GE Counter-Depth French Door Fridge is broken after 2 months!!!

9 years ago

We purchased a GE Counter-Depth refrigerator in 2014. It arrived with a large dent in the front door, and with the freezer door handle broken on the left side. We received a replacement refrigerator a couple of weeks later - a brand new model at the time: PYE22PSHSS.

We had it professionally installed and life was good. My portable thermometer read temperatures that were within 1 degree of the setting at several different points in the refrigerator cavity. All good.

Around week #8, the items on the top shelf started to freeze. Re-arranged things a bit, and the next day all items were back to un-thawed. However the thermometer showed a 3 degree difference between top and bottom shelves. "Weird", I thought, "but maybe it will go away".

Around week #9, the frozen top shelf returned. The following day, the middle shelf froze, and then the bottom shelf, produce and cheese drawers on the third day. Re-arranged the items a little and increased the setting by 1 degree, and it went back to un-frozen.

It went back to having a 3 degree gradient, with the top shelf roughly in line with the setting and the bottom a bit warmer.

This "normal operation" lasted two more weeks. And then one morning we woke up to find a 57F degree fridge. Re-arranged, emptied it out, reset the breaker: nothing worked. Stayed 57F all day.

We called GE and they said they could send somebody in 7 weeks. My wife yelled very considerably at the person on the phone and her supervisor and his supervisor. They told her to call the local Sears, as they may be able to have somebody come sooner. She called Sears and said they couldn't help her, as they don't know how to bill GE Warranty Services to get paid since we didn't buy this there.

She called back to GE and they said she had to wait 7 weeks, and they asked her to buy a few bags of ice while awaiting repair. She said "it's 57 degrees, the ice will melt and leak onto the wood floors - I'll have to change the ice regularly. Would you do that at your house for seven weeks?". "Oh, maybe you're right" the (fourth) GE person told her. Unfortunately, a better response wasn't on his cheat sheet so we went back to "we can get somebody out there in 7 weeks".

Again with the supervisor, the manager and a little more colorful language. They were able to schedule a repair for two weeks from now.

Everybody was very apologetic and sympathetic, but nobody could speed the repair process. At least we are down to a two week wait now.

Frankly we didn't call for a shoulder to cry on or a sympathetic friend - we simply want a working refrigerator. Hence we are very frustrated and displeased with the pace and complexity in the process.

So we are using our 35 year old (also GE by the way) refrigerator in the garage for now.

Very annoying that such a new product would stop functioning so quickly, and also dissatisfying that the warranty service is not prompt. We will see what happens next.

Overall, I sure-as-heck wish we didn't buy a GE refrigerator.

Now we know better, but too late, GE already got our money.

Hopefully you learn not to give GE yours.

This post was edited by daburd on Mon, Jan 26, 15 at 13:33

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (5)

dodge59
9 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago
Wow, 7 weeks!!!!!

Fortunately, I don't anticipate buying anymore appliances in my lifetime, but if I did, my first call would be to the company saying I needed a repair on the appliance I was thinking about buying. I would tell them I bought it a few months ago, and I need it fixed ASAP.

Most likely I would be queried about the serial number, where I bought it etc, but I would tell them, I will get that all in a minute, just answer a simple question, "When can you get somebody here to fix it"

The other way is to Goggle the fridge model number + reviews, and you might "get lucky" and find some worth while info regarding reliability and service, but I think the first way I described is a "safer bet"!

Of course , posts like yours, alerts us all to be vigilant, sooo
Thanks for your post!!!!

I wonder if the Electrolux buyout of GE is causing some "Loose ends"?

