I did a massive months long search for the chairs we bought and discovered most sites will carry the same chair and just attach a different style name to it. With that in mind, the best thing you can do is forget about which site you're looking on and just focus on finding a style you like. Once you do then find the best price at a store that offers them. Be sure that where ever you buy from has an easy return policy and is responsive if there is a problem. I found there were a lot of "catches" in the return policies with many of the online only stores and didn't want to deal with that. So my buying criteria insisted on there being a store front locally. The best deal offered for what we wanted was at of all places Kohl's! They had the best price and a very easy return policy as well plus they shipped quick and were here in no time at all.

I got mine from Target.com. They came in 2 days fully assembled, and have held up well against my 3 kids the last 4 1/2 years.