Goodman R22 compressor died. Upgrade or replace?

12 years ago

We just moved into 9 year old home and because of cold weather could not test the air conditioning unit. We turned it on for the first time and it died within a day. A friend recommended an ac technician he's used for years who came out, spent an hour with me and felt bad charging anything after what he found. Turns out the freon was leaking inside the compressor and outside. It's a Goodman CLK60. He said Goodman uses same compressor as other high end units but keeps prices low by not advertising like the others. He suggested we just replace the unit and he'll add the freon since they can't sell them with freon. He's a registered distributor for many different brands but said Goodman is good if installed correctly and it's best to match with the unit in the attic. The rooms square footage adds up to 2200 but the house was listed as 3200 square feet (2 floors). it's a 5 ton, 60,000 BTU system. I have a few questions:

1. is the size of the unit good? I was concerned it had to work too hard and that led to breaking.

2. he said the cost of labor to take apart the compressor and find the leak and then order the part, replace, etc may make it not worth it compared to getting a new one. it's my call. should I replace or spend to find out where leak(s) is happening?

3. he said it would cost a ton more to go to R410a system. he would flush the copper line if we went that route, not re-run copper. but we'd have to replace the attic unit (forgot what that's called). we plan on being here 40+ years. does that length affect our decision? Goodman has the optional lifetime warranty program which is appealing.

4. We only have 1 unit for a relatively large home. Does the desire to someday convert to 2 zones affect our decision making process?

I know most people are skeptical of technicians, but I totally trust him. My friend is a seasoned builder and has used him for years. He's an old timer who seems to know his stuff.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (6)

mike_home
12 years ago
Goodman's usually have a 10 year parts warranty if the unit was registered at the time of installation. Someone would need to contact to local distributor to verify if the unit is covered. It's a young unit and may be worthwhile fixing.

If you are going to replace it, you should not stay with the R22. A R410 unit does not cost more. Could it be the old timer does not want to get involved with a R410 unit?

To answer you other questions:

1. I think 5 tons is oversized for a 2200 square foot house that is 9 years old.

2. I think you should find out the cost of a repair espeically if the warranty is in effect.

3. If you are going to be there 40 years, then you definitely don't want an R22 unit. If possible the line set should be changed.

4. If you are planning on zoning, should consider doing this now. It will affect the installation.
0
abwhitney
Original Author
12 years ago
Thanks for your reply. I like lists, so forgive the format:

- I thought Goodman warranty was only for original owner? I can see the serial number, but should they allow it still?

- The unit that is in the attic, does that need to replaced (plus any additional duct work, etc) if we replace the outside compressor with an R410 unit? I don't think he's shirking the work away but rather thinks it's not necessary to upgrade. There's added costs in the labor.

- the 2200 square feet is the inside the walls dimensions. It doesn't take into effect the high ceilings, especially the cathedral ceiling foyer and family room. In any case, wouldn't I have to replace the attic unit if I wanted to go smaller? are you thinking it's a waste of energy?

- Any further thoughts on zoning? We have 1 zone for upstairs and downstairs. I thought of zoning to save on costs over time, but if it costs thousands to add 2nd furnace, split off the duct work and get another unit, is it really worth it? all bedrooms are on same floor, so this would just be an upstairs vs downstairs zone thing.

