Banana Pudding

14 years ago

Usually when I make banana pudding, it rarely has time to chill before it's consumed. (patience is not one of my best things)

I love to make some for a large family gathering this weekend and I'm wondering just how far in advance I could make it...

Do soggy cookies make the dish or ruin the dish?

Featured Answer

lindac

14 years ago

Seems to me that banana pudding is different for those living below the Mason Dixon line....
Growing up banana pudding was home made cornstarch custard with bananas in it....chilled and served with whipped cream. Then I met someone whose mother layered it with vanilla wafers....and it was made ahead so it was sort of a vanilla version of the icebox cake made with the boxed chocolate wafers.
Then I come here and find that some make it like a banana cream pie with meringue and with the cookies in the middle.
I like it anyway you do it!....but do prefer it cold.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (13)

lindac
14 years ago
I like the cookies soggy.....otherwise it's just pudding, bananas and boxed cookies.
teresa_nc7
14 years ago
The problem with banana pudding made ahead: you must keep it chilled, so the meringue weeps and the bananas can get too ripe and start turning soft and brown.

I'd make it the morning of the day you want to serve it - just my opinion.

Teresa
Related Discussions
MIL's banana pudding recipe
Q
Comments (27)
here is the recipe I use at work. 2 cups milk 1/3 cup sugar 1/4 cup cornstarch 4 egg yolks sprinkle of salt Mix all the ingredients together in a microwave safe bowl. I use a 2 quart pyrex glass bowl. Microwave for 2 minutes and stir. Repeat this 2 or 3 more times. It depends upon your microwave as how long it will take. We only have a small one at work. I dont know the wattage. Peel and slice your bananas into 7up or orange juice to prevent them from turning black to fast. Let set for a couple of minutes and drain real well and add to pudding mixture. Put into a baked pie shell or a graham cracker crust. Top with meringue made with the remaining 4 egg whites and bake at 400 degrees for 13 minutes or until desired color. Or you can skip the meringue and use whip cream on top. The salt may be omitted, all it is for is that it takes the really sweet taste out of it and makes it taste much better. THIS SAME RECIPE MAY BE USED FOR COCONUT CREAM PIE.THE ONLY DIFFERENCE IS THAT YOU OMIT THE BANANAS AND ADD A 1/3 CUP OR MORE OF TOASTED COCONUT. IF YOU TOAST THE COCONUT IT GIVES IT A STRONGER FLAVOR. I USE THE MICROWAVE TO TOAST IT. PUT IT ON A PLATE AND MICROWAVE IT UNTIL IT IS CRISP AND BROWNED. BE SURE TO CHECK IT EVERY FEW SECONDS AND STIR IT WHEN YOU CHECK IT OR IT WILL BURN IN ONE SPOT AND NOT BROWN IN THE OTHER SPOTS. THIS IS REALLY EASY. If anyone has any questions or would like a similar recipe for butterscotch pudding please let me know. In fact I was thinking with Marilyn Sues recipe which sounds really good I think my butterscotch recipe might work.
...See More
gonna make banana pudding and a ????
Q
Comments (9)
AND Has anyone tried this: 1 (15 ounce) box Hostess Twinkies 1 (5 ounce) package banana instant pudding 1 1/2 cups milk 2 -3 bananas (sliced) 1 (2 5/8 ounce) box dream whip whipped dessert topping mix (has 2 envelopes of topping 1.3 ounce each) Change Measurements: US : Metric Directions: Prep Time: 15 mins Total Time: 15 mins 1 Split Twinkies lengthwise and lay in 9x13 pan (should use whole box). 2 Prepare instant pudding with 1 1/2 cups milk. 3 Lay sliced bananas over Twinkies in pan and pour pudding over bananas. 4 Prepare 2 envelopes of Dream Whip as per package directions and spread this over the top of pudding. 5 Chill in refrigerator until set (about an hour or longer).
...See More
RECIPE: banana pudding
Q
Comments (2)
Tom--I have made this banana pudding recipe for many years, and my DH thinks it is the best. Very simple; serves 6. Came from the Cotton Country Cookbook published by the Decatur, AL, Junior Service League. BANANA PUDDING 1/2 cup sugar 2 TBS. flour Dash of salt 1 3/4 cups milk 1 egg 1 tsp. vanilla 2 TBS. butter Graham crackers OR vanilla wafers 2 bananas Mix sugar, flour, and salt in top of double boiler. Measure milk and add enough milk to moisten the sugar, flour and salt mixture. With whisk, beat in egg. Turn heat to medium high, adding the rest of milk gradually. Stir constantly with spatula or wooden spoon. Cook until sauce thickens and boils. Take off stove. Add vanilla and butter. Put lid on boiler while butter melts. In a deep casserole dish, put one layer of graham crackers OR vanilla wafers and one layer of sliced bananas. After the butter has melted, stir custard carefully, and spoon the custard (does not need to cool) over the sliced bananas. Make two more layers like the first. Top the pudding with a layer of graham crackers or vanilla wafers. Chill. May add meringue if desired. Makes 6 servings. (COOK'S NOTE: I never use margarine instead of butter, and I always use vanilla wafers. If you're careful and have a nice heavy saucepan, you can get by without using a double boiler. Just stir constantly until custard comes to a boil. I use a 1-qt or a 1 1/2-qt. casserole, and I never have but two layers. Sometimes, I will crumble a few wafers over the top. You can substitute an 8 ounce can of crushed pineapple, drained, (sweetened or in its own juice) for the bananas and have a great pineapple pudding.)
...See More
Can I make the custard for banana pudding today for tomorrow
Q
Comments (7)
I know you’ve all been waiting with bated breath for the outcome. Making the custard ahead worked like a charm! I let it sit out for about 30 minutes (the length of a power nap), then sliced the bananas and completed the recipe. It was a hit! Thanks for all the words of encouragement and help!
...See More
lindac
14 years ago
I don't put meringue on it...I use whipped cream.
And submerged bananas don't brown in 24 hours.
jude31
14 years ago
It's all a matter of opinion. I don't like soggy cookies and I don't EVER use whipped cream, always meringue. And I agree with Teresa, make it the morning of, as close to serving time as you can manage and I personally would not refrigerate it if it's used the same day.
slowlane
14 years ago
Me too--always meringue (else it goes naked) and preferably no soggy cookies. The morning of or, at most, the night before is as early as I like to make it.

