I didn't think Kady or Danny were good. I didn't hear the other two. I truthfully thought Kady could sing but she had such a flat personality. Not sure what was up with her but I got the feeling she did not really want to be there. She didn't even seem upset when she was voted off.

No fair telling, Scissors. LOL

Last night, Kady jakked up a very pretty song. She couldn't stay on key if her career depended on it, and all she did was yell the high notes. I think she has a pretty voice, but she has no idea what to do with it or where to land it.

I'm very glad the last boy was sent home. VERY glad.

Oops! What was I thinking? I forgot it was a secret. Sorry.

I was happy with all that went home. Not really surprised at all.

I've never watched "Idol"...but became interested as there were three people from within an hour of my hometown all on one show...Amanda Overmeyer is the one who i'll be rooting for now! This is such an incredible chance for her to make it in the music business!

I thought the right people went home. I really like the guys this year. There are some very good singers - I think.

I was so glad to see the last guy get voted off, I really disliked his attitude. Even the way he stood there last night, sooooooo arrogant.

I felt badly for the other guy. Not that he wasn't deserving, it is tough now, I find something to like about all of them. I usually really like Simon, and even agree with him but he was really nasty Tuesday night. I think he should voice his opinion, that is why he is there, but he should take away anyone's dream. And by saying "You won't make it any further", that just seems cruel.

I was sooo happy about Danny Noriega getting the boot.
Also thought Luke was the best choice among the guys.

Between Asia'h and Kristy, I'm just glad I didn't have to make the decision. I liked them both equally, but I am glad it was Asia'h and not Kristy, mainly bcause I think Asia'h needs her adenoids removed and Kristy has such a pretty and crystal clear voice. Her voice is different somehow, but I don't know how to explain that.

Unfortunately, I think Kristy is next to go among the girls. I don't really think she makes enough of a statement. Not exactly agreeing with Simon that she is forgettable though.

Im glad Danny is gone...I think he could have gotten as annoying as Sanjiya was last year....Danny has a very sarcastic personality and it was getting on my nerves. He didn't take constructive criticism well at all. He gave some pretty hateful looks at times.

I'm OK with these cuts.

Gayle

I wasn't sad the first three went home, but I liked Danny! He is a sarcastic person and a bit juvenile when Simon would say something unkind to him, but he had personality! I just liked seeing what he would say next. Talent wise I doubt he would have gone much further, but he was just interesting to watch! Chiekese (I'm sure I spelled that wrong) was okay to stay, but I will miss Danny! I would have picked David hernandez instead. Somehow the judges liked his song?? I must be deaf sometimes??

I thought Brooke's acoustic version of her song was GREAT!

Luke should have gone home for song choice alone-UGH!

I was soooo happy Danny left, and I think Kady was glad she was voted off. So far, I've usually agreed with Simon, but he can be really nasty when he wants to be that's for sure. I think he's a good part of the reason a lot of people tune in to the show in the first place.