skip to main content

Replacement Windows in a 150-year-old house?

11 years ago

We live in the Northeast and have been toying with replacing the 150+ year old windows in this house for years. It's an old home with lovely details/charm, but not on any historic registry so we don't have any confines in that sense. I will miss the wavy glass and wood frames, but not the chipping paint, four dirty surfaces (window and storms) that are impossible to clean, and the wood pieces I have to prop in the windows to keep them open--the ones that aren't painted shut, anyway! With three little kids, this is the kind of "charm" that's quite frustrating!!

There are 39 windows to replace, so we don't want to go any higher than $350-400 if possible per window. Suggestions on brand? We have wood now but would prefer something with less upkeep--vinyl?

(I LOVE gardenweb and designed/rennovated my entire kitchen with advice from these forums, but I do realize that the general advice tends to be very high-end/costly--hoping to stick to a reasonable budget on this one...)

Thanks so much for any suggestions and help...these forums are so helpful!!

Sarah from Albany

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (7)

PRO
Windows on Washington Ltd
11 years ago
You are going to have to deal with the expense of an RRP (i.e Lead Paint) removal.

You will not even approach (i.e. in the same stratosphere) the $400 number on a quality wood window, installed price.

If you like the character of the windows, look into a good painter and a good storm window.

Tearing out historic wood windows when a storm window combination might work, to put in a cheap vinyl replacement is not advisable.
millworkman
11 years ago
Is that $350-400 including installation? If it is unfortunately what you would end up with will not bring much at all in a quality product, and in the long run cost you more in replacing them inside of 10 years.
Related Discussions
Help--neighbor cut down 150 year old Big Leaf maple
Q
Comments (6)
If you can drop the native restriction and provide water in summer one of your best bets would probably be Fargesia bamboos. These can be quite nice, grow in shade and won't take 20 years to size up. If instead the natives only restriction is set in concrete then about the only choice you have is Thuja plicata. Local shady woods with vegetation containing species such as those you have listed as being existing have no bushy, attractive native evergreen species of more than shrub height other than this conifer - it is the only kind that looks like it would lend itself to serious screening of views. Where salal is present evergreen huckle-berry may certainly also be possible - these two often grow together in the wild, on those occasions when the Vaccinium is present at all - but unless stimulated with liberal watering, this latter, like other heaths including the salal can be quite slow- and rather small-growing, prone to weevil attacks beneath overhanging trees and so on. And lack density in heavy shade, as do most trees and shrubs. Finally it is often the case that when people ask for quick 15 ft. tall plantings to block something next door they are thinking in terms of this screening being over near where the source of the unwanted view is, want therefore such height. But they may not in fact be using that part of the property most of those times when they are wanting there to be a visual barrier present. So that installing a source of relief near where they are looking from instead, well inside their property would be more efficient - and perhaps even immediately effective, if an architectural feature or modification is used.
...See More
venting second floor bath in 3 story 150 year old stone home
Q
Comments (1)
Does the bath have an exterior wall? If so you can duct right out the wall. Yes, it means cutting through the stucco and stone, but a good contractor can easily do that.
...See More
Progress on our 150+ year old small-town home
Q
Comments (31)
Teacher always said, 'Show your work.' Here's those two houses. Kind of interesting for me: the Peoria house is on what used to be called 'High Wines Road,' where the Peoria whiskey distillers all lived, which is why the district is crowded with beautiful old homes like this. I look forward to seeing your pictures. The house in Peoria, via Google maps. The house in Muskegon, via Google Maps.
...See More
Looking to replace 50 year old aluminum windows with vinyl.
Q
Comments (2)
As a general observation, the aluminum window will have a smaller frame profile and you will have more glass in that window than a replacement. That is a general observation though. There are instances where the proper replacement will clean up the opening size and give you at least the same amount of glass and perhaps more. All depends on what is coming out and going back in, but your window contractor should be able to discuss that factor with you.
...See More
brickeyee
11 years ago
I would never remove 150 year old windows.

Nothing you can get now is as good.
EcoStarRemodel
11 years ago
+1. I would look at storm windows with LoE glass and additional insulation around the windows. The cost of lead paint containment alone is going to be around $100 per window so that only leaves you $250-$300 including labor. It can be done but you would be putting a very cheap quality window in that is likely worse than what you have now.

If your home has poor attic and wall insulation, I would look more towards improving on that than I would about windows. Have you had an energy audit done? If not, that's where I would start.
sarahandbray
Original Author
11 years ago
OK, just switched up my post and opened a new thread (plus, changed my math--1871 to 2012 doesn't quite hit 150+, but close!)
Looking for advice on contractors that might do this repair. We have so many other projects going on and barely time for our kids as it is--can't imagine taking on another DIY project like repairing the windows.
(never counted # of windows before--41 plus 5 on basement! Ugh!)

Thanks for all the advice :)
Sarah
jmc01
11 years ago
See my post on your other thread.
sarahandbray
Original Author
11 years ago
Did not click--thanks for the warning. Have since switched to getting new replacement storm windows--just couldn't get rid of the windows, and from what I've read, they are actually in pretty decent shape, given the age.
Thanks again for the responses!
Sarah

Related Stories

HOUZZ TOURS My Houzz: An Artistic Life Fills a 150-Year-Old Home

By Esther Hershcovich

A gorgeous courtyard, eclectic style and original details shine in a Paris-born artist's beachside rental

BASEMENTS Room of the Day: Swank Basement Redo for a 100-Year-Old Row House

By Annie Thornton

A downtown Knoxville basement goes from low-ceilinged cave to welcoming guest retreat

FURNITURE Old Furniture: Clean, Reupholster or Replace It?

By Becky Dietrich, Interior Designer

A veteran upholstery cleaner weighs in on the options for found, inherited and thrift store furniture

MODERN HOMES Houzz Tour: 800-Year-Old Walls, Modern Interiors in Provence

By Vanessa Brunner

Old architecture and new additions mix beautifully in a luxurious renovated vacation home

HOUZZ TOURS Houzz Tour: A 300-Year-Old Home Adapts to a Modern Family of 7

By Karen Egly-Thompson

A new addition adds much-needed square footage to a 1750s home in Massachusetts

Replace Your Windows and Save Money — a How-to Guide

Reduce drafts to lower heating bills by swapping out old panes for new, in this DIY project for handy homeowners

GREAT HOME PROJECTS How to Replace Your Lawn With a Garden

By June Scott Design

New project for a new year: Lose the turfgrass for energy savings, wildlife friendliness and lower maintenance

PORCHES Room of the Day: A Colorado Porch for Year-Round Enjoyment

By Becky Harris

New windows, insulation and other upgrades turn this sun porch on a 1914 stone house into a 4-season room

REMODELING GUIDES Replace vs. Restore: The Great Window Debate

By Lindsey M. Roberts

Deciding what to do with windows in disrepair isn't easy. This insight on the pros and cons of window replacement or restoration can help

KITCHEN DESIGN Get Ideas From This Year’s Top 20 Kitchen Tours

By Becky Harris

Smart storage, functionality for cooks and families, vintage touches and lots of personality mark your favorites of 2015

Sponsored

More Discussions

Renewal By Andersen Review Window installation.

3

Choosing windows for sunroom - which size and must they match?

1

Muntins or no muntins?

23

Suggestions for an aluminum painted shut window

3

Sports-proof windows

4