Gary
hvtech42
9 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago
Sorry to hear about your issues. I have had the standard depth version of that refrigerator for 3 years now and no problems yet. Thanks for warning us about GE service. Mine is out of warranty now (except for the sealed system) so if it ever breaks down I will be sure not to call GE and instead do it myself or hire a local repairman.
Related Discussions
Need opinions/suggestions for french door counter depth fridge
Q
Comments (4)
Hi there - I could have written this request!! Thanks for posting it...I joined Consumer Reports for the month because of all the purchases we'll be making, and I also was looking at the KitchenAid fridge. After looking at the reviews, I'm shying away from that choice. Now, we're looking at Samsung...and I'm also thinking of Bosch, though it has ice/water in the door which I don't really want. Another possibility is the GE Profile 23 cf, though it won't be available until August.
...See More
Counter-Depth French Door Fridge? Electrolux, Kitchen Aid, other?
Q
Comments (10)
The first version of my new kitchen layout needed a CD FD fridge. After much research, I had decided on the KA pro. Now, my layout has changed to being better with a single door bottom-freezer. I chose the KA again. It's sitting in my garage right now awaiting install next month so I can't give it a review. KA is well-regarded here. During my research, my trusted family friend/appliance salesperson told me she does not recommend Elux appliances because of reliability issues. I was planning on the Elux non-icon ovens despite her advice. She said whatever I do, don't buy one of their fridges. Hard to know as many here like their Elux fridges.
...See More
42' counter depth vs 36' standard french door fridge
Q
Comments (19)
I have what KristianCO has, but without the wine slots in between. At least at the time, that required ordering a panel that goes between them -- an insulation panel, I think? She mentioned the ice -- another reason I liked the Thermador over the SZ. The SZ had the ice down at the bottom, nearly on the floor. That just doesn't work for all the ice we can use here in Texas. Fori, it's not having a second fridge to make up for the failures of the first one. People who spend $3 million on a house as well as the guest who walk into one expect a certain lifestyle to go with it. Even if they don't cook, they probably entertain. If they don't entertain, they want to look like they do -- or at least they could. In my area, people look for a space for a second fridge in homes by the time they hit $250-350K. By $1 mil, they expect a second fridge regardless of how big the one in the main kitchen is. Beverage fridge somewhere in the house or in an outdoor kitchen is probably also desired if not expected. I've seen homes below $1 mil (at the time) that had built-in fridge, second fridge space in the utility, a wine fridge and a small beverage fridge in the master suite. Those homes are probably between $1 mil and $2 mil now, but they give a clue what folks look for when they reach a certain price point. Yes, you can design for change and tear out a pantry, assuming you also left the upper clearance, and maybe it won't make a mess of flooring and cabinets, but in a $3 mil home, I don't think you are going to save a lot of money in the long run. First, you have to plan the layout to include a tall pantry and cabinet above the fridge that would be lost or have a 12" or greater opening and dress that off. That would all be lost when changing the fridge and you could have the cost of cutting down the above fridge cabinet and doors or a new cabinet. All the crown on that wall will probably need to be removed to change the upper cabinet. Your toe kicks will have to be removed and adjusted. Not a big deal, but another detail. And if any of these trim pieces split when being removed, you have to match trim and finish. This won't break the bank for anyone living in a $3 mill plus home, but it is enough that you can see the savings may be negligible or non-existent. Not to mention that after suffering through an entire build out, the last thing you will want to do is any reno any time in the reasonably foreseeable future. Most folks are exhausted well before the build is done. Ok to do it - but be honest with yourself about the cost, especially if you are not a DIYer.
...See More
Reliable 36" counter-depth French door fridge.
Q
Comments (4)
In the category you're describing (flush counter-depth, tall), have you looked at the Thermador? We have the 30" and its been excellent so far (just two months). The one downside (and it's significant, but I don't know how it compares to the others) is that the produce drawer is WAY too small (too shallow top to bottom - you can't possibly fit a head of lettuce in it).
...See More
daburd
Original Author
9 years ago
UPDATE: The GE repairman arrived and advised that the motor was broken. Again - only a couple months old. He ordered a new motor and returned a week later to install it. There is a 2 to 3 degree gradient between the top and bottom shelf, but the refrigerator is now basically functional.

Note: this is a "brand new" GE model which they started manufacturing in the Summer of 2014.

The repairman mentioned that he's already had to repair a few "no cool" refrigerators of the same model as ours - a model which has only been available for about 6 months so far.

Overall: poor reliability (based on my experience and the repairman's anecdotes) and very slow and frustrating customer service. Avoid GE refrigerators!
hvtech42
9 years ago
Yes, this particular model number came out in 2014 but what really matters is the underlying design. Often they'll make minor aesthetic/interior improvements from year to year and change the model number. My fridge is the same basic design as this one.

I've talked to repairmen who've had to repair multiple of the same Whirlpool, Frigidaire, GE, Samsung, LG, etc. fridges for no cooling. This repairman's anecdotes, especially given that he works for GE and only sees their appliances, don't really say anything about its reliability compared to the competition.

This experience certainly was terrible and I'm not trying to excuse that... just trying to convey to future readers that avoiding one particular brand won't really make you less likely to run into a situation like this. None of them are made like they used to, and there are instances of crappy service with all of them. The only way to statistically improve your chances of getting a good fridge is to buy a very basic, no-frills top mount with mechanical controls, and the only way to improve your chances of excellent customer service are to buy a SubZero.
nanj
9 years ago
I subscribe to a newsletter from Yale Appliance and in the article I've linked they report that 25% of all new appliances need service in the first year, regardless of the brand. Yale sells from the moderate priced to the very expensive and have their own service division so know of what they speak. Based on this, I am to the point of choosing appliances based on criteria other than reliability. And realizing the need to have access to service in the rural area where we will build.

Yale Appliance Blog

GE Counter-Depth French Door Fridge is broken after 2 months!!!

Comments (5)

dodge59

hvtech42

Related Discussions

daburd
Original Author

hvtech42

nanj

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

GE Counter-Depth French Door Fridge is broken after 2 months!!!

Comments (5)

dodge59

hvtech42

Related Discussions

daburdOriginal Author

hvtech42

nanj

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

daburd
Original Author