Obviously you appear to like the darker palate of siding choices. Of the three you mention, I personally like the Boothbay Blue best. White trim would be ideal, and black shutters, too. A black door would work, as would a dark barn red, if you wanted something different.

If you click on the house picture, it will show it enlarged.

Here is a link that might be useful: Boothbay Blue house

I don't see the other colours you mention. In general, however, I think blue houses look best near the ocean or a lake or some body of water, and then in a dark, greyish blue. Lighter hues don't wear well, imo, and the boothbay blue would be too light for me, but that is just my taste. A bluish grey with black shutters and smart white trim would look better, but I don't see that as a choice in the link.

Did you see this sample of boothbay blue with white trim and black shutters and door.

{{!gwi}}

Thank you all for posting.

No, the house isn't anywhere near water.

Thank you so much for link and pic. I think that does look pretty good. Opinions.

I'm just very worried about making the wrong choice as I've never done this before. *I* may think it looks good but then when it's built in front of me I might say "Oh crap..." lol

You never mention the style of your house. Is it a bungalow, split or ranch or colonial etc etc.

Anyone with paint peeling/cracking on HardiePlank Colorplus lap siding [the pre-painted stuff] please email me. Particularly interested in Canadian and the Northern States.
thanx.

Did you decide? We're also building and think we've decided on Evening Blue, a gray stone skirt, black shutters, grayish trim, gray or black roof...it is so hard to decide though!!!
Still debating, ours is a one story house.
If you have any pictures I'd love to see them, or if you found any others along the way of the "blues". I was looking for something more like a charcoal gray, to us the evening blue looks gray, at least on the sample! We don't want it to look too blue, but we also don't want to look too much like the neighbour's house which is lighter gray stone with a charcoal / black roof.