boyfriend has 5 kids

17 years ago

I need advice! I've been seeing this 44 year old man for just under 5 years. He is the perfect man for me, except that he now has sole custody of 5 kids between the ages of 6 to 12 (he's divorced, she lost custody shortly after we had met five years ago). I've explained when the situation changed that I think it would be best for a few years that we maintain separate houses (we're within walking distance of each other) until his children are a little older and less needy of him. From my own experience, I didn't think it was wise to interject myself on a permanent basis (yet) into a new and already stressful situation. This close co-location was affording us balance and seemed feasible until we could look into moving in together when his kids had reached some independence. I am a 45 y.o. working single mom of one 13 y.o. girl.

Here's my dilema - this arrangement seemed quite suitable to him and so we've been doing this. Now he's met someone else who is a mother of 2 (12 & 14). Although not an assurance that she will undertake his situation, he's apparently now changed his mind about everything. Now that I am aware, I'm hurt by the betrayal, but I'm wondering too for the sake of closure: was I wrong to not move in with him and become this instant "substitute mother" to 5 that he now apparently wants? Bearing in mind that this used to be suitable to him, was it not wise to allow his kids the right to a more balanced environment until a time for us could happen? Am I wrong?

Featured Answer

colleenoz

7 years ago

I’m sorry to say, but going by the evidence of everyone else’s experience, it will not turn out well. Your BF’s kids are unlikely to have an epiphany and suddenly like you, and you will come to resent their attitude and wish you had not hitched your horse to this particular wagon and wasted years of your life in unhappiness.

You really need to consider if this is truly the life you want- remember, at the beginning of relationships, people are on their best behaviour, so the politeness will eventually fade. Do you want better? If so, move on and wait for something better. Even if you don’t find another partner you will still be happier than being with a partner whose children treat you poorly.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (7)

finedreams
17 years ago
i dated a guy once who told me isn't interested in marriage or children ever. but he said he loved me and wanted to be wiht me. Nonetheless I broke up wiht him because I wanted marriage and children. In few months he met someone else and they got married rather quickly and now have two children. My point? he was not interested in marriage or children WITH ME. but was prefectly fine wiht the other person. I just was not right for him. was i hurt? of course. But what could i do? he didn't want to marry ME or have children wiht me. In fact i was happy I didn't stay and wasted my time.

I have other examples from other people's lives.

it could be that he changed his mind because he has met someone else and she might seem more suitable partner for him. That's what usually happens.

it could also be that he got tired of just dating for 5 years and wants to live with someone. if i would date someone for 5 years wihtout formal commitment, i would probably move on on someone else too. 5 years is a long time.

it could also be that she didn't mind having that many kids while you did. Honestly I do not want to have 5 kids at home and I would not date anyone wiht that many chidlren just because it is not my cup of tea.

maybe next time you should date people with fewer children or none to eliminate the problem.

also if someone didn't want to live with me because of my daughter being too young, I wouldn't even wait 5 years and move on right away.
imamommy
17 years ago
In my opinion, you got LUCKY! L-U-C-K-Y !!!!!!!

It was suitable for him to have your companionship when it was convenient but taking care of 5 kids is a lot of work, and he was more than likely looking for an instant substitute mother for his kids and while you would have fit the bill, so does anyone that is willing apparently.

