I'm making Sharon's Plain Italian Tomato Sauce and it's VERY thin. It has 15 more minutes to cook and I can't imagine using it as a sauce in it's present state. How thick should it be and what would you use a very thin sauce with? It's almost drinkable. like a thick slushy drink. A response would be appreciated.
That's the way it's supposed to be.... Don't rinse your pasta....put on the lovely fresh sauce.....and sop up the juice with a good bread. All tomato sauce is not sludgy and thick and sits in a pile on top of the pasta. The tomato sauce that I have eaten in Italy is more like Sharon's than what is often made here.
Thanks, LindaC. I don't remember the thinness of sauce in Italy but I do remember that Americans tend to pile on the sauce. I never got in the habit of rinsing my pasta, one good thing in my favor. Guess I'll go ahead and 'jar' it up and process it. Thanks again.
Jude it all has to do with the fresh tomatoes. Some years they are thicker and some thinner.
My canned tomatoes are not a sauce per se, I don't recall ever saying it was but perhaps I did. Rather they are a base for many sauces or wonderful just as is, tossed with pasta, or even used as the base for a Bloody Mary!
It's not about the recipe, it's all about the years tomato crop.
Jude, although I wouldn't do it, I'm not against using a bit of tomato paste to thicken the tomatoes when you actually go to use it for a pasta sauce. However, please don't add any tomato paste to the sauce before canning it. It can change the ratio and make it unsafe for canning.
Folks I have already 'jarred' it and even though it's thin, it tastes great and if I had had the 'Mary'on hand I probably would have mixed it up.
Sharon I was only going by the name of the recipe as posted. I always assume I have done something wrong. How is that for confidence!!!!! I may just mark it private stock! I think the tomatoes may have had a lot to do with it and thanks for pointing that out.
Jude : I was talking about making the Sauce a little thicker.
Not a thick sludge that sits in a pile, on top of the Pasta. Never in my Lifetime, have I heard Spaghetti Sauce described in this way.
I think all the Italian Immigrants who made Sauce all these years , thicker and thinner, came from Italy. That's where they learned to make it !!!!! and carried on the tradition.
Chase: is right, I wouldn't add Tomato Paste to your sauce before canning. Lou
When you go to use it cook it down some more and add some mushrooms, peppers etc. A bit of pate if you need to but try tossing your pasta in it, just to coat and top with some fresh parm.
My favourite way to use it is as Putenesca (sp? and to lazy to check) sauce, the tomato sauce, capers, finley minced anchovies, chopped black olives and a few red pepper flakes. Simmer for a bit and then toss the sauce with pasta , don't drwon the pasta just toss it...oh man!
It's aslo a fabulous base for soup. Just add equal amounts of chicken broth to the tomato sauce, throw in some small pasta shapes , some chopped spinach and some sauted Italian sausage. YUM!
Every time I see a post about Sharon's tomato sauce, I kick myself for not canning a batch myself. Her sauce is the best homemade tomato sauce I have had. THE BEST!!!! As long as you have jars of this sauce in your pantry you won't have to resort to using canned tomatoes. Anything that you would use canned tomatoes in use this sauce. It will make everything better.
Y'all are starving me to death and I just finished eating supper. Sharon thanks for the serving suggestions. I didn't have enough tomatoes to make the whole recipe but I carefully measured the ingredients and cut it in half. Our late crop of tomatoes is just coming in, no where near the quantity of the first crop but you can bet your sweet Bippy (whatever that is)that I'll be making more.
I've been canning Annie's Salsa for the last 2 days and I am "whupped". Old people get tired easy.LOL My last batch of Annie's salsa is pretty dang hot. I used one habanero and 2 jalapeno's and I'm going to mark it AKH for A$$ Kickin' Hot.
I think it's time for me to call it a day. Oh, and Ann, thanks for the endorsement.
Last weekend I canned half of the half recipe that was posted. Starting out with 12 cups of peeled smooshed tomatoes and the appropriate amounts of other ingredients, I cooked it down until I had a little more than eight cups of sauce. I wanted it a little thicker thinking I would most likely add some red wine to it when I use it (is that sacrilege?). Max picked even more tomatoes today and I will not cook the next batch down so much. It is delicious. I used about half a cup of the leftover that wasn't enough to fill a jar tonight to finish off some sauteed zucchini and onion wedges. it was so good - with a little shredded parm it could hae been my whole meal.
Sharon, I love Puttanesca and I will definitely use some that way.
In Italy -- as in America -- tomato sauces are many and varied.
Everything from chopped fresh, unpeeled tomatoes ("alla rustica" or "il pomodoro") to peeled, seeded tomatoes cooked for a gazillion hours and made thick and rich as in "marinara" ("sludgy and thick"? -- heavens!).
Sauces can be simply "canned" tomatoes or "canned" tomatoes not-so-simply with a few other seasonings before somehow getting it to or into the pasta.
All very likeable, as far as I'm concerned. But one thing I've never liked: a sauce made watery from watery tomatoes or undrained pasta. Sopping it up with bread ain't the answer in my book.
If you already have it canned, adjust for that thinness later if a recipe calls for something thicker. In other words, cook it a little more later.
From others' comments, it sounds to me as if you have a wonderfully tasty tomato sauce.
a few years back. I used it as is and was glad I did - it was delicious, tasting very much like fresh tomatoes. I second what's been recommended - that you try the sauce first before adding anything to it. Yum!
I think "sludgy" might well describe some commercial sauces, particularly those with additives and various kinds of thickeners. But sauces "au naturel" are quite a different thing, regardless of their density.
The one thing that strikes me about Italian sauces is the pasta is foremost and the sauce is a much smaller component than with many Italian-American dishes.
lindac
jude31Original Author
Related Discussions
Favorite tomato sauce?
Q
Tweaking chili sauce?
Q
Tomato Sauce
Q
Cookalong #4 - Basil
Q
User
hawk307
User
jude31Original Author
hawk307
User
User
jude31Original Author
lsr2002
gardenguru1950
lorijean44
readinglady