What brand of turkey to buy?

17 years ago

With grocery prices the way that they are, I was wondering what turkey to buy. I really love a Butterball or Honeysuckle White turkey but the store brands are so much cheaper. I hsve used Riverside and have heard that it is comparable. What is everybody else's experience? Is it just me or does a Butterball really taste better?

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (14)

gardenguru1950
17 years ago
Wherever I've lived (in 6 states), I've also been able to find a source of "fresh" turkeys from some local or near-local turkey ranch. Preferably natural, free-range or organic. They don't have "brands". Most have been available through the mid-sized supermarkets that have good meat departments but occasionally you'll find them direct.

I've found these fresh (sometimes not exactly but "on ice") turkeys always better in flavor than the big brand names.

Most of the turkey's flavor comes from the prep and cooking techniques, anyway.

So, look under "turkey" in the yellow pages???

Joe
gardenguru1950
17 years ago
That should have read...

Wherever I've lived, I've ALWAYS been able to find a source of "fresh" turkeys..."

Joe
Related Discussions
should i buy brown turkey, or texas everbearing?
Q
Comments (11)
You know, I have seen a lot of figs labled "Brown Turkey" here in Texas and from what I can tell, when ever a tag is lost or a grower does not know what he has, he labels it "Brown Turkey". Almost a generic catch-all. That being said, Brown Turkey is reasonable, when its good, it is great, when not it is...just ok. As to your question, yes, the two varieties should be the same- if they are true to type. You might want to look up "Celeste'- one of the best for our part of the state. It is common, most garden centers should cary it or, just look for a massive one in some neighborhood, probably it is Celeste. A lot of local people call it "Sugar fig". Fig growers are a generous bunch- always willing to give you some cuttings. Either way...if the price is good at N.Haven, give it a shot-you will not make a "wrong" choice. BTW..the Brown Turkey(s) in my collection are all different. I trust none of them as being true- they were all from commercial sources. Pretty sure 2 of them are Celeste!
...See More
Read up on hoods, know what I need...now what brand to buy?
Q
Comments (4)
I've decided to go with Prestige 54" to go over new 48" Capital Culinarian. That will be paired with a 1600CFM remote (roof mounted) blower). That's a bit over powered but I'd rather go over than under since I do a lot of stir-fry and saute. Also plan to do some grilling on the new range.
...See More
Lindac and Lou, What Kind Of Turkeys Are You Getting?
Q
Comments (11)
Lou, the farmer I get my turkeys from has mostly birds over 30 pounds. A 25 pounder is a "small" turkey, usually a hen. He raises something called "Standard Bronze" and the average weight of a Tom is 35-40 pounds, hens are 25-30 pounds. He's had a couple of big Toms that have neared 50 pounds but they're old birds and not suitable for roasting. He also has a few smaller Bourbon Red turkeys, but he's building his flock and doesn't sell those yet. The Toms are averaging 35 pounds and the hens about 20 pounds. He doesn't sell the "broad breasted white" turkeys for a couple of reasons. One, they cannot mate naturally, and so the only way you can get them is to get poults from a hatchery. They are too hybridized and inbred to breed. Second, they are bred to have a lot of breast meat and to mature quickly, so many times they have the same problems that broiler chickens do. Their puny little legs cannot support the weight of the bird and their legs break. Or, they sit at a feeder and eat until they have a heart attack. The big agribusiness turkey growers don't care about either of those things, they are interested in quick growth and profit. For small independents, though, those traits are not conducive to raising flocks year after year. Annie
...See More
Turkey--Favorite Brand?
Q
Comments (25)
I am going to brine mine, and so I ordered two free-range (organic..see "expensive") from the natural grocer here (Tx panhandle). I didn't want to add more salt to something already injected with salty solution. The turkeys at our local store are .37 a pound....so yes, you can get turkeys, and big ones, under $8. Some are, indeed, about $4. I, on the other hand, am paying $1.89 a pound. Crazy? Probably. But if I hadn't planned on the brining, I might think differently. However, I will be purchasing a couple of smaller ones to roast for the broth for my dressing. Interesting how the prices differ....I got the "cheapest" ones at the natural food store.....some of them are up to $2.89 a pound! And, I've not really had a bad turkey, either, so there ya go. Last year was the first time we had done the brining thing and vowed never to go back! My main problem is trying to figure out what else to serve (main dish wise) for DH...he HATES turkey! Doesn't want ham, either. Thankfully, we have a HUGE family, so it won't go to waste! Happy Turkey Day, all!
...See More
lindac
17 years ago
If you are talking frozen turkey and unless you get a "direct from the grower" bird I think that's best...
the supermarket brand is best....less "solution" and most often cheaper.
However I cooked a Butterball last Sunday and it was really very good. But the only reason I bought it is it was $.69 a pound and I put it in the freezer!
Linda C
annie1992
17 years ago
I usually get a fresh turkey from a local Amish farmer, nothing at all like Butterball or Honeysuckle.