I can see the appeal of warm banana pudding, but chilled, especially in the summer, does it for me.
Lars
14 years ago
I've never had banana pudding with meringue - only with whipped cream, and that was below the Mason Dixon line. It has always had vanilla wafers in it, however, sometimes only in the bottom and sometimes in layers.

I would think that if it has meringue, then it is a pie instead of a pudding, but that's just what I'm used to, and I've never had it warm - only chilled. Perhaps the meringue is an Eastern thing.

Lars
murphy_zone7
14 years ago
way back in the day (long ago and far away).....my mom, grandmother, aunts etc all made banana pudding with the cooked pudding using only egg yolks, milk, cornstarch, and sugar, the cooked pudding was layered with bananas and vanilla wafers, the whites (not to be wasted) were used for the meringue, placed on the pudding and browned under the broiler. The bananas always had a "cooked" kind of taste and I never really liked it. It was usually made and served the same day and leftovers were put in the fridge which really made the bananas bad IMO. If you put it together with warm pudding, the wafers will get kinda soft by the time it is served.
Now when I make it I use instant pudding, vanilla extract, cool whip, vanilla wafers, and bananas. NO MERINGUE! Quick, easy, and good. Perfect summertime dessert. It must spend the night in the fridge so those wafers get soft.
Oh this is from BELOW the mason dixon line! LOL I can't remember the last time I saw banana pudding with meringue on it...not even at family reunions, church socials, and other places that southern folk gather.
annie1992
14 years ago
Funny about the differences in toppings. My Grandmother always put meringue on the banana pudding, and she used cookies, but she crumbled homemade sugar cookies into the pan, topped with bananas, homemade pudding and meringue on top.

As Murphy mentioned, the yolks went in the custard and the whites became meringue, maybe just to use the egg whites.

My ex-MIL is from Kentucky and my current SIL is from Tennessee and they both use whipped cream. Well, that's not true, they both use Cool Whip, LOL, the ex-MIL used to use Dream Whip.

Annie
evenshade
14 years ago
Another one from below the Mason Dixon line and it was always meringue. I haven't had it in ages but I love it still warm with the 'Nilla wafers just starting to soften.
teresa_nc7
14 years ago
Just goes to show.....different strokes for different folks!

My mom, my two sisters and I are rather picky when it comes to banana pudding and chicken salad for that matter. We won't eat just *any* banana pudding -- we need to know who made it, how they made it, and when it was made. Same thing with the chicken salad. And some Southerners do not care for chicken salad made with the dark chicken meat included in the recipe. Meh.....I don't mind some dark meat in the chicken salad. Guess I'm just not one of those "refined" Southerners. I never order banana pudding in a restaurant and will only get chicken salad at certain places.

I have a good friend who is known for her banana pudding. She gets up at 5:00 AM to make a big casserole dish of it whenever anyone is celebrating a birthday in her area of the office. Luckily for me, she always calls to tell me the pudding is there or she has been known to bring me a cup full. Good enough to make your eyes roll back in your head!

Teresa
lbpod
14 years ago
Happyintexas, I know EXACTLY what you mean about
consuming the banana pudding before it has been chilled.
I too, think it is best at room temperature, not warm
mind you.

And Annie1992, I didn't realize that there was anyone
on this planet, besides me, that was old enough to
remember Dream Whip. WOW !!!!!
Janet
5 years ago
Can it be made at lunch and leave on counter til supper to eat

Banana Pudding

lindac

Comments (13)

lindac

teresa_nc7

Related Discussions

lindac

jude31

slowlane

Lars

murphy_zone7

annie1992

evenshade

teresa_nc7

lbpod

Janet

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US