heat zone question: deciding between two contractors

10 years ago

Hi again,

I just posted a question about Viessmann vs. Burnham Alpine vs. Buderus. I also have a separate question about heat zones.

We are buying an 1800 sf house that currently has one zone of oil heat. We are putting on a family room/kitchen addition with a master bedroom and bath above it. We have proposals from two contractors (who are recommending different burners!) The contractors have different approaches to zoning.

The first contractor (Viessmann or Buderus guy) is suggesting that we keep one zone for the existing living room, dining room AND the there kid bedrooms upstairs (which are existing rooms.) He is then suggesting new zones for the master, the kitchen/family room and the basement.

The second contractor (Burnham Alpine or Buderus) is recommending that we keep the first floor one zone and split the second floor into two zones: master and existing kid bedrooms. We would then have a basement zone for the playroom.

In addition, the first contractor is quoting a one step a/c system, and the second contractor is quoting a two step system: supposedly quieter and more efficient (and we don't go away much.)

The second contractor is more expensive, but we feel more comfortable with him. We are trying to put the recommendations into perspective. Any input?

Thanks so much!

Sara

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (6)

mike_home
10 years ago
The second contractor's suggestion of zoning by floors and bedrooms makes more sense. His proposal will allow you to keep the first floor at one temperature, and the bedrooms at another. This will allow you to set back the bedroom temperature during the day when no one is upstairs. You would also be able to set back the first floor during the night when everyone is sleeping. In addition you may want the kid's room to be warmer then the master bedroom. I assume the new master bedroom will have much better insulation than the other bedrooms so this would be another reason to have an independent zones on the second floor.

A 2-stage AC does a better job of humidity control. It will also be quieter when it runs in the low stage. In my opinion they are worth the extra money.

I am not an expert on boilers. Have the contractor explain the options. I know that high efficiency modulating boilers need to operate at lower water temperatures in order to reach peak efficiency. In some installations this is not possible and you end up paying a lot of money for a boiler that cannot reach its full potential.
newenglandsara2
Original Author
10 years ago
Thanks so much, Mike_Home! I like the second contractor's suggestions, but I guess they are a lot more expensive. I hope that the first contractor was trying to save us money and still has the expertise to know what is ideal. He is the one who normally works with our GC, so our GC is pushing us to use him. I feel more comfortable with the other contractor (who we have used for a previous HVAC job), but: 1) his quote is pricier and 2) our GC has never worked with him before. Decisions, decisions....:-) Thanks again!
Related Discussions
Two Stage for Two Story? Nutty Contractor?
Q
Comments (4)
I work for a reputable hvac contractor in the south. We sell 80% and 90% furnaces, one-stage, two-stage, and variable speed. We sell AC and heat pump up to 18 SEER. We always try to give the HO a choice. It seems the bigger the house, the more the HO wants. For those with smaller houses, the upgraders tend to go for the AC first, then things like filtration and humidification, then the nice furnace. These are people who are gainfully employed and who plan to be in the same house 5 to 10 years later. That being said, I have a small house. I replaced my system 9 years ago, upgrading my AC to 12 SEER and adding Aprilaire filtration. Now, the one thing I really wish I had done is upgrade to a variable speed furnace. As far as that contractor goes, you may have to read between the lines some more. Maybe he genuinely cared about your parents' best interests. Maybe the president backed him up. Maybe you can find out what he sells to younger couples in small houses. Maybe Lennox has been putting out some bad product. Maybe he is thinking about switching brands and does't want the call-backs. Maybe he is a stick in the mud.
...See More
Have question about radiant heat between joists.
Q
Comments (1)
Do not run tubing under cabinets and fixtures. You can and probably should do home runs for each loop back to the manifold. It is easier to balance the flow that way. You are not wasting tubing doing so. You could do a "main" down the edge of the building and feed each zone/loop off of that but you have to get in to Reverse Returns and the piping just gets a bit more complicated. As well, having everything terminate at the manifold allow you to troubleshoot or at least view the flow to each zone in one spot as opposed to running back and forth. Waste a little tubing. You will be happy you did.
...See More
Help us decide between two contractors for a kitchen remodel
Q
Comments (35)
I've been in sales for about 20 years and I always resent it when people say that sales people manipulate because I believe a good salesperson gives the buyer enough information to make an informed decision. I think what Trebuchet means when he says they aren't closing, is that they aren't addressing the concerns of the buyer enough for them to make a decision. Tre gives the "dog & pony show" i.e. informs them of the choices and then let's them make a decision based upon the information he gave them. Jakuvall, you say you're not a salesman nor a "closer" but your definition of what you do actually fits my definition of a good salesperson: address the concerns of the consumer and give them enough information to make an educated decision. In a nutshell, you have enough education and belief in your skillset to instill a confidence in the buyer that you're the person for the job. That's why you have a better than average closing ratio: you're authentic. I'm very proud to be a salesperson and a closer.
...See More
Help with kitchen design, trying to decide between two layouts
Q
Comments (79)
You know, I agree with you that the island perpendicular to the window wall doesn't feel as right as the island parallel to the window wall. Interesting. I stopped and thought about why that would be. My first thought was that, with the island perpendicular to the window wall, the end of the island closest to the living room now feels as if it's intruding into the walkway between the kitchen and living room. Even though the island ends in line with the side of the fridge closest to the living room, the island still feels as if it's intruding. However, when I look at the island parallel to the window, I also think the end of the island closest to the dining room feels as if it is intruding into the dining room. Even though the island ends in line with the side of the perimeter cabinet closest to the dining room, the island still feels as if it's intruding. So when you're standing in the living room, you like the perpendicular-to-the-window-wall island orientation less (because the island feels as if it's intruding towards you). And when you're standing in the dining room, you'll like the parallel-to-the-window-wall island orientation less (because the island feels as if it's intruding towards you). Given all that, I actually think this shape island (posted earlier upthread) feels the best from both perspectives: That is because the island is completely and clearly inside the invisible borders of the kitchen as delineated by the side of the fridge closest to the living room and the side of the perimeter cabinet closest to the dining room. A square (ish) island doesn't even touch the borders -- it's well inside them by a foot or two, making it impossible for the island to feel as if it's intruding into another room. This home layout is so open that it lacks some of the normal cues (walls/doorways/floor changes) marking where the kitchen ends and another room begins. So in this island's case, a setback from the technical kitchen border helps to clarify things. The island's definitely in the kitchen and only in the kitchen. Here is an edited version that stops the island a foot or two short of the borders in both directions: I'd recommend having seating just on the living room side of the island. Seating on the dining room side puts those chairs back to back with dining room chairs, and I always think that looks/functions a bit oddly.
...See More
ionized_gw
10 years ago
Do you have forced air now or hydronic?
newenglandsara2
Original Author
10 years ago
Hi Ionized, good question! The heat is radiators with copper pipes and fins inside the radiators. (Therefore, we can add some baseboard where needed, and it will be compatible.) Hope this helps!
bakerboy63
10 years ago
Sara,

