Overhang, counter hanging over, undermount sink -- yes/no?

16 years ago

Q: Let a Silestone counter extend over (and cover) a portion of the sink.

Good / No good ?

Goal is two fold: one, to reduce the apparent size of the hole, without losing anything

in terms of the ability to get large items into the sink.

Related goal, to give more counter space in a 60 sq.ft. kitchen.

I'll get a large deep Silgranit or Swanstone sink (e.g. Blanco Cascade, Franke Orca, Swanstone Ascend)

it is possible to cut a huge opening in the countertop while still covering a portion of the sink.

Today I have 16x17 and I find it OK but a bit small at times. In the Cascade

the large bowl is 22x17 so I'd be happy if the counter overhung by two inches.

As for the esthetics (shape to give to the hole cut in the counter), I believe I can produce a design

that works well and is_even_a_bit_custom so that adds value to the average discerning homeowner or buyer.

As for how to handle the shadows and light I believe I can manage that too, and

I'll be glad to post photos of my finished work later.

2. another Q:

--Why do counters always stop short of the undermount sink sides?

I have seen many photos. The counter never goes far enough to line up

to match the edge of the vertical sides. Personally I see no reason to stop

short and display a bit of the top surface of an undermount sink.

3. It seems to me that it would also be possible to router an edge in a solid surface

material so as to hold cutting boards sunken in to match counter depth.

-- Let that be third question... Why is this never done ?

-- David

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (4)

lightlystarched
16 years ago
For me, I would not like a counter that significantly overhung the sides of the sink. Every time you remove something from the sink, you'd have to be sure to pull it in and out so as to not bang into the overhang. I have a bad enough habit of hitting the faucet with dishes and glasses, adding another hazzard would mean I'd have to get rubber dishes. Also, cleaning the sink would be harder as you'd have to scrub under the rim, and that sort of makes me think of a toilet =(

Just my $.02.
0
neesie
16 years ago
I asked my fabricator to give me a flush reveal, I didn't see the advantage of a positive reveal (where the counter doesn't go far enough to line up to the top of the sink) and personally I didn't want the negative reveal either. I believe that stuff would still be underneath, like a toilet bowl, even though you can't see it.

