Question on property taxes at closing

12 years ago

Our house finally sold after nearly a year on the market. The closing was Tuesday and we did very well, tripling what we orginally paid for the house over 20 yrs ago. But here's the question for those of you experienced with closings: Over the year the house was for sale, we paid off the original mortgage, not realizing that the lender had only escrowed and paid taxes through 2009, but not for 2010, since the mortgage was paid in full in January 2011 and we pay taxes in arrears here. After the mortgage was released by the lender, we got a huge refund back for our overpaid tax escrow account, but it didn't dawn on us until yesterday (the day after the closing), when we looked at the Auditor's website for the property that our 2010 taxes were still outstanding and unpaid. Now the settlement statement does reflect that 2011 taxes from Jan. 1 through Sept 27 were deducted from our check, but nothing for 2010, which is what I expected to see. Obviously, the title company whp prepared the paperwork and conducted the closing completely missed the 2010 taxes being outstanding and delinquent and I assume the deed cannot be transferred to the new owners until the taxes are paid. We have no problem doing the right thing and paying the 2010 taxes, but shouldn't the title company bear some responsibility for not catching this glaring error when they researched the property for liens and encumberances to the deed? They were paid to do a title search and they obviously missed a big thing that might cause a problem both for the buyers and for us.

We called our real estate agent last night when we discovered the problem and are waiting to hear back, but I'd like the opinions of those of you who are experienced in this kind of issue. BTW....initially, even our own agent was convinced that we were ok and that just deducting the 2011 taxes through the closing date was correct...UNTIL we made her look at the Auditor's website and see that our 2010 taxes were still outstanding. She was shocked that this was missed.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (7)

liriodendron
12 years ago
You know what the right thing to do is, so just do it. Write a check and mail it in with return receipt requested, or go down to where ever you pay your taxes and take care of it in person. If you go in person, I expect you'll be treated as a hero for stepping up, unprompted.

Doesn't matter who missed it, and anyway if anyone has a beef it's not you as the title company is working in either the buyer's or morgage company's interest.

Even if you were tempted to let it slide I think eventually the State Auditor's office would find the error and you'd be on the hook for interest, and possibly penalties, on the unpaid tax debt. The fact that you no longer own the property wouldn't protect you.

Congratulation on selling your house, at a good profit, in this economy.

L.
Jamie
12 years ago
The auditor's website could be a little out of date. I wouldn't be too quick to start handing out money. But, yes, as a courtesy and because they probably have insurance against mistakes, the closing agent may pay some or all of anything due.