I just like the fresh ones, no preservatives, no "flavor enhancers", just good old fashioned turkey, hanging out in the yard and eating bugs and whatever it can find. It's a different flavor than the turkeys raised in a big barn and eating only the meal they are fed.

Annie
centralcacyclist
17 years ago
After eating a few free range birds I find Butterball birds to taste odd. They are "enhanced" with injected solutions that I don't care for. I'd look for a store brand "natural" or free range bird.
vacuumfreak
17 years ago
I got a turkey for a neighbor at Aldi yesterday... it was 11 pounds for 8.99 (no tax on top if it, I don't know if it was already included or what)...

They had a much larger one there, but I didn't notice the price because I wasn't even considering one that big. But, they were Butterball brand!
deborah_ps
17 years ago
I'm unable to get a fresh turkey and thought I'd try one of Trader Joes Organic turkeys. A "natural sea salt" brined at $1.79 per lb. or the Kosher salt brined at $2.29 per lb.
I didn't realize that they would be pre brined and now am rethinking my options. Is it worth paying the extra money for either one or should I just buy a house brand grocery store one for a lot less per pound?
deborah_ps
17 years ago
I'm unable to get a fresh turkey and thought I'd try one of Trader Joes Organic turkeys. A "natural sea salt" brined at $1.79 per lb. or the Kosher salt brined at $2.29 per lb.
I didn't realize that they would be pre brined and now am rethinking my options. Is it worth paying the extra money for either one or should I just buy a house brand grocery store one for a lot less per pound?
kellyeng
17 years ago
I was going with organic free-range but then I ran across the Cook's Illustrated turkey taste test. They taste tested and had the turkeys lab tested as well. They found that the tastiest turkeys had higher levels of fat and salt. I decided to go with the kosher turkey from kosherkaddy.com. It's more expensive ($3.89/lb.) plus shipping but my curiosity got the better of me.

I'll report back after TG!

Here is a link that might be useful: Turkey Taste Test
daylilydayzed
17 years ago
I bought a turkey from my local Publix(one mile from house) for .69 cent a pound last week. All other stores , Aldi included were charging more per pound. I find that Publix brands are just as good quality as name brands. I am not saying they are but I think they are equal to them in my opinion.
kathleenca
17 years ago
For years, I bought the frozen Butterball-type or store brand. After reading articles & comments, about four years ago I started buying the fresh (& usually free-range) turkey. I was resistant at first because the cost was more, but then reasoned that I didn't buy the cheapest beef, chicken, etc., so why was I focusing on the cheapest turkey?

The flavor & moisture is so much better in the fresh turkeys that I will not go back to frozen. Additionally, while I have not wet-brined a turkey, this year I plan to pre-salt/salt-brine it as written up in last month's Bon Appetit & the LA Times of Nov 19. ann_t discussed it & included the technique/recipe at the end of October.

Here is a link that might be useful: Best turkey techniques
centralcacyclist
17 years ago
I have always purchased Willie Birds in the past but this year I am going to cook a Diestel turkey. My local grocer carries them so I don't have to order it. I'll report back. I bet Granjan is familiar with Diestel.

Here is a link that might be useful: Diestel
robynpa
17 years ago
If you have a Jewish grocery try there. The kosher turkeys are really good.
jojoco
17 years ago
Plainville Turkeys are from my neck of the woods. While they are outstanding, I've found the best improvement over past years was the addition of a meat thermometer with an alarm. Really, forget the turkey and invest in a good thermometer.
Jo

What brand of turkey to buy?

Comments (14)

gardenguru1950

gardenguru1950

Related Discussions

lindac

annie1992

centralcacyclist

vacuumfreak

deborah_ps

deborah_ps

kellyeng

daylilydayzed

kathleenca

centralcacyclist

robynpa

jojoco

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US