Thanks!
0
Related Discussions
Use R-22 or R-410?
Q
Comments (18)
To clarify and relieve some of the scares created: R-22 used in production of equipment ceases (if not earlier by manufacturer choice) Jan 1 2010. From then on till 2015 the gas will continue to be produced and imported for servicing existing equipment. Jan 1, 2015 till 2020 it will be produced and imported for servicing existing refrigeration and air conditioning applications only. Jan 1, 2020 production and import is banned and only recycled/reclaimed and stockpiled R-22 quantities available for servicing existing equipment. Yes the first CFC phase-out caused some panic and I remember $50 jugs of R-12 selling for as much as $900 but, the industry was sleeping and the manufacturers were not prepared, perhaps in denial. I even kept one for years to service my autos and refrigerator but guess what, never used or needed it since I realized I didnÂt own anything that used it. This scarcity eventually instituted excessive pricing/reclaiming & recycling costs and forced the development of "drop-in" replacement refrigerants, some good some bad, however with testing comes success. I remember the early days when you could sell back used refrigerant until they realized itÂs cost to transport & process was more than it was worth, leading contractors to have to pay to dispose of legally. While any intelligent HVAC dealer would have access to R-22 till at least 2025, the advancement of drop-in R-22 equivalents will surely be available. Puron refrigerant (R-410) started its usage and marketing to the environmentally conscious person. While R-12Âs make up consisted of considerably more CFCÂs than R-22, making it first on the hit list among a few others, it is now known and shared that the effects of refrigerants play a minor role in the ozone layer depletion. The effects of refrigerants and their release (intentional or not) is minor compared to a volcano eruption, manufacturing and factory discharges and every day uses of aerosol products in and around the home. Here is a link that might be useful: CFC Phaseout
...See More
Central air replacing R12 compressor
Q
Comments (3)
Your current AC condenser uses R22. The new refrigerant is R410a. The refrigerants you listed are not used in residential HVAC systems. I think continuing with a R22 system is a waste of money. You are paying a lot of money just for the refrigerant. If you want to keep the current air handler then you should be able to change the indoor coil and the condenser. If the lineset is relatively easy to change, I would change that also. I you are planning to live in this house another 10 years then I would also recommend changing the air handler. You will eventually spend money on either repairing or replacing it. If the funds are available then do it now and get the maximum efficiency out of it. Electricity prices on Long Island are high. You will see a pay back on spending the extra money for better efficiency.
...See More
Replacement HVAC Goodman vs Trane
Q
Comments (13)
In my opinion, a new system is not worth a penny no matter what brand if you have duct issues. I put more into the checking ducts making sure they look good and marking down what I think can be improved if anything. Brand of equipment, manual j, whatever you name it, Checking the duct in my opinion is top priority if it is accessible. I went into 3 attics today. 2 had small issues and 1 was ok. The small issues will be fixed and the cost is minimal when the new system goes in if they choose us. I will say the Trane XR15 is a more close comparison to a goodman 16 which the XR15 cost less than the XL15i. You may want to ask about the XR15 if you are considering comparing a trane model that is a more budgeted A/C It is my opinion the most important part of buying an air conditioning system is the contractor who installs it. With that, a Professional who believes in what they sell will more than likely install it better than a company who will sell you anything that you want. I am not a big fan of companies that sell many different brands.
...See More
convert existing coil from R22 to R410?
Q
Comments (4)
How many more years do you plan to live in this house? If it is going to be more than 5 years, then it would make sense to spend the money now and go with option 3. Ask the warranty company to give you the money for the compressor, and then go higher a good HVAC installer. Your repaired Goodman equipment might make it to 20 years, but it is unlikely without another major repair. I don't know what is involved in properly flushing out a coil, but I never see anyone on this forum talking about it. It seems the standard practice is to replace the coil when changing refrigerants. I would not recommend option 2. Option 1 is a possibility. Did all the R22 leak out when the compressor died? Be careful, the warranty company pays the HVAC contractor very little. These guys try to make some money by "selling" you more refrigerant that you may not need. It is unfortunate, but this is the draw back of having a home warranty.
...See More
weedmeister
12 years ago
2. the evaporator will most likely need to be replaced in the attic, not the blower or furnace.

3. Volume is a better measure than square footage. The rules of thumb for sq. ft. presume 8ft ceilings. If the unit is too large, it will short-cycle, leading to humidity problems (cool/clammy).

When you go to a 410 system, chances are very good that you will need to run a new lineset. This is because the new unit(s) will require a larger size.
0
abwhitney
Original Author
12 years ago
thanks weemeister. with all the work needed, plus cleaning out the pipes, it sounds to me like it may not be worth upgrading to the R410. I'm not seeing the ROI aside from the environmental benefits. our ceilings are definitely more than 8ft. I think they're ten. the foyer is 2 stories high and the family room is probably 1.75 stories high at the v peak.
0
mike_home
12 years ago
I don't know the limits of the Goodman warranty. Do some research and don't assume anything.

R22 refrigerant is being phased out. Over time it will become expensive.

You will have to replace the coil if you change the size of the condenser. Talk to additional contractors and see if they will do a load calculation.

Zoning will help even out the downstairs and upstairs temperatures. The duct work will need to be evaluated to determine how difficut it would be to separate the downstairs and upstairs duct work. Are you going to replace the condenser and then find out upstairs is much warmer than downstairs?

You can take the inexpensive approach and then do a total replacement in 10 years. How much is the quote to swap the condenser and charge it with R22?
0
abwhitney
Original Author
12 years ago
Checked on their site - out of warranty. Figures.

The quote is somewhere around $1400 installed. I should have more information today or tomorrow. I'm in Massachusetts, so I'm not sure what regional costs are.

I think the idea of doing a total replacement in 10 to 20 years is where I'm going to go. I'd rather have a fresh system install with any additional duct work done rather than hoping all the adaptation work is done correctly.
0

Goodman R22 compressor died. Upgrade or replace?

Comments (6)

mike_home

abwhitney
Original Author

Related Discussions

weedmeister

abwhitney
Original Author

mike_home

abwhitney
Original Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Goodman R22 compressor died. Upgrade or replace?

Comments (6)

mike_home

abwhitneyOriginal Author

Related Discussions

weedmeister

abwhitneyOriginal Author

mike_home

abwhitneyOriginal Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

abwhitney
Original Author

abwhitney
Original Author

abwhitney
Original Author