Living areas paint color--BM Thunder or Smoke Embers?

9 years ago

In our new build, the living room/kitchen/dining/and family room all blend into each other, so they will all be one color. We will have a lot of natural light, with warm off-white cabinets, wood floors a walnut gray/brown (color to be determined still), not reddish though.

All the colors we've sampled so far seem too beige/tan/brown, especially at night, such as Himalayan Trek, Stone Harbor, and SW colors like Requisite Gray and functional Gray.

I want a true warm gray that still reads mostly grayish, but isn't too gray or cold and will go w/ creamy off-white (not too yellow, but not stark white). I like both Thunder and Smoke Embers. Smoke Embers seems a little warmer/a tad more brown, maybe, while Thunder is a rich gorgeous gray. San Antonio Gray is nice but seems darker.

I really like blues as an accent and in a few other rooms, either pale misty grays with a hint of blue, or darker, smoky gray-blues.

We wanted to paint the doors a rich brown-black, like SW Urbane Bronze, but if we go more gray, maybe a deep charcoal would work better. We will get new furnishings so I can adapt there. I just want it to still be warm and inviting and not clash w/ the cabinets or trim, which has a hint of warmth and is not stark white either.

Has anyone used either of these colors or have any advice on whether one or both of these would clash or read too cold? Thanks!

Featured Answer

Skyangel23
Original Author

9 years ago

Hi Tibbrix, thanks for the response. I do have the two grays on poster board w/poster putty up on the wall. I like them both but definitely tend to second guess myself and am unsure whether one or both would be too cool for warm cabinets.

In my lighting, Smoke Embers reads a little more beige, and Thunder is a bit more gray, but with a lot of depth. IT definitely draws the eye more than the other colors. I did color match to PPG paint though, so the colors might be a tad off from the true BM shades.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (12)

tibbrix
9 years ago
Smoke Embers is pretty gray, i.e.: cool. Thunder has more beige in it and will be warmer. I think Thunder is a beautiful color with a lot of depth to it.

SW Urban Bronze is gorgeous and would be stunning against Thunder, IMO. I just put the two in separate windows, side-by-side, and they make a gorgeous combination.

Best thing to do, though, is get samples and put swatches on the walls and live with them for a few days.
Related Discussions
Breezygirl do you have a picture of BM Thunder in your LR?
Q
Comments (14)
Hi Positano. Sorry I couldn't get to this earlier. I saw your post right before I rushed out the door to lead our July 4 parade. I've never posted pics of my rooms with Thunder or Nimbus, although you might be able to see them in the background of a couple of my kitchen shots. I didn't specifically take pics of those rooms after we moved in because they were a mess with all our moving boxes, etc as we did some minor finishing on other areas of the house to enable us to unpack said boxes. Plus, DH needed to finish painting them. I accidentally dropped my camera in the lake the evening after my dad's memorial service several weeks ago so I can't take new photos for you right now. Let me try to find the computer cord for DH's little-used camera in the next day or so. Thunder does not tend to any purple or pink undertones in my LR. Nimbus, in my FR bordering kitchen, seemed to at first before we moved in, but either the furniture fixed that or I got used to it. I don't see any lavender now. I really like both colors, but Thunder can make my heart skip a beat sometimes. Love it! I'll see what I can do for you!
...See More
Living room paint color w/ maroon brick fireplace
Q
Comments (39)
An update, as I think we have a winner! Thanks for all the amazing suggestions - I can't even say how helpful this was. My husband rejected a few of the options, like the sage greens. We sampled some more of the finalists and were much happier with these choices than the cooler greys we tried last weekend, which we hated. It was a tough call between Sea Pearl and Revere Pewter, but Sea Pearl won, primarily because we also want to use it the same color in the adjoining hallway, which also leads to some other rooms where we will be using more dramatic colors, so the lighter shade seemed better. Incidentally, we also decided that for the whole house, Cotton Balls will work better than White Dove on the trim and ceilings. We have White Dove in our condo and love it, but the light in the new house is totally different. The White Dove just seems dingy in some rooms, especially the north-facing ones. I'll update this thread with "after" pics in a couple weeks! Samples! You can also see that in the interim, the floors have been refinished! Woohoo! The Sea Pearl is hard to discern in this first pic because it's pretty close to the color of the raw horsehair plaster we will be painting over. (There used to be wallpaper.) But it's swatched to the left of the Revere Pewter, I swear. Here's the hallway. It's crazy how different the light is from room to room in this house. (Still doesn't explain why the downstairs bedroom, just visible on the left, was painted orange...we're going to use the Revere Pewter in there.)
...See More
I have looked at too many paint colors... kitchen update
Q
Comments (18)
After reading the latest posts, I see you are further along than you think. All the colors you named plus Gray Owl are grey green. If these are your walls throughout, it sounds like you are leaning toward painting over Dusty Trail. I say: go for it. So the only question now is: do you want the kitchen cabinets to read as green-blue, or as definitely "gray?" Note: with these pretty beach colors either will be beautiful. If Mindful Gray is still on your list please do a sample. Online it looks like anything from purple to putty to charcoal depending on lighting. Looking at your swatches again.... Benjamin Moore White Dove is a good off white color if you decide for your living room--if you don't want the green in there. SW Agreeable Gray looks the most "greige" of your chips, it may blend with the existing kitchen floor. If you definitely don't want beige, you could eliminate White Duck. This is the kind of thinking I try to do with paint. Again sample boards are needed because paint will not look exactly like the chip in your home.
...See More
HELP Paint color scheme - Burnt Orange and blue accents
Q
Comments (8)
I think doing some computer imaging would be super helpful for you if that's something you have the tech skills and interest to take on. Some of the paint manufacturers have apps that let you "paint" an image of your own room to try out colors (not a substitute for testing colors in your own space since the app can only guess about light conditions, but it can help point you in the right direction). Some rug vendors (RugsUsa and eSale rugs, among others) let you visualize a rug in your space (they do a great job of sussing out what is furniture and what is floor and getting the perspective right). And I get a lot of mileage out of Microsoft Word in terms of creating collages of images, like layering the putty sofa over the top of the existing sofa, or layering in curtains or artwork. It's helpful to figure out how to remove backgrounds from images, make an image float over text so you can stack them, and how to reorder images so the curtains are on top of the wall and not under it. I did this with Benjamin Moore's personal color viewer. Colors are BM Tandoori and Elmira White.
...See More
Skyangel23
Original Author
9 years ago
Here is the closest to how Smoke Embers reads in our light:
Skyangel23
Original Author
9 years ago
This is how Thunder reads:
Skyangel23
Original Author
9 years ago
these will be our kitchen cabinets, a warm off-white, reads white unless you hold it next to something a true white.
tibbrix
9 years ago
Wow. Completely opposite the swatches show on the BM site!

