Metal pie pans: aluminum or stainless steel?

13 years ago

I've been unable to find 9" metal pie pans in local stores, and so I'm going to have to order them from Amazon. I did find 10" aluminum pie pans at Surfas for $3.55 each, but 10" pans will not fit in my pie saver, and I want 9" pies anyway. I probably should have checked thrift stores.

I was reading reviews at Amazon and felt I could not trust some of them. Anyway, the steel pans are much more expensive, and I wonder if they distribute heat as well as the aluminum ones. I believe the one metal one I have is steel, and it seems to work fine, but the aluminum is so much less expensive, and I do need to get two of them. I felt that if Surfas sold aluminum pans, then those are probably preferable. The metal pie pan I have has "ears" on the sides for use as handles, and this makes it very difficult to fit in the pie saver - I want just simple round pans.

Has anyone used silicon crust shields?

Lars

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (11)

claire_de_luna
13 years ago
Lars, don't buy the stainless steel pie plate. If it's not stainless, but regular steel, that would be different, which would conduct heat better than stainless (although it would rust unless it were enameled.) I know this because the first cake pans I bought 30 years ago were stainless steel, and I always had trouble with them. They simply don't conduct heat as well. (Neither does SS cookware.) Once I switched to aluminum...No Problem! Of course, you didn't ask but if you want to buy a high-end pie plate, look for a copper one that's lined with tin. Works great every time!
Lars
Original Author
13 years ago
Thanks, Claire. I think I will order the aluminum pans. I believe the pan I have is regular steel that is enameled. I had a bunch of steel pans that rusted, like you said, and I got rid of those, which is why I now have a shortage of metal pans.

As for the copper lined with tin - what I found was beautiful, but it did not have a lip for the edge of the crust, and I need that!

Still wondering about the silicon crust shields, however.

Lars
Related Discussions
Aluminum Clad Stainless Steel
Q
Comments (13)
Breasley, I think you have it backwards. Clad cookware usually means stainless, with a layer of aluminum (or copper, on really high end stuff, or both, sometimes) sandwiched between the SS. This serves several purposes, the most important of which is evening out the heat so there are no hot spots. The better pieces have the nonferrous layer rolled a little up the sides, in a tub-like effect. If you haven't used stainless cookware before, there are a couple of things to keep in mind. First and foremost, read, and understand, the manufacturer's instructions for use and cleaning. Never use high heat. It's unnecessary, to begin with, and can cause problems with the finish ranging from staining to separation of the laminates. Do not put stainless in the dishwasher unless the manufacturer specifically says you can. When buying stainless, get items with metal handles, so they can be used on the range or in the oven. But here's a strange thing: Because it's totally made of metal, stainless can be used on top of the range or in the oven. However, some makers caution to _not_ use their products under the broiler. Almost all manufacturers, and certainly all the high-end ones, offer sets. While there may be some cost savings with sets, buying them is usually not a good idea, because they may not have the products that fit your cooking style. It's better to buy the ones you need, from open stock. Keep in mind, too, that you might find Brand A's skillets more to your liking, while Brand B's sauce pans fit you better. Obviously, you cannot mix and match with sets. There are lots of great companies out there, making all sorts of stainless cookware across the full spectrum of prices. I won't make any recomendations except to point out that in my experience All-Clad's customer service ranges from slim to non-existent. As a result, I'll never have another All-Clad product in my house. FWIW, Emerilware is made by All-Clad (in China, though, not domestically), so I'll never buy any of that, either.
...See More
water stains on metal Mikasa platter (stainless steel or chrome?)
Q
Comments (1)
I clean my stainless steel pans with a powdered product called Cameo, and it even safely removes marks from high heat, but doesn't marr the polished finish. I'd also check in at the local True Value Store (or other hardware stores) and see if they happen to have something that is made for chrome/stainless. An old-fashioned cleaner (often used for cleaning chrome faucets) is to mix 4 t. table salt into 1/2 c. white vinegar. Dissolve salt in vinegar and apply with a sponge or soft colth. Rinse. I'd try this on the back first, so you don't do more damage - just in case.... -Grainlady
...See More
Stainless Steel Electric Fry Pans as seen used at Costco?
Q
Comments (4)
I saw an all stainless square one without the dreaded non-stick at,of all places, Home Depot tonite. It was a brand I never heard of but seemed well built and sturdier than the aluminum teflon coated ones. All our Walmarts only have the non-stick ones. Target is supposed to carry a round one by West Bend but I've never seen one off line.
...See More
All clad stainless roasting pan - aluminum core?
Q
Comments (12)
Aluminum adds conductivity, stainless adds strength and protects from reactivity. Whether a pan actually warps also depends on the relative thicknesses of the metals. Thin stainless will warp more than thick stainless. Effectively clad stainless/aluminum combinations should not warp when used as directed, if the metallurgy and engineering are done properly. All-Clad's claim to fame is its metallurgy. I've never had a problem with warping when using AC stovetop products, although I do not care for the handle design, which is the main reason I no longer use them. I do believe the SS roaster, however, is a vastly overpriced product that does not perform as promised. Had I bought it, I would return it, too.
...See More
soonergrandmom
13 years ago
My favorite pie plates are made by Corning and they fit perfectly in my four pie servers. LOL I know, who needs four? I shouldn't admit it but have lots more pie plates than that.
wizardnm
13 years ago
My favorite pie plates are glass. I have aluminum, ironstone and even Emile Henery pie plates. But I really think the Pyrex is the all around winner.