I think you should move on and be grateful you didn't put your daughter in a situation with a man that will change his mind about you because he may have a better prospect. If this prospect falls through, my suggestion is RUN RUN RUN. If he truly cared about you and a future with you, he would have discussed other options than meeting a new woman that 'might' be more suitable.
Related Discussions
Crazy to do hardwood floor with 5 kids and large dog?
Q
Comments (15)
I can speak from experience here: I share my house with a DH, toddler and a 100lb dog with paws the size of a Yeti's. In our old house we tore out all of the carpet and vinyl from the first floor and installed red oak strip flooring (I believe it was Shaw brand). It looked great for about a month and then all I could do is notice the huge gouges my dog put into the floor. He doesn't even have sharp nails, but he's 100lbs and there's only so much you can do. In the current house, we tore out all of the 22yr old carpet and put in a much harder wood species, amendoim, and I have to admit it looks fantastic and it's held up a lot better than the oak ever did. The dog put some superficial scratches in the floor but since the wood only has a clear coat and no stain, you can only notice the scratches if you're glancing at the floor at the right angle, under the right light. We had laminate in the basement of our old house and it used to drive me bonkers whenever the dog would claw to get traction on the floor and I also hated the echo the floor created, even with good padding underneath. I vowed never to put laminate flooring anywhere again, even if the dog couldn't do anything to it. Also, no matter how good technology gets, laminate always looks fake to me and I'd rather not go there. It's just never going to look as good as real wood. In the new house I wanted to put ceramic tile in the kitchen this time around but DH wouldn't hear of it. He swears he doesn't hate tile, but he just can't fine a tile in the whole wide world that he likes :) I let him win that war but I got to pretty much make every other decision with the kitchen since then. I figure we can always refinish the floors once they get to be too bad. As a previous poster said, site finished floors don't have anywhere near the same durability as factory prefinished floors so that's something to keep in mind. My DH always says that people like wood floors and never notice the scratches anyway. I guess he was right because the condition of the floors was never brought up once when we were selling the house even though I lived in fear that that was the first and only thing people would notice as they came through the house. I apologize for the stream-of-consciousness reply but I can't say my brain has been firing on all cylinders today so I hope I helped even a little :)
...See More
Boyfriend has a teenage daughter?
Q
Comments (11)
I find myself in a 'similiar' position. When I met my husband, he was upfront that he had no children, however he was with a young woman 12 years ago, 16 years now that became pregnant during their relationship. They were in a a rocky relationship. He didn't speak badly of her but just said it wasn't a good relationship and then all of a sudden came a baby. My husband was 23. The young lady was 19. He was with her through most of the pregnancy but close to the end, the relationship could not be saved. He moved out. She called when the baby was born. He went to the hospital and asked for a paternity test. (I don't begrudge him for this, he had walked in on her during the pregnancy with another man). She refused the test. She told him he was not the father. He told her when she changed her mind to contact him. He went on with his life. He called her a few times and was told by her mother they would file harrassment charges against him if he contacted them again. So he left her alone. He worked at the same school district where he had been working for the next 12 years. She never contacted him. Well I did some research (on my own) and I found the girl. I posted about this. She looks identical to my husband. I know in my heart this is his daughter. But at this point in her life, what good would it do to barge in And start using the 'I'm your daddy' phrase? He agreed she does look like him and his grandmother. But he doesn't believe she is his because he really believes her mom would have filed for child support or something. I used to worry about this all the time. What if she contacts us? What about our children? What about our future children? What about my child that is his stepdaughter? And what about my in laws? They were devastated when they found out they weren't really going to have a chance at being grandparents to this baby. As time went on, I have stopped dwelling on the what ifs. Sure this girl may show up one day but I can't waste today worrying about tomorrow. She is almost an adult at this point and who knows what she has been told. What she thinks. Where her mind is and her feelings along with emotions of not having a dad in her life. It's possible she HAS a dad in her life. She might have been raised by another man. It's just not worth dwelling over. I agree with mkroopy-- there are so many other factors that can be involved here. No one knows. My husband is an excellent father. He is an excellent stepfather. But 16 years ago, he didn't know that he could file for a court ordered paternity test. Well honestly I dont think he could. The laws have changed so much. He wasn't in a financial position to wage a custody battle against this you g woman. If it happened today, I have no doubt that he would pursue every legal avenue to make sure that he has the right to be a father to a child that might be his. But 16 years ago? I don't think he knew or had the ambition to go forth on that circumstance. He changed into a different person after that. He lived a more 'careful' life. He didn't put himself into that position again. He grew from that situation and became the man he is today. People grow. People change. Just as they can become 'bad' partners and become our ex's. They can become better people from the mistakes they make. I don't worry anymore about this child that may be my husband's. I can't worry until the day my doorbell rings. Then ... I'll be back posting about adult stepchildren that are distant and hateful :)
...See More
My boyfriend has 3 kids and still lives with ex. Am I stupid?
Q
Comments (17)
I am in a similar situation except maybe a bit more complicated, who knows! I understand. Either way, you have to be understanding to all sides of the story, including that she is their mother and may not like you being a part of the children's lives like you want. But, if you and your man are going to make it work, eventually they will have to get to know you. As far as him...I understand that the way he is trying to deal with everything in his head is the right way (which it's not, but to him it is...for now), and you can't make him change. He needs to realize himself...that although it will be hard (more than hard or a bump in the road), that if it's you he wants to be with, he needs to focus on getting himself together as an individual and take a chance in not living with the children and realize he can have both, maybe not exactly how he wants...but it's a compromise. Basically, he has some things to figure out (and so do you). Will you always want to have to deal with his ex and everything that comes with her? Nomatter how much it seems like everything is in place, he is not...none of you are. It does take a toll on the children and I understand he wants to see them everyday and be in the same house and help financially, but where do each of you want to be next year...or say in 5 years? How long can this go on? I hope that it works out and soon. Believe me, I am not judging, just giving you things to think about that I know I have. I am only 23 but I feel I've been through quite a bit for my age. My man and I have been together off and on for 5 years, he is 33. Within those 5 years we have had other partners, he has gotten a divorce, had 3 children, I moved away and came back, and now he lives with his ex-wife...all the while she's known about me and wants me to have nothing to do with the children. Things have come a long way. We plan to get married and have children of our own and even move in soon, but with all the rollercoaster action in our past, we want to make sure everything is right before going to the next step. He is figuring out his life and so am I so we can become a union and bring God in our relationship.
...See More
My boyfriend has 2 daughters
Q
Comments (3)
Well, presumably your boyfriend is aware of his financial obligations and how much income he has left after meeting those obligations. Surely you can work out a budget to decide if you can comfortably raise your own family or not. (And good on the German system for compelling parents to financially support the children they bring into the world.)
...See More
lamom
17 years ago
I agree with finedreams, it could just be that this new person is a better partner for him with the five kids. You didn't do the wrong thing, you did what thought was best for yourself, your DD and your relationship.

