Thank you all so much! tommorrowisanotherday--I actually have a quart of it from a regional paint dealer, Dunn Edwards (we'll be using their premium paint in eggshell--it's been great for us). We are going to paint a larger swatch on the wall just to make sure we still love it. We do have a very open concept floor plan. The entry, front all, kitchen, dining area, living room, and upstairs loft areas (all areas except two bedrooms and a bath) are all open to each other. The only rooms that aren't, and will have different colors, are the four bedrooms/three baths and the laundry room. I'm going with one color because it was hard enough to pick that one and I can't imagine picking more for flow. It's frustrating for sure, and pricey to have it painted. We'd do it ourselves, but 20' ceilings are too much for us. I'm afraid of heights. sandyponder--I love your living room--it's so cozy and warm looking! That is the look I'm going for. I never would have guessed that's Pine Grove--it looks so much darker on the strip. We have south, north and east facing windows in our open areas, plus a couple of solar tubes, so we get a fair amount of light throughout the day. I feel much more comfortable with the darker color now. ttodd--I hear you :-)! We're doing it. My neighbor thinks I'm crazy, but she may not be a huge green fan. I am, and so are my husband and daughter. It's going to look like a forest in here when it's done. I'll get pics up asap.

Does anyone have a recommendation for a complementary white that goes with Graytint? All these work with Graytint just depends on which one you like best. Chantilly Lace BM OC-065 Ice Mist BM OC-067 Snow White BM OC-066 As far as gloss level, you could do the same as the walls, eggshell, or bump it up one level to satin (or whatever the next bump up in gloss level is called in the brand you want to buy).

I would just change the sheen unless you want more contrast. I would not use White Opulence in this situation because they are both too close but too different. It would be just "off" in that head scratching way. Now I do know White Opulence very well,as I've used it for all my trim and all the kitchen cabs in this house.

Not too much. Your house will end up looking bigger. I think the roof is neutral enough that you have the luxury of going with your gut, going with the color that speaks to you.