I love the Oakwood Manor paint (darker paint) with the Lighter drapes.
I really love the way the lighter drapes look with that paisley fabric and both will look awesome against the darker wall.
That's my vote!

I had just made my decision and see Lorriekay picked the exact same ones. So that's two of us. I just thing it's a warmer look for a room that doesn't get too much light.

How much of your room is wall, and how much will be drapes? I like the darker drapes with that fabric. They're more of a contrast to either paint, and maybe a warmer, richer look overall.

The lighter drapes would reflect more light, so if they'll be covering a large amount of wall, I'd probably go with those.

ps I bought a tablecloth in sort of a muted version of your fabric at LNT's closeout. I can't wait to use it.

My DR is 15' x 12'. The window is 72" wide by 48" high. I will have a panel on either side of the window. Hope this helps. My carpet is a mixed beige. Furniture is dark walnut.

I have my kitchen island painted BM Barbados Sand along with a free standing china hutch. It's ivory and I think it would be bland on a wall. I would choose the darker shade of Oakwood Manor for wall color. This still won't be a dark color but will have more depth.

From the way they look on my monitor, I like the Oakwood Manor paint with the Antique drapes.

Thanks everyone for your opinion. boysrus, thanks for the tip on the paint. It looks like Oakwood Manor wins. I still can't decide on the drapes though. I think I'll order both and hang them after the painting's done and then I'll decide.

Love the Oakwood Manor and Antique drapes! They provide more contrast and will look great with those dining room chairs you redid so beautifully. Looking forward to more pics!