Nancy

Here is a link that might be useful: This is my favorite
jimster
13 years ago
Pie crust shields seem to me one of the better applications of silicone in bakeware. Admittedly, I have used no silicone bakeware. Containers, such as baking pans seem floppy, not a desirable attribute IMO. The floppiness would seem to be an asset in crust shields and this is consistent with the customer reviews on Amazon.

Lars, I nominate you for guinea pig. Get some and report back. ;-)

Jim
dcarch7 d c f l a s h 7 @ y a h o o . c o m
13 years ago
Poor conductor of heat may not be a bad thing for pie making.

I go for glass or stainless steel also because you can use oven cleaner on them, which you cannot if you have aluminum.

Silicone crust shield is great. After all, crust is all about pie eating. Burned crust is not very nice.

dcarch
Jasdip
13 years ago
Speaking of silicone, I saw a loaf pan on the weekend that was silicone, but the handles were reinforced with metal for ease of handling. The whole thing was sturdier, not so floppy.
Lars
Original Author
13 years ago
Okay, I'll get the silicone crust shields and report back. I already have four glass pie pans, and I only use those for pies that have crumb crusts or other pre-baked pie crusts. For the regular pie crust, I prefer using the metal pan because I like the way the bottom crust comes out, compared to the Pyrex pans.

I used to have both 8" and 9" pie pans, but the 8" appear to have been phased out when I wasn't looking. Now I see more 10" pans.

As for silicone, I have a Madeleine pan that I use for making chocolate candy but rarely for Madeleines. Silicone is ideal for chocolate.

Lars
jessyf
13 years ago
When I see 'aluminum pie pan', I see Marie Callendars pies. Just a thought if you have any around.
Lars
Original Author
13 years ago
This is the kind of pie pan I was talking about. I don't know what kind of pans Marie C has, but I need heavy aluminum. The 10" pans at Surfas were cheaper than the Amazon price, and so I'm a bit upset that they did not have the 9" size. They did say that others had asked for 9" metal pie pans, and so I'm not the only one looking for them. They might get some in their next shipment, however. I would expect Marie C to use disposable pans.

Lars
jessyf
13 years ago
Marie C doesn't use disposable. You get 50 cents back (or is it 25 cents?) when you return them because they reuse them. The picture looks like they are the same weight, but MC isn't non-stick. I'd stop by restaurant, ask to look at an empty pie tin, see if it might work, and buy a couple of pies bwhahaha, keep the pans.

I just weighed one of mine (guests who want to bring dessert) - it weighs one ounce. And I would guess it is stainless steel, but I'm not sure.

Metal pie pans: aluminum or stainless steel?

Comments (11)

claire_de_luna

Lars
Original Author

Related Discussions

soonergrandmom

wizardnm

jimster

dcarch7 d c f l a s h 7 @ y a h o o . c o m

Jasdip

Lars
Original Author

jessyf

Lars
Original Author

jessyf

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Metal pie pans: aluminum or stainless steel?

Comments (11)

LarsOriginal Author

Related Discussions

LarsOriginal Author

LarsOriginal Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Lars
Original Author

Lars
Original Author

Lars
Original Author