When we have closed in the past, we have usually been asked to sign a document that says we will allow and comply with corrections after the fact, fwiw.
Related Discussions
tax question about a property transfer btw father and daughter
Q
Comments (2)
You really need to talk to a CPA and/or real estate attorney in your jurisdiction. And also at issue is how the property has been handled for tax purposes to-date. Has it been depreciated as an investment property? Have maintenance expenses been used to offset income? How has this been handled on each party's taxes to date? Without knowing the above, and without being an expert in your area, I don't see how the scenario can be spun as a sale "not" taking place. The mental gymnastics required would land on "I'm gifting you this interest in our joint property for no consideration, and then you are gifting me DP + $20,000, but the two have nothing to do with one another."
...See More
Tax Deduction on Rental Property
Q
Comments (12)
Definitely give your tax accountant a call. You have many more issues than this to discuss with him/her. You need to have everything set up as efficiently and properly as possible so that at the end of the tax year, you hand him/her a workable stack of information. Your tax accountant isn't just there from Feb-April--he's there all year. I give mine a call anytime I have a question that pertains to what's going to be happening to my taxes. He's happy to offer advice, many times he doesn't even charge me. AND by asking ahead of time, you often have the option of setting things up in the most favorable way for you. There are legal ways to reduce your tax liability, but you need to be getting good advice, so you don't make costly mistakes. Please call your tax accountant a call--this is what they do. And if you don't have one--with going into this investment, now's the time to get one.
...See More
Property Tax Deduction Question
Q
Comments (1)
I assume that if you pay it prior to Dec 31 you can deduct it from this year's taxable income, and if you pay it next year, you'll deduct it next year. So the difference is the possible savings in the year interim vs., ordinarily, the return that you could have got on the money. In your case, however, less the costs involved in deferring paying the other bills in the meantime. Adjusted for what different tax rate that you may have to pay on the highest taxed dollars of your taxable income, next year, if different from the rate this year. Would it make more sense to borrow some at the bank to pay the other bills, if the difference in cost would be marked? If only minimal, probably not worth the bother - unless you want to build a solid credit history, lacking one at present. Though, if you're farming, I think that building a credit history will not be a concern! Also - how long before you may be able to pay off the other bills (and what new unpaid bills may you have rung up in the meantime)? Hope you are able to figure which is best. Good wishes for the New Year. joyful guy
...See More
Challenging a Property Tax Assessment
Q
Comments (9)
Your town/city/state would be more than happy to have you pay more taxes, if that is what you want! I agree with the other posters ... your logic is a bit flawed. Depending on your town/city and how they calculate RE values (and how often), you could have assesments that are close to market value or very different. My old town in Mass kept assesments pretty current and in "normal" markets they used to lag about $100K from market value. In todays market with short sales and foreclosures the numbers can be all over the place. CA is a crazy place with Prop 13. It sets the assesment value at the purchase price, with controlled increments. So you can have neighbors with similar houses worth $1 mill, but one might be paying $2k in taxes and the other $12K. A flawed system that they also applied to commercial real estate! One of the many reasons the state of CA has major money issues. Your future buyers, if they use a bank, will be required to have an apparaisal. The assesment won't matter ... what will matter is the current RE market at the time of the sale.
...See More
mainecoonkitty
Original Author
12 years ago
We paid it this morning to the title company and probably saved the document preparer her job. She had completely missed it and marked it on the settlement forms as paid. The poor girl was sobbing when she thanked us. Both the buyer's agent and our own agent were astonished that we caught it and so many others, including them, completely missed it. A little while ago, the president of the title company called my husband to thank him. He's also sending us a check for our portion of the title search fee and a gift card to a really nice restaurant here in town for dinner on him. We're going to take the new owners out for dinner. All's well that ends well! :)
weedyacres
12 years ago
Doing the right thing pays. :-)
LoveInTheHouse
12 years ago
You're one of the good guys.
mainecoonkitty
Original Author
12 years ago
LOL! Thanks. We never considered not paying the taxes, but it does concern me that such a big thing got missed and no one caught it.
blueheron
12 years ago
Something similar happened to us when we bought our cottage on the river in 2000. We bought it from a guy we knew, Joel, and there were no RE agents involved, but we did have a title search done. He had only owned it for a year and was moving out of state.

About 2 months after we bought it, we went to the cottage one weekend and found a notice on the door saying the property was being sold for back taxes! SAY WHAT?

Promptly on Monday morning my husband appeared at the title company's office and showed them the notice. They apologized profusely and paid the tax bill immediately.

The problem arose because Joel had to purchase both the house and the land, the house from the seller and the land from a utility company. It seems the title company had only searched the title to the land, not the property. Joel had no idea about this, either, because he had never gotten any tax bills. It seems they had been sent to the previous owner who had thrown them away. Whew! What a scare that was.

Question on property taxes at closing

Comments (7)

liriodendron

Jamie

Related Discussions

mainecoonkitty
Original Author

weedyacres

LoveInTheHouse

mainecoonkitty
Original Author

blueheron

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Question on property taxes at closing

Comments (7)

liriodendron

Jamie

Related Discussions

mainecoonkittyOriginal Author

weedyacres

LoveInTheHouse

mainecoonkittyOriginal Author

blueheron

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

mainecoonkitty
Original Author

mainecoonkitty
Original Author