Should I try to avoid butting 2 deck boards on 1 joist?

13 years ago

I am replacing my existing PT 2x6 deck boards with 5/4 PT, and am thinking about trying to avoid butting boards against each other on the same joist.

A deck book got me thinking about this because it tends to weaken the boards by having the screws so close to the ends, and it invites rot by having the ends over a solid board underneath, which doesn't allow for drainage or air circulation. This seems to make a lot of sense.

So the book suggests having a parallel joist, separated by a 1/2" spacer, to screw the next board in line to. With a wide deck, and a random arrangement of board ends, this adds a lot of parallel joists.

I'm trying to figure out if I have a valid construction concern, or if I'm just being neurotic. It seems the standard method for building decks is to just randomize the ends as much as possible, butt the boards on a single joist, angle the screws a bit into the joist, and be done with it. It seems a bit half a$$ed, but if it works and lasts, why not?

Help, experiences, and ideas appreciated!

Thanks,

David

In a previous message:

http://ths.gardenweb.com/forums/load/porch/msg060940437221.html?2

...I asked advice on an idea for replacing my deck boards, dividing the deck into three sections separated by perpendicular trim boards. The only reason for doing so was this concern about two boards on a joist.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (5)

john_hyatt
13 years ago
Its a good idea to add sister joists when butt joining composite 5/4. With pt 5/4 it hardley matters. J.
brooklyndecks
13 years ago
David,

As John said, you shouldn't overthink a pressure treated deck, as it won't look good for very long anyway. That said, you can still build it well and be proud of it when you're finished.
I build higher end, using Ipe for decking, and this is how I frame for butt joints. I stagger the joints, and create a repetitive pattern. I sister joists wherever a joint happens, so each board lands on it's own joist. Butt joints are always problematic...I work with a caliper and a table saw to make sure that I butt 2 boards that have exactly the same width. You'll find out that 5/4x6 really means 1"x5 3/8 or maybe 1"x5 1/2". I rip the wider board to the same width of the smaller. Then there's the cut...the 2 boards need to meet at a tight joint. It's not easy, so I round over the tops of both cuts. It's more forgiving. If there's a slight gap, you won't notice it.
Anyway, there is a lot to deck building that you can obsess about, but do you want to? I do, because I like to...I need to.
Back to your question...I sister the joists together...no 1/2 gap.

steve
Related Discussions
?- deck joists sit on wall plate
Q
Comments (10)
It is intersting. How far in are the joists rotted? Repair/replace could be done a couple ways that I see. Tear out / Replace the same way it was done. Using a bottle jack remove each joist one at a time placing temp blocks as you go.Replace each joist one at a time. Depending on the condition of the wood plan on installing a ledger. This is what I would do. If you can cut the joists back enough to fasten a ledger to them that would be ideal. If not cut them out one at a time using the bottle jack, place a block to the inside of the plate to hold the load, fasten the ledger to them. It would be good if the ledger landed on the bearing wall. Ledger attachment must be firm and strong. Reread.Again. Use the marketed steel ties, or have them made for you, for pull away protection. Install all needed flashing. Inform the permit store. Remove/replace All rotted areas including the top plate if it has gone that far. Love the heels on that frisky blonde. J.
...See More
Deck Joist Sag - replace or repair?
Q
Comments (3)
How could some joists be 3/4" below the others? That's a big difference. 1) Should I sister up a new joist next to the bowed joists? And if I do, will the load make the current joist sag more? That could work. Set the new joist with the crown up, clamp them together (flush on top) and bolt or screw them together. 2) Should I flip it and plane what would now be a crown? no 3) Should I just replace the sagging joists? (Hard for me to do since I can not transport 16' joists) That could work...crown up. If you can't transport new joists, how can you get sister joists for solution #1) 4) since you have a beam in the middle (not really the middle), you can shim up the low joists. FIRST... I would run strings/blocks along the top of the outer joists...front to back, to make sure they are straight. I also run strings along the sides of the 2 outer joists and straighten them. Use nylon string. Make 7 identical small blocks of wood, put 1 block between string and joist top at each end of the string lines. Use the 7th block as your gauge. It should just fit between string and joist top...everywhere. I would run 3 tight string lines across all of the joists...one on each end, and 1 in the middle. Tweak the joists by shimming/planing until that block fits right. When you're done with the strings, your deck will be flat. Not necessarily level, but flat, and that's what you need to achieve. steve
...See More
Ipe Deck -- Joists and Deck Board thickness questions
Q
Comments (2)
1. I would go w/ 2X10s for the ledger & joists. While most 2X8s can span 12 feet it depends on your local jurisdiction's code & what the live & dead loads are, the deflection coefficients, and the type joists. Plus 2X10s will reduce the floor bounce better than 2X8s. Also, since you are cantilevering the IRC code requires that 2X10 joists be used. The size girder is dependant on the post spacing. I would go w/ 5 posts spaced at 6'. Three 2X10s are plenty sufficient for that. 2. I would go w/ 5/4 if money is no object & probably even it it was. Less cupping typically & if you want to run the decking on a diagonal that increases the span but no problem w/ 5/4 IPE. 3. The joist's spacing is related to the joist span (which is 12' approximately (I guess 11' since it sounds like it will be cantilevered by 1')) and to the size & type of joists used. I would go w/ 16" OC.
...See More
Is it true that I should avoid cabinets made in California - paint?
Q
Comments (26)
I'm in CA and used a local large custom-ish cabinet maker that does a baked on conversion varnish. We will see how it holds up, but they were (of course) confident in their product and contractors had good things to say about them too. Most people I talked to seemed to think as long as it was a heated finish rather than just painted it would wear well, regardless of where it was manufactured. I'm not an expert and have only had my cabs for less than a year though, so time will tell!
...See More
David B
Original Author
13 years ago
Thanks for the advice. When you guys sister joists, do you run it full length, or just as a short nailer under each board joint?

David
brooklyndecks
13 years ago
david

I sister full length. Since I repeat the pattern every 2 or 3 rows, it makes sense to sister one time, instead of many.
If I used a random pattern, I might do random sistering, but that would really slow down the job.
If you sister full length, you get another benefit...a stiffer deck...better than viagra.
If you already have a stiff deck, you could sister a 2x4 instead of a larger board. Make sure it's well fastened, and coplane at the top with it's sister. It's also a good idea to cover the double joist with vycor to seal out the moisture and tree trash.

steve
David B
Original Author
13 years ago
Thanks, Steve. The boards I'm removing are all 2x6 PT, and I'm thinking about using some of them as these sisters, since I have them, and most seem pretty solid.

Went to Lowes yesterday to buy some framing lumber to shore up the previous bad design, and browsed through the 5/4 PT deck boards. Man, they are crummy! Full of knots.

David

Should I try to avoid butting 2 deck boards on 1 joist?

Comments (5)

john_hyatt

brooklyndecks

Related Discussions

David B
Original Author

brooklyndecks

David B
Original Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Should I try to avoid butting 2 deck boards on 1 joist?

Comments (5)

john_hyatt

brooklyndecks

Related Discussions

David BOriginal Author

brooklyndecks

David BOriginal Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

David B
Original Author

David B
Original Author