My 10-day old grout is cracking!!?!?

13 years ago

SO my contractor ripped out my OSB subfloor and installed (if I am remembering correctly) 1/2" plywood then 3/8" plywood. Then used ECB membrane before setting the tiles. I'm not exactly sure what kind of adhesives were used, but I'm none too pleased with the install. Even though the porcelain 12x18 tiles are textured, we don't feel that they should be uneven in their placement. Yes, I'm being extremely picky but they are not fully level. I mentioned it to him, and he did offer to rip "the one or two that you think are terrible" out, but I sort of ignored it because we were arguing about my feeling doubly-billed by over $1200.

A week later, the "wet" grout is for sure dry and not uniform in color. It has also started cracking in 3-5 different places - around 3 tiles that are not close to each other. Could it be because of the extreme cold we've had and these tiles being close to the door that currently has no door jamb? (I'm in WI, temps outside are negatives). ?? DO I need to tell him to rip it out and start over? Any words of wisdom to help me from freaking out because I think he considers us a "lost cause" and isn't going to do his best work anymore??

Yikes!

Featured Answer

diymidwesterngal
Original Author

13 years ago

Thanks for the feedback all. He immediately agreed to redo the cracked grout of course, and also replaced 2 large-chip tiles that were in the main walkway.

Now that it has been 6 days since the last tile work, the rest of the grout is cracking. I'm completely distressed. The first grout job was done by someone else, with the GC doing the "repairs" -- but all of it is now cracking and crumbling. The grout was never sealed so I'm not sure whether or not that is anything additional to worry about.

I'm going to request that he come out to redo ALL of the grout - most is cracking anyways, and the color is far from uniform now. Is there anything I can keep an eye out for, or should ask him to be aware of when grouting this time? It is a sanded grout and the lines are not too narrow. I would guess 1/4 - 3/8" wide? Should I ask him to try a different kind of grout?

Also, MongoCT: you mention that where the tile intersects wall/door/etc it should be caulked... All of my wall-tile edges have a baseboard over so no cracking can be seen, but what kind of caulk should be used at the doorway? It is the front door, and gets a lot of traffic. Can caulk be shaded, or do we go with a standard "color" available and get over it?

Thanks again all! I appreciate your time :)

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (8)

floorguy
13 years ago
Too much water in the grout mix!

It has shrank since losing all the added water.

It could also be from movement in the substrate.
0
brickeyee
13 years ago
"SO my contractor ripped out my OSB subfloor and installed (if I am remembering correctly) 1/2" plywood then 3/8" plywood."

Without knowing joist span, spacing, and size there is no way to tell if the structure is solid enough.

