refinishing an old piano

17 years ago

Hi

We just received as a gift an old (c.50 years) upright piano from my mother in law. I cannot tell what kind of wood it is (it's not walnut, pine or oak, I can tell that much), but is is stained, not painted. Also, its wood - not plastic, but does have some veneers. Maybe mahogany?

The piano is a very small upright and I doubt it was an expensive, high end model even when new.

It's varnished with many scratches and scores, but none of the peeling or bubbling sometimes seen on older varnished pieces. Some panels/sections/pieces are stained darker than others for a decorative contrast.

I want to do a quick and easy re-finish job. I have fairly low expectations and do not expect to make it look like new. Also, if some or even most of the scratches remain visible, so be it.

I was thinking I would:

1- clean well, removing all old dust, dirt, oils and grease.

2- do a very light sanding job all over

3- pay special attention sanding and smoothing to any chipped corners/edges

4- one or two coats of a stain seeking to match the original color, going a little lighter if need be, not a little darker

5- top it off with a coat or two of varnish.

I don't think I need to worry about the acoustical qualities of the finish. The piano is for our children to learn on and play at home, not for the audience at Carnegie hall. (Of course, if there is something that I must avoid at all costs or else it will devastate the sound of the piano, please warn me!)

I have never re-finsihed anything and do not have a lot of time to do this project. Ideally, not counting time waiting for coats to dry, it should not take more than 5 hours.

Q: How does my plan sound, in general?

Q: Do I need to remove/strip ALL of the old varnish before I re-stain? Candidly, I don't have the space, time or resources to use a furntiure stripper.

Q: Are there any adequate finishes that combine a stain and a varnish in one?

Q: is there a simpler way - such as a high gloss wax/polish that could simple be wiped on, buffed and polished?

Thanks!

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (6)

Jon1270
17 years ago
You certainly could wax the thing to restore the shine, though wax is heat and moisture sensitive so it's not great for surfaces that get touched alot. Do the scratches go all the way through the top coat and the stained wood to reveal a line of lighter-colored,unstained wood underneath?

Mahogany does sound likely, but I'm skeptical that the topcoat is varnish. I'm not a piano expert, but my guess is that it would've been finished like a piece of furniture, probably with lacquer. If you want to repair the existing finish then you'll need to figure out what sort of finish it is. Shellac (a possibility but, I'd think, unlikely) and lacquer are both fairly easy to identify because they will redissolve in their original solvents. If alcohol (solvent alcohol from the hardware store, not rubbing alcohol) dissolves it then it's shellac. If lacquer thinner softens it, then it's lacquer. (lacquer thinner will also dissolve shellac, but alcohol will not immediately soften lacquer, so do the alchohol check first.) If neither alchohol nor lacquer thinner immediately affect it, then it's probably varnish.