I have a cousin with custody of her two kids who met her husband with two kids in joint custody. They decided together to NOT merge their households even when they got married. Their reason was it was easier for the kids at the time to not be forced in to a blended family situation, their ex-spouses were not thrilled about the marriage at the time, and since they had already been maintaining separate households financially that they would just keep doing it. Also, both had been through terrible and expensive divorces so they wanted to stay separate financially.

Theirs is one of the happiest marriages and blended families that I know in large part due to not forcing everyone to live together Brady Bunch style. You did the right thing. He just moved on, that happens.
cindy_pond
17 years ago
count your blessings. This happened to a friend of mine. She moved in with a man who had 5 kids she had 3. She did everything for his kids. they called her mom. He broke up with her while driving across the george washington bridge after a number of years. Real sensitive...He married someone else shortly after. lesson learned!!
disengaging
17 years ago
In my opinion, you got LUCKY! L-U-C-K-Y !!!!!!!

I totally agree! And I not only think you did the right thing, but made the responsible decision--first for yourself, but even more so for your daughter.

It may be hard to say with any degree of certainty, but it really does sound like he was looking for someone to play "mommy" and help him take care of his kids. I don't necessarily see anything wrong with that in itself, but after 5 years, I think the LEAST he owed you was to break it off with you first before starting to see someone else.

If he actually cared about YOU, he would have let you know, so the two of you could at least TRY to work out a mutually acceptable compromise. For example, buying a house together with an in-law apartment for you and your daughter and waiting a while longer before gradually blending the 2 families.

Any guy (or woman) worth keeping isn't going to go off in search of a "better deal" while they're still involved in a relationship with someone else. I personally would not want to be with someone who could disrespect ANYONE in that way. For me, there would alway be the question, "If he could do it to her, how do I know he won't do the same to me?"
Kasey Parry
7 years ago
I'm in a similar situation. I've been with a man for some time now, he has joint custody of 5 children. I love him very much just don't know what to do, because you see he has expressed many times he loves me as well but his children barley like me, thier polite when need be when I'm around, but I've caught a few things, a glare, rolling of the eyes, snickering, not saying thank you to me when I've done something for them, and a few complaints. Right now the situation is a bit complicated. I stay at his house most of the time when the weekend he has them comes my daughter and I are at my place. I'm not sure what the future holds for him and me, right now we are playing it all by ear. I have no idea what the future holds for us all I do is hope it turns out well.

boyfriend has 5 kids

colleenoz

Comments (7)

finedreams

imamommy

Related Discussions

lamom

cindy_pond

disengaging

Kasey Parry

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US