My sink hole was cut out of the granite countertop on site (meaning in my kitchen). It took a worker nearly 3 hours to work with the granite to get it "flush" but he did a wonderful job. I have a blanco Silgranit 1 3/4 bowl. I also purchased a custom cutting board that sits over the sink but it is not sunken to match the counter depth. LOVE IT!
0
Related Discussions
leaking undermount sink (silestone countertop)
Q
Comments (20)
Well, I stand corrected on the mold issue. I just did some quick research and found the article below. Based on that info, I'd inform the installation company to bring new pieces of wood for the install. For the mold on the inside of the cabinet you'll need to find something to kill the mold. Earlier you said "I called HD; They said it is not my responsibility to get a plumber, and they would talk to the installer." If the leak wasn't caused by anything the plumber did, and it does look like it's due to little or no caulk around your sink, then I'd hold them responsible for paying the plumber. Besides that, hiring the plumber again was also due to the fact that they scratched your countertop! Did they say anything after the initial installation about the need for someone to caulk around the sink, or did they say they caulked it? It appear the reason they're not using the clips is because there nothing to clip too. There's no overhanging plywood on the front and sides of the cutout to attach the clips to. That looks like a huge cutout, but I've also made similar cutouts in cabinets that were a little small for the sink we wanted to use. BTW, my kitchen sink doesn't have clips either. It's held up by plywood and 1x4's on three sides and a narrower strip on the back edge to allow for the faucet. Before they show up for the install, make sure the cabinets are to your liking and confirm that they'll bring the new wood. Here is a link that might be useful: mold
...See More
Acrylic undermount sink with laminate countertop?
Q
Comments (11)
Nolamom, sorry for the late reply. I hadn't checked this thread for a while. We used a Corian Counter-Seal ring. The KD says something seemed to have changed in the adhesive Corian tells the fabricators to use, as during a 2 year period about 5 failures like ours happened (2007-late 2008). The fabricators swore they were using the approved stuff and were certified, so it wasn't their fault. The Counter-Seal people said it was past the 1 year warranty, so it wasn't their problem. The KD quit selling the undermount rings as he couldn't afford to cover more new counters for replacements. I just saw some ads for a new overmount sink that has a very flat thin lip, so it seems to almost look and work like an undermount sink. Here's the info--it's from an article on CNET. "How about an easy-(and inexpensive) to-install overmount sink that gives you the look of a flushmount? That's what you get with MicroEdge, the latest offering from Blanco. It's an ultrafine rim--1.25 mm--that installs over virtually any counter material for a precision, near seamless edge. The sink isn't cheap--you'll spend around $600--but the install is standard enough that you can do it yourself or hire someone to do it for you for far less than a flush or undermount." I'm was actually glad I didn't see these sinks before we ordered the granite, as I might have given in to my DH's desire to just replace the sink section of the laminate and do an overmount sink this time. If granite/quartz isn't an option, these new sinks might be workable for OP. Good luck!
...See More
question about silicone seal between counter and undermount sink
Q
Comments (10)
Thanks, all, for these messages. I think the grout is epoxy, as stoneonecorp guessed, because he mixed multiple small batches and worked very quickly, and I didn't see anything sand/cement-y involved. And I'm glad to hear that non-experts can redo that caulk sink seal with no apparent trauma. I was surprised when he told me that *I* should caulk over his grout seal. This is a guy who was recommended *very* highly by a lot of people: I called every single person on his references list and asked a lot of very critical questions. No one, not a single person, said, "he expected us to finish up the job; he told us to caulk our own counters." ISn't that part of the installation? Anyway, I think I know the answer to that. And given that he whined when we asked him to come back and re-seal the sink (which he messed up the second time as well as the first time -- all the while complaining that no other homeowner had ever asked him to do this, and that the sink is not his responsibility), I don't want him back in my house, because I think he's a jerk. So: sounds like I should recaulk the sink seal and caulk over the grout he laid. Yes? I'm going to use clear silicone and masking tape, so it looks nice. Any other tips, advice, cautions? Pamkcs, did you just rip the old sealant out with a screwdriver and clean what was behind it? As before, thanks in advance!
...See More
undermount Sink into 33" cabinet (yes another one) sorry
Q
Comments (8)
I bet Joseph Corlett will know for sure, and hopefully he will respond. But, to my eye, I don't see any reason you can't trim. It looks like the strips are there to stabilize the box and they will still do that if trimmed to allow the bowl to fit. In fact, if the bowl is fitting against the strips, won't that give additional lateral stability? Also, I would like to hear if anyone has ever HAD to remove and replace a good quality sink. I don't mean, taste changed and wanted something different. Or installation was sub par so everything had to be re-done. I have seen many posts over the past 4 years that attested that having the flanges overlap the cabinet sides was just fine. In this case they would overlap only the strips but still, would clips then even be needed?
...See More
Related Professionals
East Peoria Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Portland Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Boca Raton Kitchen & Bathroom Remodelers · Gilbert Kitchen & Bathroom Remodelers · Payson Kitchen & Bathroom Remodelers · Schiller Park Kitchen & Bathroom Remodelers · Spokane Kitchen & Bathroom Remodelers · Waukegan Kitchen & Bathroom Remodelers · Phillipsburg Kitchen & Bathroom Remodelers · Key Biscayne Cabinets & Cabinetry · National City Cabinets & Cabinetry · Parsippany Cabinets & Cabinetry · Phelan Cabinets & Cabinetry · Edwards Tile and Stone Contractors · South Holland Tile and Stone Contractors
davidro1
Original Author
16 years ago
OK, three sides flush reveal, one side negative reveal (overhang) that would be the non-visible side, and with a stainless steel bar underneath the silestone so as to avoid making it feel like a toilet rim.

-dr
0
sue_ct
16 years ago
I went with a flush reveal also, and like it. I think that much of an overhang would be a disaster with breaking things hitting it, also. I am not sure what you would gain with a stainless steel bar under the overhang, wouldn't there be the same rim type effect under the bar? I do place my sink colander directly on my quartz countertop because I don't have the sink reveal to put it down into the sink and it works fine. No routing needed with mine. If you really want the larger bowl without losing counter space, consider an insert that will fit over the sink or half of the sink made of matching silestone or bumping out the sink a bit to get a sink that is larger front to back instead of side to side, and go with a deeper sink so you can fit more in without using up counter space. The Franke sinks with grids that fit half way up the sink let you use the grids as shelves and use the sink for more working space and still keep them out of the water or whatever else is in the bottom of the sink. Consider a negative reveal with some sink showing or a routed out area of the surrounding counter fit with custom cutting board that that will cover half or all of the sink and allow you to use the area as a counter top when you don't need the sink.

Sue
0

Overhang, counter hanging over, undermount sink -- yes/no?

Comments (4)

lightlystarched

neesie

Related Discussions

Related Professionals

davidro1
Original Author

sue_ct

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Overhang, counter hanging over, undermount sink -- yes/no?

Comments (4)

lightlystarched

neesie

Related Discussions

Related Professionals

davidro1Original Author

sue_ct

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

davidro1
Original Author