Cooling the attic?

14 years ago

Hi.

I recently purchased a 1925 home in Southwest Virginia. It's approx 2100 square feet on the two main floors. The heating (radiators) and cooling (heat pump) seem to work fine on these floors. The basement is semi-finished but seems to stay warm enough in the cold and not too hot so far. The attic, however, is another issue.

Someone started finishing the walk-up attic in this house - there is an extra bathroom (tub only, no shower) up there. It's quite charming with sloped ceilings and a huge deep old-fashioned tub. My kids love bathing up there as do I. Since it turned warm, however, the room is too muggy for evening baths. There are two other spaces framed out, and some closed-off storage (where the heat pump air handler is) and some open storage as well (you can see the insulation, rafters, etc). I was hoping to use one of those rooms for a jewelry studio. But I am dismayed to find this space with some really cool potential is basically going to be unusable half the year.

This is new territory for me, so please make suggestions as well as weighing in on the options I am pondering.

1. Put a window unit in the bathroom. Not super desirable but would consider. Also would consider a "portable" ac unit.

2. Finish out the walls and flooring of the attic space, and either try to increase the ducts to this space (really don't think this will cut it and may put too much strain on the system) or put in one of these mini-split ductless systems I have been reading about.

I am definitely open to other ideas. Should I call a HVAC guy out to assess the situation and give recommendations? I am having a contractor friend come look at it to give me suggestions but he will be the first to say he's not an HVAC person.

I want to try to achieve comfortable temps without spending the world on this as I am a single mom with two young children. On the other hand, I don't want to do a "quick fix" that I am then going to throw more money at down the road.

Thanks for your help!!!

Kara

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (4)

coppercoil
14 years ago
Being no expert either, I would say call several HVAC guys out.

We are working on a similar project, and having people out really helped educate me on what direction to go in. You are not wasting their time, you are giving them an opportunity to bid for business (the fact that you learn something is a bonus).

Just be very clear that you are on a limited budget and that cost is as important as performance. Who knows, the system you have may be oversized and may be able to deal with the additional load efficiently... then the only question is engineering new supply/return air duct work to the upper level.

Oh, most codes require that bathrooms have either an extractor fan or a window - so (if you are pulling permits) a velux window may be the most economical option...
coppercoil
14 years ago
http://www.dsireusa.org/incentives/homeowner.cfm?state=VA&re=1&ee=1

Here is a link that might be useful: DSIRE Incentives in VA
Related Discussions
Attic insulation
Q
Comments (3)
www.buildingscience.com search for unvented attics. 2" of foam is not enough by itself. R-value will be less than R-14 and in my area R-38 is recommended. what you are doing by moving the insulation to the roofline is moving the thermal barrier from the attic floor to the attic roof. ductleakage becomes less of an issue (unless it is an ungodly amount..and it can be)items like recessed lights can be IC instead of ICAT, kneewalls and cathedral ends in the attic are also less of an issue. it is not the be all and end all of all insulations. 1" is not R-15 and does not perform as such. there are other methods of achieving air tightness than foam, so that air infiltration sealing does not enter into an evaluation of the foam insulation performance but rather into cost and ROI. there are lots of insulation options, do some research before making a decision so that you can get what is right for you. best of luck.
...See More
LG Art Cool Inverter for attic room?
Q
Comments (3)
Thanks for the responses. Will have to do more research, I guess, to understand the difference in price and quality.
...See More
time to do something about HVAC
Q
Comments (1)
I didn't read you whole post because,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,ahh what the hell, it was just to darn long for a forum question! I did read far enough though to where it said the house practically lacks any appreciable insulation. Don't waste any of your money on a decent mechanical system until you update the building envelope. I doesn't make any difference how efficient a system you have, if the heat is coming into and going out of poorly fitting windows, doors and non insulated walls etc. you'll be wasting tons of money. Just by doing those things first you'll see a savings. Then you can upgrade the mechanical systems. Oh, one more thing, the foam insulation betweem the roof rafters is a big no no. Thats not how its done. Moisture will get trapped between the roof sheathing and the foam and eventually rot your roof. Your next roof job on the house might be a total tear off. And by total I mean replacing some of the wood below everything. It happened in the house I bought 15 years ago. Fortunately I was aware of it and the seller dropped one giant you know what when I poked my screw driver up through his soggy roof. I'd suggest you rearrange your priorities. Just curious, are you a journalist or something like that?
...See More
Cooling house without attic
Q
Comments (2)
A window fan could work, but if you have a peaked ceiling that is where the hot air is going to concentrate. You will probably need interior fans to move that air in the upstairs combined with a window fan to exhaust the hot air. Dont forget an open window. Perhaps one of those 2 fan window units? One side blows in fresh air while the other side exhausts.
...See More
kararobin
Original Author
14 years ago
Thanks for your info!
I had a friend who is a contractor take a look and he figured out (I felt sort of stupid!) that the three vents cut into the attic rooms were closed on the duct side. He opened them and it felt cooler immediately.
I am going to see how that pans out and also call in a local HVAC company to service and check the existing system. And give me an opinion on how well the current AC will work in the attic.
After talking with my friend, I also realized the need to re-insulate the attic area regardless of the air situation. I guess time with tell how those measures would work and then I can decide how to proceed and what I need.
Thanks again and further suggestions/thoughts are welcome.
Kara
energy_rater_la
14 years ago
the thing about conditioning rooms in the attic is that the temp in the attic is much more extreme than outdoor temps.
here in the south in the summer attic temps reach 130 degrees (and higher)
insulating walls shared with conditioned space and attic space helps, but installing a foil/foam sheathing board
over the insulation with the foil facing into the attic space will do two things. foil will reflect the heat back into the attic, instead of allowing it to transfer into the
conditioned space. foam sheathing will help to minimize air infiltration from attic into conditioned space, and insulation in walls will perform as spec'd.
caulking the foam/foil sheathing boards will also
help to minimize air leakage.
if you can stop the air movement from attic into cond. space
it will be much more affordable to heat and cool, and comfort will be easier to achieve.

air sealing would be done before adding additional insulation to attic floor.

best of luck.

Cooling the attic?

Comments (4)

coppercoil

coppercoil

Related Discussions

kararobin
Original Author

energy_rater_la

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Cooling the attic?

Comments (4)

coppercoil

coppercoil

Related Discussions

kararobinOriginal Author

energy_rater_la

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

kararobin
Original Author