Houzz Logo Print
friedag

The Importance of a Good Title

20 years ago

A few years ago here at RP, I started a thread about this subject and got a lot of suggestions for the greatest book titles of all time. I though I saved the thread; but apparently not, so I'm repeating in hopes of spurring my memory. And other equally great titles not mentioned previously will come up, I'm sure.

I do recall that Gone with the Wind is a much-admired title -- even those who don't particularly like the story are usually willing to admit that the title was an inspired choice. Yeah, "a rose by any other name would smell as sweet" and "manure is manure even if it's called 'ambrosia'"...but is that really true? I highly suspect that many readers are very susceptible to titles they like, or equally put off by those they dislike, for whatever reason, even before they know something about those books' contents. A personal example: I like The Unbearable Lightness of Being, and as many of you already know, I played around with that title to name one of my recent threads. It so happens that I didn't like Kundera's story very much at all, but oooh! that title.

On the flip side, there are wonderfully written books that were given atrocious titles or -- perhaps, even worse --uninteresting, forgettable titles that have probably sunk them into obscurity, if not oblivion. Occasionally, though, really good stories will overcome wan titles, so much so, in fact, that we may forget that the title-givers weren't very imaginative. Sometimes, books are renamed (this used to be more common than it is nowadays), and different titles prevail in different countries -- Smilla's Sense of Snow (US title) is Miss Smilla's Feeling for Snow in other English-language translations. It seems (to me, anyway) that the title first heard or read (thus, most familiar) will remain the favorite of that reader, usually.

Anyway, I hope you all will indulge me and give your opinions on any of these: Great Titles, Bad Titles, Easily-Forgotten Titles, Differing Titles of the Same Book, etc. Lists are okay; but if you can discuss your choices, please do!

One last question that you can answer "yes" or "no": Have you deliberately not read a book because you couldn't stand the title? Of course, if you want to expand and give examples, I would love to read everything you have to say!

Comments (57)