Question on Trane XR15 Heat Pump.

14 years ago

I am about to replace my old unit that quit and have to make a decision pretty soon because the heat is tough to take. I have narrowed my choices down to the Trane XR15, Carrier Performance 15 or Bryant Preferred 15. The cheapest quote I have right now is on the Trane. Does anyone know the pros and cons to any of these 3 units? If you were purchasing one of these units yourself, Which would you prefer and why? I have seen where some have made statements as to the noise of the Trane XR15. Is it that much louder than the others? Is it loud enough to be an irritant considering it has to sit next to a bedroom? Your thoughts would be appreciated.

Featured Answer

tigerdunes

14 years ago

I do like the "electronic demand defrost" feature on Trane heat pumps which eliminates the nuisance and unnecessary defrost calls that you get with timed defrost. I believe both the Performance 15 and Preferred 15 HPs have timed defrost.

As you know, noise while it can be measured is strictly subjective from person to person. The new XR15 HP mdl states 76 db while the Performance and Preferred 15 are listed as low as 68 db, depending on mdl size. I have a Trane that is listed at 74 db and can say it is very quiet. It sits outside a bedroom. I do not find it objectionable. Any of these mdls will be quieter than your current mdl. For info, Trane's XL15i is rated at 74 db and has a little better compressor warranty over the XR15.

you do want a stat that has "dehumidify on demand" feature and if you elect either the Performance or Preferred 15, I recommend the "H" mdl for better heating efficiency.

like everything, there are pros and cons.

IMO
Good Luck!

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (8)

classicdave
14 years ago
with out knowing the exact model #s of each system and what thermostat controller is being used there is no way to verify what may be the best deal.

Does the Carrier or Bryant come with the Infinity/Evolution Controller? This would be my deciding factor.

What thermostat is being used with the Trane XR15?

I would way heavily on the contractor, which one you feel would do the best install, which one would meet your needs if you have a problem ect..
Related Discussions
Trane XR15 install - two stage?
Q
Comments (16)
opakm....sorry for the late response. The state rebate information can be found on: http://www.texaspowerfulsmart.org/rebate/ However, it ended right after I had my system installed. I'm sorry. I LOVE my system. I am very happy that I got it. I have noticed a huge difference in the comfort of my home and my utility bill. My bills are around $80-$100 less a month....and I keep my house about 3-4 degrees cooler (about 74-75). I have since added solar screens (highly recommend....as long as you don't mind your house being a bit darker) and some insulation in the attic. I haven't had an electric bill since I've had that installed...and I will try to post how much it all has saved me. Honestly though, it's not all about the cost savings, but the comfort that my family and I have with the new system. Which system did you end up getting? How has it turned out for you?
...See More
Help w/ Trane XR15 Quotes
Q
Comments (13)
Help Â we bought a house built in 1994 with two central air systems. We had to replace the 3T system in 2006 and did so with a Trane. Now the 2T system is gone and we have three confusing quotes. Also, the existing air handler space is narrow only 21.5 inches wide. The old handler is a Tempstar BEA24A model NBH3024SKB2. The quotes are (prices installed w/o Tax credit): Lennox $5757 16 SEER for XC14-024 AND CB27UH-024 AND 10 YEAR WARRANTY REEM $3994 16.5 SEER for 14AJM24A01 and RHLLHM2517JA including $500 for 10 year warranty labor TRANE $6240 20 SEER for 4TTZ0024A and 4TEE3CO3A (but this seems wider than 21.5 inches) 10 year warranty So first since I have a relatively new Trane, IÂd like to also have another Trane just so warranty issues are easier. I think the XL15i should be slightly cheaper and do the job..BUT is there a Trane system with an air handler under 20" wide? How does the REEM stack up against Trane? Bother the version bid and an XL15 system if it can fit? Same question for LennoxÂ With FloridaÂs heavier usage of A/C which is the better system and do you have any alternatives we should consider?? Thx
...See More
Trane (XR15 vs XL16i)
Q
Comments (9)
Thanks TigerDunes. The dealer seemed apprehensive with suggesting the XL16i unit. But I think he was trying to meet my requirement of handling the heavier load during hot summer days and family/friend parties. My understanding is that if it is 95 degrees outside, then the unit should be able to cool the inside of the house to 75 degrees. Is this correct? The 2-stage compressor sounds like a very convenient/flexible feature, but (like you said) the actual implementation/performance appears to not measure up in a real world situation. Maybe Trane still has some work to be done to make this unit a real viable solution. I also realize that adding features can contribute to a more complex unit. A more complex unit can have more parts that can fail. The dealer only mentioned the changing of ductwork between the return and air-handler (from 16in to 18in). But no change in the ductwork from the air handler to the floor vents. Thanks again for all your help. Sincerely,
...See More
Buying a new Trane heat pump ; Some questions
Q
Comments (2)
Brad Have you decided on a 2 ton or 2 1/2 ton system? If going up in size, ductwork should be surveyed to see if it can handle the additional air. The main benefit of the var speed air handler is improved dehumidification in AC cooling plus improved efficiency. There is a less expensive alternative on the var speed air handler and that would be the GAM5 air handler with the high eff blower motor but not var speed. Worth considering. I personally prefer the XR13 HP model over the XB series. To your questions #1 already answered. 2. What mdl air handler was quoted? 3. Pricing on the VS air handler is high 4.you must have an air handler or furnace with evap coil to drive the condenser. Var speed blower motors and high eff blower motors yield better efficiency 5.each increase in a SEER point yields up to 4-5% in electric savings. What size heat strip was quoted? What are you doing now about filtering your return air? Post back. IMO
...See More
golfer1512
14 years ago
I purchased the Trane xr14 over Carrier after researching both brands. I was also told by a tech working on my old york that trane was beter built and suited the coast of Fl where I live. And the tech's company didn't handle Trane and he would buy one. I was sold. It is much quieter than my previous 9 yr old york and it has a cover over the compressor to surpress noise. I read that someone said Trane was all made in the US and that Carrier had parts made in China or Mexico. I didn't know if that is a fact but maybe others can verify.
ibjammin
Original Author
14 years ago
Tiger, about the Trane XL15i, does it qualify for the tax credit in a 4 ton HP? In another thread, you gave me some suggested models that would be best suited for my climate.
http://ths.gardenweb.com/forums/load/hvac/msg1017320615302.html