Large tiles require a VERY solid substrate (about the same as stone).
0
Related Discussions
Sad day, I had to put down my 20+ year old crock pot...
Q
Comments (9)
I did go with the Fagor a few months ago and love it - the browning feature is great although most meats in the quantities you would be slo or pressure cooking have to be done in two batches. I still find it nicer to have a plate to wash over a separate skillet though :) And - My larger pressure cookers are stored in the basement and not completely handy when I want them. On days when I'm not especially organized (and I have a few of those) when I've wanted dinner ready at dinner time and was going to be gone in the late afternoon - but had not started slow cooking something earlier in the day...I've set it to pressure cook a few minutes, then reset to slo cook on low till time I wanted to serve....tenderizing inexpensive meats further than the 'keep warm' feature would do. But it is only 6 qt. Nesco makes an identical product - I went with the Fagor because its an inch smaller in diameter, allowing it to be stored on a 12" kitchen cupboard shelf, with the door closed :) I was looking for a replacement to my 70's era West Bend bean pot style crockpot that had been a faithful kitchen help most of my adult life and got distracted by the multi-function appliance. What I kept finding in reviews is that the newer slow cookers cook hotter than the old, surprising some of us who were used to the really slow cooking.
...See More
My 10 year old Son
Q
Comments (13)
David: I think a lot of the disagreements about what are the best trees and/or which are "trash" trees comes from how different trees grow in different parts of the country. I think you are out of the best range for growing sweetgum. Here I am a bit too far north and west, but I never see them sucker, and seldom see breakage. Go to eastern MD and south and they will knock your socks off. Of course there are the seed cases, and I can understand peoples feelings about those. But if I love a tree, I ignore such things. I have tried the male seedless variety--or at least one of them, and it was ill-adapted to this area and had to get rid of it. It seemed to be too far north for it. No color--the leaves just froze off in December. I posted "In praise of hackberries" a few months ago and although many people agreed with my opinion of the tree, others in different areas described growth habits/problems I had never seen here. Here they are often so perfect in form and generally magnificent I could never imagine anyone not loving them. I posted because many people cannot identify this tree and it is almost never offered for sale. Sycamores! Wow. Here in Winchester, VA they are wonderful--not just my opinion. It is probably the most commonly planted tree here in developments, along streets, parks, etc. And they are stunnning! I can't imagine what you are seeing there. So what trees are loved and by whom is not just a question of personal taste--often it is how a tree grows in one area as opposed to another. BTW--Ken hates maples because they are not good for growing hostas under! Ha--I will never be "hosta"le to maples! --Spruce
...See More
Curling and Drying of cotyledon leaves 10 day old seedlings
Q
Comments (16)
Hey! Don't know if anyone is still following this... but thought I'd give my two cents anyway. My seedlings are at about the same point... 12 days maybe... and I've just noticed they also have the curling/drying symptom. This is the first year I've used coconut based growth medium... usually I use the Jiffy brand pellets. Don't know if this is related to the symptoms. I think that maybe they dried out a bit more than the usually do, as I am not yet used to the properties of the "coconut soil". About fertilizing... I don't usually bother until maybe week 5 or 6, after I've trasplated the seedlings into bigger pots, and especially when then go outside (still in pots) and less controlled watering might lead to leaching. (As for type of fertilizer, my mom swears by a course of epsom salts.) Lastly, I try to keep my plants over 18 degrees C in the day... I think that is over 65F... afterall they're heat lovers!
...See More
Grout cracking in bathroom corner walls on 7 month old bathroom
Q
Comments (11)
If you have a curb, you will have the cracks develop there, too. and where the walls meet the floor. Anywhere where two different materials meet or where one surface meets another that is in a different direction (known as "change of plane"). My contractor still grouts such places, too. But I did a solid surface shower that he could not do wrong. I am keeping an eye on the place where the floor meets the shower pan, all other places are in dry areas. So there it is just cosmetic. I would guess that water can get behind your tile with those cracks. If properly waterproofed it is fine, but if not, I would get to this as soon as you can. A lot of shower builders do not use waterproofing, even though it is now required. If you do a search on this forum for "Shower waterproof," you can see many discussions about it and learn what is and is not waterproof. (Redguard yes, Durock no, for instance.)
...See More
MongoCT
13 years ago
Another consideration is the grout used. Sanded versus unsanded.

Unsanded is quite smooth and is used for grout joints less than 1/8" wide. Unsanded has sand added as a bulk filler, it can have a bit of texture, sort of like sandpaper. It's used for joints 1/8" wide and up to about 1/2" wide.

If unsanded is used in wide joints, it can crack as it cures.

If sanded is used in narrow joints, it can be tough to get the larger particles down into the joint so as to completely fill the grout joint.

The membrane can help if there is some movement in the floor, but as has been mentioned, the larger the tile you use, the flatter and stiffer the floor has to be.

If your cracks are at an intersection...floor to tub, floor to wall, tub to wall, wall to wall corner, etc, then the cracking is expected due to disimilar movement. Those areas typically get caulked.
0
homebound
13 years ago
Tell him it looks awful (and he knows it), and that it needs to be regrouted by someone experienced. At the same time, get the worst of the uneven tiles reset. Soften him up by letting him think you have a friend that may be interested in a tile quote, too, but that you will discuss that after your job is finished.
0
MongoCT
13 years ago
Tile-to-wall can be left with an open gap if it's to be covered by baseboard.

At a door threshold, if you need colored caulk, there are color-matched caulks available. Texture-matched too, meaning you can get "sanded" color matched caulk if you use sanded caulk. You can also tint your own, easiest is a latex caulk with latex paint or pigment mixed in.

Blotchy or uneven grout color grout can usually be attributed to too much water used during cleanup.

Cracked grout can be shrinkage cracks from packing it in to wide of a joint than it's specified for, or from too much water used when mixing the grout.

I've seen people mix grout too wet and it flows too easily, they "pour" is on the floor then slather it around with a float. Grouting should be a vigorous workout, packing it in the joints, working it to get it where it needs to go. It's not casual like icing a cake.
0
brickeyee
13 years ago
Over watered grout is also much more prone to damage from substrate flex.
0
floorguy
13 years ago
Grout should be the consistency of toothpaste, not honey

Too much water in the mix, or movement in the substrate.
0

My 10-day old grout is cracking!!?!?

diymidwesterngal
Original Author

Comments (8)

floorguy

brickeyee

Related Discussions

MongoCT

homebound

MongoCT

brickeyee

floorguy

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

My 10-day old grout is cracking!!?!?

diymidwesterngalOriginal Author

Comments (8)

floorguy

brickeyee

Related Discussions

MongoCT

homebound

MongoCT

brickeyee

floorguy

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

diymidwesterngal
Original Author