Generally, I'm hoping the damage is just light surface scratches you can deal with by buffing or waxing or other minimalist approaches. Repairing lots of deep scratches that go all the way through the film or, worse, all the way through the stain too, would not be a 5-hour project even if you had done it before.
lindac
17 years ago
Quick and dirty??
Get a can of mineral spirits ( paint thinner) and with good ventilation, wipe the piano all over ( not the keys!) until the rag or paper towel you use doesn't show any more dirt. This will remove all greasey and oily dirt.
Let it dry and wipe all over with a solvent based ( as opposed to water based) stain in the color you like. I would choose a color as close to what is there as possible. Repeat the stain if needed.
Linda C
Related Discussions
old piano - taking out insides??
Q
Comments (13)
mycompost - please don't feel guilty! Actually, most pianists will acknowledge that square grands are pretty much worthless - they are so old that most of them are beyond repair, and even the ones that still work don't have a very good sound or action. They were actually designed more for their shape and furniture value, with less emphasis placed on the musical capability. And today, any value they have is as decorative furniture (most have beautiful cabinets), not as a musical instrument. I belong to an online forum for piano fanatics and when people post looking for the value of their old pianos (square grand or old upright) they are almost always told that they're not worth the gas it would cost you to haul it away. Old regular-style grands are sometimes worth restoring, but it is not worth the investment (often in the tens of thousands of dollars!) to restore an old upright or square grand. The forum has a nickname for all these worthless old pianos - "landfill piano". So you actually did a good thing by keeping your piano out of the landfill! I would love to see a picture if you have one. Oh, and if anyone is really interested, there are a few books (The Piano Book by Larry Fine comes to mind) that show an overview of all the parts in the piano and how they work together. Piano Repair and Rebuilding by Arthur Reblitz is a little more technical, but may have more detail about how to get the parts out.
...See More
question about old upright piano... is the sound board
Q
Comments (13)
Have an old Lester "player" piano... original company in Delaware County, PA... just south of Philly. Dad bought it when we were kids/teens... I'm sure he spent VERY little for it. Was never in tune or tuned. Never had the "guts" to play or the piece that would have gone across that section to hide it. Has little sliding door that covers pedals. Many of the white keys (thinking they're probably IVORY??) are chipped. Bet I spent 10 times what he paid for it to have it hauled to NJ when clearing out his house. It's a BEAST! Has been painted a few times. Now it sits with my "stereo" stuff on top and 2 relatively inexpensive speakers inside the box... they sound like a million bucks coming outta that solid wood box. One of these days, when I have enough participants, would like to deconstruct it!?! Metal (brass??) plate in back... where all the wires connect... appears to run all the way to the floor? Figure next time nephew is in the area, all I'll have to do is say it can't be done... and it'll get DONE!?!
...See More
refinishing a piano
Q
Comments (4)
I'm in the last stages of refinishing an oak student desk. I first tried gel stain because it sounded simple and gets such rave reviews, esp. for going really dark on cabinets and vanities. In my case it was a disaster. I won't bore you with details, but the whole thing had to come off and the next thing I knew I was down to bare wood. I then used an oil-based stain and my faith in all that's right and good was restored. I'm now nearly finished with my top coats. Photos will ensue. My point is, a bathroom vanity and a piano are different. My experience with gel stain was full of regret (and a lot of swearing). A cheapo student desk and a piano are worlds apart. All the products I used are from General Finishes. Their oil-based stain was a dream to work with. After the gel stain fiasco I called their 800 customer support number and talked to a guy who was very helpful. You might give them a call, describe your project, and ask for their recommendations. Good luck. Despite my initial setback, I have so enjoyed refinishing my desk.
...See More
Disassembling an old upright piano
Q
Comments (1)
Hi, remove the action, it is held in with a few screws at the tops of the metal brackets. The screws usually have large knurled heads and are turned by hand after loosening with a screwdriver. The strings need to be cut out one at a time, after first taking off the tension with a tuning hammer with the appropriately-sized socket/head. There is something like 35k lbs. of string tension in an upright piano. Be careful, as strings can snap (explosively) while loosening. Cut the strings out with wire cutters and dispose of one by one, or you'll have quite a tangle of strings. The cut ends will be very sharp, leather gloves and goggles are a must. The iron frame is very well secured to the wood frame with huge wood screws. Once the iron frame is loose, it can be broken to pieces with a sledgehammer for easier removal. Removing the keys and trapwork is fairly simple. The best wood would be the heavy maple posts of the frame, and maybe the decorative work holding up the key cheeks. The rest is veneer over a substrate of inferior lumber. On better pianos, the case will have a lot of visible screws to remove, and still need some mallet blows to break the old hot glue joints. Inferior pianos may have early assembly screws veneered over so you may never find them. At any stage, you can wreck the veneer while breaking the glue's bond. Hot vinegar/water can be flowed into a joint to dissolve the glue, but too much exposure will also dissolve the veneer's glue, so it's risky both ways. Be really careful with the string removal. Casey
...See More
dainaadele
17 years ago
Don't worry about damaging the sound of the piano. So long as you leave the soundboard alone everything will be fine. The soundboard is the wood board behind the piano. (The side that will probably be to the wall.) I did a similar things to my first piano.

When I bought for $200,the piano legs had been replaced at one time and the bench did not match either. In my case I had the time to strip off the original finish. I put the darkest stain I coud find, several times, and then poly for at least 3 coats. By the time I was done you could not see that the wood no longer matched. I hate to say it, but 5 years later I sold it to our postman for $700. It looked that much better! He thought he was getting a deal! Grin.
dgmarie
17 years ago
Use Old English Dark Wood polish and scratch cover. I used this on my furniture and kitchen cabinets and it WORKS MIRACLES. I am in Luv with it. I would try it in a heart beat and I bet you'll like. It costs all of $4.50! Forget the sanding and staining. You'll be biting off more than you want to chew.
kmealy
17 years ago
Here is an article that may help:
http://www.homesteadfinishing.com/htdocs/savingfinish.htm

Here is a link that might be useful: Saving the Finish
sombreuil_mongrel
17 years ago
Hi,
I liked the saving the finish article, except that 220 grit is way too abrasive (IMO) for anyone who hasn't done this before; IOW, it will be entirely too easy to sand thru sharp corners and remove the stain underneath, not just the finish. I start with 800 grit wet/dry abrasive, lubricated with water+Dawn detergent. This gets off the worst alligatoring. I proceed up thru 2000 grit, at which point new shellac can be padded on, and the piece waxed, as described in the article.
Thanks.
Casey

refinishing an old piano

Comments (6)

Jon1270

lindac

Related Discussions

dainaadele

dgmarie

kmealy

sombreuil_mongrel

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US