Do Electrical Switches Need to be Grounded?

13 years ago

We just moved into a new house two weeks ago. On our second day at the new house, an electrician who was installing light fixtures for us told us that the light switches were not grounded. He said that it was against code and he was amazed that they weren't grounded given the electrocution/fire risk. He offered to fix them for us for $15 apiece, and we probably have 40 switches in the house, so it was definitely going to be costly.

I didn't know this electrician well, so I decided to get a second opinion. The second electrician (recommended by my realtor) told me that the code now requires switches to be grounded, but this is a new requirement put in place after my house was built. He said that the code requirement is a safety precaution, but he did not recommend retrofitting the switches. On the other hand, he also works with my realtor, who has an incentive not to have any issues with the house crop up after the closing.

Given the two different opinions, I am at a bit of a loss. I don't have an electrician in this area who I trust. I checked with the inspector, but he said that the norm is not to take off the switch plates and check for grounding and he didn't have any additional advice for me. Does anyone have any advice on how I should proceed and whether this is in fact a safety risk that I should spend a bunch of money to fix?

Thanks,

Jessica

Featured Answer

David

13 years ago

All new circuits are expected to have proper grounding. Pre-existing circuits can be left as is.

It is more prudent to leave the existing circuits as is for now. There may be other issues (eg- fraying/ crumbling insulation, inadequate circuits, aluminium wiring, improper outlet grounding, etc).

At some later point in time, when you decide to upgrade the service panel / change the wiring (if it is aluminium or it is really old)/ add additional wiring, fix the circuits.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (7)

David
13 years ago
Did the electrician say how each switch would be fixed for $15 per switch?

I would expect additional costs to be tacked on for unexpected issues that were uncovered.

It would be better to plan on re-wiring the entire house from the service panel than to allow spot fixes if you must have everything conform to the latest electrical code.
Related Discussions
When and How to Switch Citrus from In-ground to Containers?
Q
Comments (3)
Wait until late summer and root prune with a sharp spade. Think of an octagon or stop sign. You'll make 4 plunge cuts at the N,S,E,W sides in late summer. In late fall, make 4 more plunge cuts that represent the other 4 sides of the octagon - Ne,Nw,Sw,Se. Sever the roots a couple of inches outside of where the original root mass was. This will force the roots to 'back-bud' and grow more roots closer to the trunk so when you lift it in spring it will be able to sustain itself. Make sure you water as required after root pruning. When you lift & pot it up in spring of '11, treat it like any other citrus repot and remove wedges of roots totaling about half of the roots. Complete the repot in the spring of '12. Al
...See More
Electrical light switch question-Can this be done?
Q
Comments (13)
If there is attic above the kitchen wall and no 2nd story to pass through. Running new wire shouldn't be bad at all. Insteon allows you to change light switching without wiring. A module would be placed in each light on different addresses. The switch box would then have insteon switches that send the command wirelessly to the module. It would cost 100 for the 2 switches and 40 per light plus a couple hours to put them in. In some situations, these costly materials beet cutting sheet rock and fishing new wires. In your case it sounds like a new wire is possible.
...See More
Do I have ground wires coming to my electric panel?
Q
Comments (10)
Does not matter if 'ground' is created by the conduit. Code says a ground wire must be inside that conduit. Because conduit is not a reliable connection. Absolutely wrong. Article 250.118 Types of Equipment Grounding Conductors specifically permits either a copper, aluminum, or copper clad conductor OR Rigid (RMC), Intermediate (IMC), EMT conduits. The handbook even amplifies on a separate grounding conductor not being required in such conduit. Plus there are more things certain flexible conduits (in some circumstances), cable trays, AC cable, etc.... All in all there are 14 things listed (a separate conductor as well as 13 other things that can suffice).
...See More
Dimmer Switches...do I need to discuss it NOW while eletrical
Q
Comments (6)
Actually it can affect it during the rough in. If you know where you want dimmers exactly they should make sure that it's going to work at the location. The most common run of the mill dimmers are rated at 600w and 1000w. Say you have a three gang box and you want all three switches to be dimmers. If the load of all three switches requires you to use 1000w dimmers at each location, it could be impossible. The dimmers have "fins" on the sides of them that act as heat sinks. In order to get three dimmers to fit correctly side by side some fins have to be removed. Removing them, lowers the load that each switch can handle. So some planning should be thought out and some switches may need to be moved so they are not side by side other dimmers. Also if you are doing smart switching, some require a neutral. If you're under the 2011 code this shouldn't be an issue as it's now required at every switch.
...See More
jerickson100
Original Author
13 years ago
Just to clarify, this is not an old home - it was built in 2003, so the rest of the wiring should be fine. The electrician says he just needs to attach a small piece of the ground wire to the existing grounds and
attach that to the green screw on the switch, so it should be pretty easy. There are just so many switches that it will add up so I hate to spend the money if there is not a real risk of leaving it as is. The outlets are all grounded -- it is just the switches that are not grounded.

Thanks again!
texaskitchentoo
13 years ago
I can't believe a house built in 2003, the same year as my house, passed inspection without having the switches properly grounded. Makes you wonder at the value of the local building inspector. It almost sounds like someone cut the ground wire instead of connecting it to the ground screw. it only takes a minute. Sloppy. That being said, if the house does have 12/2 romex the ground wire is there, you can probably just attach them yourself. if its been cut off you may have to attach a pigtail to reach the switch.
smakcanada
5 years ago
I have this same question. My house is BRAND NEW. I wanted to add a dimmer switch (which I've done before in other houses) so I opened a 3 switch bank of light switches in my kitchen and was surprised to find that the green wires on all 3 switches did NOT have copper wires attached. In the back of the box all the copper wires are bundled together and capped together. The box is grey plastic. Q: Is there some reason why the switches aren't grounded? I live in Ontario, Canada.
zver11
5 years ago
From a practicality point of view (and code in some places), switches do not have to be grounded if the junction box is metal and the junction box is grounded. All switches make contact with the junction box through the plate they are screwed in with. Even if this not the case, there is no real shock or fire risk as long as the faceplate is nonconducting. I would definitely get the repair done if the faceplates are metal(or replace the faceplates with plastic)
smakcanada
5 years ago
zver11: thanks for your post. I ended up having an electrician come in & light switches DON'T need to be grounded - receptacles DO. She replaced the switch in about 5 minutes. I was correct that there was no problem with the LED 'pot' lights (thank goodness); it was just a faulty switch. The reason I couldn't figure it out was that the wire I thought was white was spray painted! She scraped all the paint off and she put plastic?rubber? little square 'washers' under all the screws. I'm happy & it was an inexpensive fix and now I have peace of mind as well as light!

Do Electrical Switches Need to be Grounded?

David

Comments (7)

David

Related Discussions

jerickson100
Original Author

texaskitchentoo

smakcanada

zver11

smakcanada

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Do Electrical Switches Need to be Grounded?

David

Comments (7)

David

Related Discussions

jerickson100Original Author

texaskitchentoo

smakcanada

zver11

smakcanada

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

jerickson100
Original Author