shower until we arrive. I need to see it in person to decide if the bump out bothers me as much in person as it does in pictures.

I think the bump out looks nice and the 2" bull nose would be perfect on its front side.

You know, if you post something ANYTHING on the internet, you should be prepared for all the comments you get. After all, you are asking for opinions and suggestions...from the world at large. Hollysprings is trying to tell you that you have some problems with what you a showing in your photos. A polite "thank you" would be better than your nasty reply. Rethink this one, mountgal.

-Babka

#3 looks the most "visually logical" to me, for what it's worth. (I don't think the bump out looks terrible, either, but I guess I'm missing some back story?)

I often see John Bridges forum recommended for tile issues since it's a forum for professionals. I'd ask there.

I don't know the backstory either, but I kinda think the bump-out is a little more appropriate for a vintage style bathroom. Flat and "unframed" would be too modern.

I think all your choices are close and that's probably why it's hard. I like #3 best, especially if you can get the pink and green to line up correctly.