Soot in house from oil furnace?
hollan
14 years ago
Featured Answer
Sort by:Oldest
Comments (12)
baymee
14 years agoscottys
14 years agoRelated Discussions
replace Oil Furnace with Propane 2 stage hot air furnace.
Comments (21)The obvious should be stated - the absolute cheapest way to heat your house is geothermal. It should at least be considered. Next cheapest is air source heat pump particularly with an efficient mini split. It seems to me that converting the whole house to a standard ducted heat pump has a fairly low upfront cost and a fairly low run cost. It is a compromise for upfront cost and ongoing cost. I can't see why anyone would recommend propane - unless the goal is having generator backup heat. Are you talking paying $350 for 12 months? A heat pump with electric backup should be 50% of that or less depending on climate and what system you buy. It would seem like Carrier Greenspeed would pay off for such a high heating need. You would probably save closer to 75% compared to oil. So even though it might be $20k installed, the payback is 7 years. You really need to experience a well installed forced air system. I don't know mine is on. I fail to see how a gentle circulation of air through a filter creates dust - it actually reduces it. And then it humidifies it....See MoreOil Fume Smell - brand new oil furnace
Comments (13)I would like to thank everyone for there thoughtful comments. Today another Senior Tech stopped by (the sales rep also a former tech arranged this for us) He walked in and immediately I envisioned Sherlock Holmes just by his demeanor. We went into the basement and unlike the previous 4 or 5 techs who spent hours on this rather then opening up the oil furnace He simply looked at the large pipe that extends from the furnace to the chimney. Then like Sherlock he rubbed his ring finger over it near the furnace. He smiled & said I know what the problem is. (I thought he was joking) After showing me a little dust. He pointed out a little discoloration on the pipe . He then said occasionally the heat is going in the wrong direction.. To prove this he connected a Draft Meter. When the system is on (flame on) its negative but when the fan goes on it is positive (looking for air) We went up stairs and once again he smiled. We have chairs and stuff in front of the outgoing vents and he moved them a few inches & then said problem solved. He said the newer powerful systems simply need to circulate more air. both in and out. We went back to the basement with his Draft Regulator and it tested perfect. IT only took this gentleman less then a minute to resolve a problem that we had since November or December -A problem that most of the other techs downplayed etc The chairs and stuff were there with the old less powerful furnace without any issues. . again thanks for your input....See MoreHeat pump, oil furnace, and electric furnace
Comments (5)Thanks for the feedback (hope others will reply with more)! OK, I guess that sounds right not to state 'furnace' for electric. We really want to eliminate oil even if it is minimally cost-effective or costs a little more. There would be some peace-of-mind since the furnace is 15yrs old and the tank (and line) is underground and likely 60yrs old. Also skyrocketed price of oil will probably stay or go higher. With all my research thus far I ruled out 13 SEER or lower. One upcoming bid is 14.5 SEER. We will not do propane, so it is heat pump with current oil or new electric. And wouldn't any heating fail with an electrical outage since the fan needs electricity (unless one has a generator)? Also, any advice on recommended brands? I think one guy is going to offer York and Goodman and the other guy Carrier (but there are so many brands out there and I am finding a LOT of unsatisfied reviews)....See MoreReplacing an Oil Furnace... Still have some confusion...
Comments (13)dandm2007... My old Magic Chef oil furnace cracked a heat exchanger last year. There was a mild odor in the house when it ran - kinda like kerosene. Sometimes, the CO detector would give a warning beep-beep-beep - although it never went on to the constant BRAAAAAP, which means "get out now!" I didn't have a smoke bomb, so I removed the supply plenum and with a flashlight I found an 8 cm crack on the heat exchanger. It was on the weld between the "inner drum" and "outer ring" (ptimary and secondary exchanger?). It was not easy to spot. The supply plenum - and the ductwork closest to it - had light coat of soot on the inside. It was most noticeable on the joints and elbows. That was the exhaust leaking by the crack. I've dark-coloured log walls. So I couldn't see soot above the registers. Light-coloured walls may have shown some sooting. A properly running oil furnace should emit no odor. I can't smell my furnace at all inside or outside the house. There is NO visible smoke from the chimney. On really cold days I'll see some water vapour, but that's it. Unfortunately, when I first put in the replacement furnace there was an even stronger kero odor from the vents. That was all my fault. During my DIY install, the edge of the exhaust duct slipped under the collar on the back of the furnace. This allowed exhaust gases to get sucked into the return plenum, then right out the supply. It took me a day to figure out I had botched it. Oddly enough, the CO detector never made a peep. Is it possible that the vibration from a faulty power exhaust fan wiggled your exhaust duct past the collar? If your furnace pre-heats the return air over an internal exhaust tube like my Crown does, then you'd get the same kerosene odor that I did. I'm sure your CO levels would go up, as well. A wobbling exhaust fan could have also loosened your chimney. *** CALLING HAVAC and OTHER PROS *** Does dandm's horizontal furnace pre-heat the return like my Crown lowboy? If so, could it be sucking in fumes because the exhaust duct slipped behind the collar on the furnace?? Finally...could fan vibration loosen the collar or move the exhaust in that way? Peace. Marco...See Moresnoringcow
14 years agotk03
14 years agohollan
14 years agosnoringcow
14 years agobaymee
14 years agodougl99
14 years agosnoringcow
14 years agosnoringcow
14 years agobaymee
14 years ago
Related Stories
REMODELING GUIDES8 Lessons on Renovating a House from Someone Who's Living It
So you think DIY remodeling is going to be fun? Here is one homeowner's list of what you may be getting yourself into
Full StoryMY HOUZZMy Houzz: A Seattle Bungalow Goes From Flip to Happily-Ever-After Home
Once intended for a quick sale, this 1930s house now bears witness to its remodelers’ love and marriage
Full StoryKITCHEN DESIGNPearls of Wisdom From a Real-Life Kitchen Remodel
What your best friend would tell you if you were embarking on a renovation and she'd been there, done that
Full StoryMOST POPULAR15 Remodeling ‘Uh-Oh’ Moments to Learn From
The road to successful design is paved with disaster stories. What’s yours?
Full StoryKITCHEN DESIGN16 Practical Ideas to Borrow From Professional Kitchens
Restaurant kitchens are designed to function efficiently and safely. Why not adopt some of their tricks in your own home?
Full StoryLAUNDRY ROOMSGet More From a Multipurpose Laundry Room
Laundry plus bill paying? Sign us up. Plus a potting area? We dig it. See how multiuse laundry rooms work harder and smarter for you
Full StoryREMODELING GUIDESClean-Burning Woodstoves Ignite a Greener Heating Trend
No need to rely on oil or gas to heat your home — new woodstove designs burn cleanly and are beautiful to boot
Full StoryGARDENING AND LANDSCAPINGWhat to Know Before You Buy Teak Outdoor Furniture
Learn about finishes, weathering, care and that age-old oil debate to get the teak furnishings that suit you best
Full StoryLIFEBack to the Future of the House
Can the low-tech dwellings of the past offer design lessons for homes to come? A palace curator and book author says yes
Full StoryMY HOUZZMy Houzz: Renovation Brings Energy Efficiency to a Netherlands Home
A family of 5 tackles a potentially large gas and electric bill in a 19th-century house
Full Story
baymee