Although I do think the Thunder "feels" warmer. They're both beautiful colors. I see your dilemma.
westleyandbuttercup
9 years ago
We have Thunder in most of the rooms on our main floor and have been very happy with it.
Skyangel23
Original Author
9 years ago
westleyandbuttercup, glad to know you like Thunder. Would you be willing to post a couple of pics?
scanmike
9 years ago
They are both beautiful colors, but had I been able to go grey in my home, I would have chosen Thunder. Not too dark and it has nice warmth to it.
indygo
9 years ago
No comment on the colors, but Skyangel your home is beautiful!!
westleyandbuttercup
9 years ago
I was hoping the sun would peek out today so I could take some newer photos, but no such luck. These are all from either before we moved in or right after.

Here's looking into the kitchen from the living room.

Here's the fireplace wall in the family room.

Here's a shot from the master bedroom.

Thunder with dark cabinetry in our master bath.
Skyangel23
Original Author
9 years ago
westleyandbuttercup, thank you so much for the pics! your home is beautiful, and the color is perfect.

Indygo-girl, those are just pics from the internet, not of my house sadly. I love the one with the stone fireplace... sigh.

We decided to do a custom color in between both Thunder and Smoke Embers, so a little more gray than Thunder, a little warmer/more brown undertone than Smoke Embers by itself. Hopefully it works out. :-)

Living areas paint color--BM Thunder or Smoke Embers?

Skyangel23
Original Author

Comments (12)

tibbrix

Related Discussions

Skyangel23
Original Author

Skyangel23
Original Author

Skyangel23
Original Author

tibbrix

westleyandbuttercup

Skyangel23
Original Author

scanmike

indygo

westleyandbuttercup

Skyangel23
Original Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Living areas paint color--BM Thunder or Smoke Embers?

Skyangel23Original Author

Comments (12)

tibbrix

Related Discussions

Skyangel23Original Author

Skyangel23Original Author

Skyangel23Original Author

tibbrix

westleyandbuttercup

Skyangel23Original Author

scanmike

indygo

westleyandbuttercup

Skyangel23Original Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Skyangel23
Original Author

Skyangel23
Original Author

Skyangel23
Original Author

Skyangel23
Original Author

Skyangel23
Original Author

Skyangel23
Original Author