Incredible show last night. I think it was the best show so far. I was thoroughly entertained. For the first time, Sanjaya wasn't bad. His performance was much better than anything he's done before. The person who really bothers me and I think could very well be booted off tonight is Phil Stacey. He was the first one to perform. I just don't like him. Something about that guy really bothers me? And I think that out of all the performances last night, his was the weakest. Until Sanjaya's performance last night, I thought he should be the one to go. Guess we'll find out tonight. I agree that LaKisha should have listened to Lulu. I wasn't as impressed by her last night as I usually am. I'm adding Jordin to my favs too. And I rather like Haley, the girl with the mole and thought she was pretty good last night, though not the best. But I don't think she can win this. Melinda is just awesome as far as I'm concerned. I think she'll do well wheather she wins this or not. I look forward to her performances every week. Joy

Howdie all...very intersting night! First of all, what the heck was up with interviewing the families?? I get that they were there to support the singers but I think at this stage, where most of them are done, its really not neccesary to meet the family so to speak...and I just felt terrible for Steven who had no one there. I guess they were stretching for time. So here is the list for 2/17 in order... Jackie (a little more satisfaction) A lot of energy and she could really work the crowd but her gritty voice did not work for this song. I was disappointed with Jackie and was really hoping she did better. Ricky (a song for you) the fellow looked so nervous. His voice was strong! I liked him but I don't think he has the look or attitude-but maybe that what they are looking for. Alexis (Never loved a man) well I liked her a lot but I am not buying the soul part one bit. I would like to see her sing more her age. She also looked very stiff-I didn't think she was having fun. Her dad scared me. Brent (hicktown) I think this guy was really having fun. It was a good song for him and his voice was good. He is really cute too 'wink' I found him appealing and likable. Stevie (you belong to me) oh baby what a shame. The poor thing really could not pull it off. I think she knew it too...I think its her age-maybe keep at it and revisit AI in a year or 2. Anoop (angel of mine) well I really like this guy and I really love this song but for me it was not a great fit...I think he is better suited for somethink like matchbox 20 or jet...more up tempo, cutting edge. He has a great look. Casey (everything you do magic) was it me or was she off key the entire song? I think she is a much better singer then she appeared last night. She is beautiful and I hope she works on her voice and trys again in a few years. Michael (i don't wanna be) another guy I really want to like but his singing is just so so for me. I like his grit and determination but I really can't see him going on to do broadway week or 50's 60's week. AnnMarie (natural woman) oooh one of my all time favorite songs and she did it well. Again I think she had a lot of nerves going on and it would have been better if she had relaxed a bit. I like her-very classy young lady. Steven (rock with you) mmm I really wanted to like this guy too but I was let down, wrong song-should have done a ballad to showcase his smooth voice. I really like his hair!! Tatiana (savin all my lovin) all I can say is fake fake fake! She so wanted to go loco but held herself back. I wasn't blown away by her voice either...like Randy said there were parts that were good but no consistancy. I would have rather seen her do something latino to highlight her charisma but nada...adios! Danny (hero) well he rocked to say the least! He has a great voice and an endearing quality. I almost can't wait to hear him try new types of music...see him get jazzy ect...He has a great style and very likable. Not sure how America is going to vote but my choices are Danny, Anoop and Alexis....Michael may get a wildcard vote later on. All in all I was surprized how poorly some did...plus I wish they would can the family part and focus on the singer alone. Oh and what was Paula a lot loopier last night?? She had a lot of trouble stringing her thoughts together and looked as if she forgot what she was saying mid sentance?? They need to lose her (jmho) Cheers! Susie

Ok, so Kelly is just a bigger girl...who cares??????? There are lots of people heavier out there than her, and I'm sure none of them want to hear that they've "let themselves go". Gosh, I'd hate for you to see me right now, 25lbs heavier than I want to be. And baby weight isn't my problem, that's all gone! Kelly is a singer, not a runway model. So she's gained a few lbs. Maybe she could use some working out, but don't we all have things we should be doing and don't? And I dont think she's anywhere near a 16-18!

With that stupid situation going on with "vote for the worst" anything can happen. (Vote for the worst dot com)While the site gurus are sticking with voting for Tim Urban, anyone that doesn't really understand what the site is about may vote for who they think is the worst from last night. This can really skew the votes, and is likely why Big Mike was in trouble last week. I really don't think any one of the bunch is that much of a standout, but I do agree that Andrew was pathetic last night. I hope he goes home as he has bored me for weeks now. Casey bores me too, but I know he is popular so I would doubt he'll go anywhere. Aaron was coming along but sure didn't show much stage presence last night. It will be interesting to see how it all plays out, and don't forget, the judges have used their one save for the season, so anyone could go home now. Suzan J