If you're getting 2500 - 3000 lumens per square foot, that should be plenty. Keeps the plants within inches of the lights.

Don't do a recessed light above the sink, you will get shadows. Don't do ONLY a recessed light above the sink. I also used pretty glass tile in the showers and it looks really nice when illuminated with 2 lights and dimmed just a bit. Ambiance lighting for when guests use the full bath downstairs! That sounds so nice! Two additional thoughts, not related to the above note: As you plan your lighting, consider your color scheme. If you're going with today's trendy lots-of-white, maybe-some-gray color scheme, light's going to bounce off those stark whites and could feel harsh. On the other hand, if you're using a softer, darker color scheme, those darker colors will "absorb" some of the light; so you'd need to ask whether you'd need more light fixtures. I like to read in the tub, so I definitely plan to have a light of some sort "behind me" for that purpose.

@jessicabaskerville, Given the extra ceiling height, your open area plan, and overall island size I suggest using 3 pendants of the size you're currently considering. See attached image for approximate layout. Keep the height so anyone standing at the island can see through to other spaces un-obstructed by the base of the pendants. The island pendants should be on a separate dimmer for better overall control of kitchen lighting. Also, be careful of your bulb choice since bare bulbs will produce some glare (another reason to use a separate dimmer). Please post pics when your project is completed.

My research and experience say 450 lumens at the counter for task lighting. The light has to be placed in front of the person working at the counter to avoid casting a shadow over the stuff you're chopping with a sharp knife. Sizing the bulb requires consideration of the ceiling height for distance, the beam spread as a spot of 20* or 40* and the color temperature of say 3000k with good CRI like 90 for color accuracy. Juno has Gen2 2" can fixtures that are up there in price produce 1000 lumens at the bulb. If you have upper cabinets led strip undercabinet lights can add to overhead lighting. LED 17.5w A19(regular screw-in bulb format) 100w equivalent bulbs in 5-6" white recessed can fixtures($15) are the least expensive. 4 dimmable Feit bulbs are $7 at Costco in my state. These make good ambient lighting in bedrooms and kitchens. Maybe four for your 237sqft space. You can use them for flood overhead task lighting for a very affordable plan.