These are the ones I was quoted.

3514632 Active Systems XR15 WEATHERTRON TRANE 4TWR5048E1 4TEE3F65B1 48000 12.50 15.00 46000 8.50 30200
He quoted new lineset, HW VisionPro IAQ stat, 2 year labor warranty. I will probably have an Aprilaire 5000 air purifier installed on which ever unit I purchase because my wife has allergies and asthma.

The Carrier dealer is quoting a Performance 15 25HPA548H30 FE4AN(B,F)005+UI or the 25HPA548H30 FE4ANB006+UI. His quote included a 5 year warranty.

I do not know why he showed the two different units. He is quoting his with the tin plated coil and Infinity Control stat. Do you feel the Carrier package is okay or should I make sure I have him show the one you listed( 25HPA548H30 FV4CNB006 )? I do not know anything about the configuration of HP/Air Handlers. I feel confident with both companies as far as installation.
ryanhughes
14 years ago
The FE4ANB006T and Infinity control are good with the 25HPA548H30 outdoor unit. The 006 is physically larger and gives better performance figures. The FV4C can be used but is not the Infinity interface (FE4A is).

I don't think you'll be dissatisfied with either the Trane or Carrier options.
classicdave
14 years ago
with the models shown you are not comparing apples to apples.
the electronics in that carrier infinity control setup is far superior than the XR15 system.

You may elect out of the electronic package carrier offers if so the Carrier system that compares to the XR15 system you listed would be.

25HCB548A30
FV4BN(B,F)005
EER 12.5
SEER 15
HSPF 8.5

Standard 24v control boards with carrier's edge Thermostat or the Honeywell Vision Pro IAQ or HW visionpro 8000

Trane - Carrier
either one is good, none is better than the other even in my and (golfer) state of Florida, but I thought if you were going to compare price you should know one of the reasons why your carrier quote was higher than the trane quote.
ibjammin
Original Author
14 years ago
I am considering going with the Trane XR15 due to the price. But is the XR15 capable of controlling humidity in my house if combined with the HW Vision Pro IAQ stat? That is one of my concerns in deciding on a new system.
JT12345
13 years ago
My Trane XR15 makes a weird metallic sound from the compressor. The XR13 and XR14s that my neighbors have don't. Sansone the installer does not return my calls and neither does Trane. It is outside my son's room and he does not like sleeping there. It is a high pitch annoying sound coming from the new unit. It is not the loudness. It is the type and frequency of the sound that is unacceptable.

Stay away from Trane. Stay away from Sansone. Had another tech look at it and says the compressor should be replaced or at least vaccummed and recharged.

No return calls from Trane or Sansone yet. It has been over a month now and i might have to take them to court. They suck. If i do I will post it on youtube. There is a youtube video of the xr15 with this sound and they think it is fine while their other units r a low hum.

My new XR15 sounds like a worn out 12 year old unit.

Question on Trane XR15 Heat Pump.

tigerdunes

Comments (8)

classicdave

Related Discussions

golfer1512

ibjammin
Original Author

ryanhughes

classicdave

ibjammin
Original Author

JT12345

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Question on Trane XR15 Heat Pump.

tigerdunes

Comments (8)

classicdave

Related Discussions

golfer1512

ibjamminOriginal Author

ryanhughes

classicdave

ibjamminOriginal Author

JT12345

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

ibjammin
Original Author

ibjammin
Original Author