Mike is right, you may not get the full benefits of a mod/con boiler as their full efficiencies are only met when the return temps are below 130. Normal rads run at 180, meaning return temps are something like 160. That being said, if the original house is older, and has been upgraded with insulation, better windows etc, than you may have more radiator length than you need for 180 temps, allowing you to run lower and still be warm. Like I said in the other thread, get a heat loss calc done. You should not go with any contractor that is not capable of doing this ' manual J' calculation.

The 2nd contractor sounds good, but their are pluses to the 1st guy too. Make sure they are quoting the setup with an Outdoor reset or ODR. This modulates the temp of the water based on outside temps. This is one of the main reasons to get one of these new boiler types.

Go with the 2 stage AC unit as Mike said. When my unit dies, that is what I will do. I like the Trane units, XL model I believe, where they have 2 compressors in them, one at 50%, the other at 100%, which modulates better than the other 2 stage units, which are usually 70/100%.

A lot to think about huh? The good news is, the systems today, when properly setup with a good contractor, are more comfortable and use less energy.

Good luck.
mike_home
10 years ago
" He is the one who normally works with our GC, so our GC is pushing us to use him. I feel more comfortable with the other contractor (who we have used for a previous HVAC job)"

First rule is most general contractors know very little about HVAC. They like to sub contract the HVAC work to the guy who will do the work for the lowest cost. You careful about using the first contractor. Costs are important but don't let it be the sole deciding factor.

Installation is very important. You can buy the best boiler but if it is installed poorly it will never worked correctly. If you have used the second contractor in the past and feel good about his work, then that would be a big plus. The GC may not have an agreement with the second contractor. That is something you will have to negotiate and my be the reason he is trying to sway you.

Do you have detailed quotes from both contractors? Have they explained how the equipment will be sized? Have they offered any options about equipment? What prices have been proposed so far?

heat zone question: deciding between two contractors

Comments (6)

mike_home

newenglandsara2
Original Author

Related Discussions

ionized_gw

newenglandsara2
Original Author

bakerboy63

mike_home

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

heat zone question: deciding between two contractors

Comments (6)

mike_home

newenglandsara2Original Author

Related Discussions

ionized_gw

newenglandsara2Original Author

bakerboy63

mike_home

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

newenglandsara2
Original Author

newenglandsara2
Original Author