70's Split Foyer... Flooring Update

13 years ago

We're in the process of updating our 70's Split Foyer (bi-level/raised ranch) house...a little at a time as the budget allows. We're now ready to replace the flooring...Yea! We have a SMALL foyer 7'4"x 11' which is the main entrance for the house... As you stand inside the foyer...to the right there are 7 stairs that lead down to the finished basement...and to the left... 7 stairs that lead up to the living areas.

Currently the foyer is an ugly vinyl and the stairs are carpeted. The house is an open floor plan with carpeting in the living/dining room/hallway/3 bedrooms and 2 baths (YUCK!...there is vinyl in the kitchen... Downstairs (concrete slab)... there is an office... family room... bathroom and laundry room...all carpeted.

Our house is all electric with radiant/forced air heat in the ceilings. Each room has it's own thermostat, we also have a heat pump. We live in southwestern PA where the temperatures vary season to season.

I like the look of hardwood/engineered/laminate, but dh is worried about the floors being cold and wants carpeting. We also have 2 small terriers that LOVE to race through the house. Their nails are trimmed monthly so I don't think there would be a problem with scratches??? We don't have any children but we do entertain a lot.

Thank you all so much for sharing your expertise. This is a big purchase for us and I don't want to have any regrets!

Thanks!...Sandy

Featured Answer

art_teacher_mom

13 years ago

YES, use hardwood! It's not going to be cold, I promise. You can use plush rugs in each room as well. Home Depot has some nice room-size Mohawk rugs on sale right now. Hardwood is so easy to maintain and adds value to your house. Plus you can keep it really clean!

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (8)

westiemom
Original Author
13 years ago
We want to do both sets of stairs, foyer and all of the upstairs rooms to start. Currently there are two different colors of carpeting on the stairs...beige on the upstairs and yucky hunter green on the downstairs. I'd like the stairs to be the same material so there is continuity from floor to floor. I We also want to replace the iron railing we have with wood. Is this something that the flooring installers do or do we need a contractor? I'd like some type of stone/slate for the foyer, that I can wipe up easily.

I'd also like wood/engineered for the stairs and living/dining room and kitchen since they are all open to each other. Is it possible to put heating under a engineered floor? What brand would you recommend and what is the cost? DH is worried about the house being cold and I'm not sure I can talk him out of carpeting. The dogs track in dirt and mud and its seems I'm constantly having to spot clean the carpeting...it just never feels clean to me...(We have approx 800 sf of "open areas" stairs/living/dining/kitchen)

I'm not opposed to carpet in the bedrooms and will probably go with tile in the bathrooms. Two of the three upstairs bedrooms are over a heated integral garage. Would wood floors feel cold underfoot?

I like the look of BR-111, Brazilian Cherry....sort of a mid tone brownish red...any recommendations? Is it best to but locally or over the internet? How do you deal with warranty problems with internet purchases? Can you recommend anyone in my area...roughly 40 miles east of Pittsburgh, Pa?

Thanks again for all the help!...Sandy
idrive65
13 years ago
Westie, have you peeked under the carpeting? We used to have a 70's raised ranch just like yours and there were hardwood floors and stairtreads under the green shag carpet that we ripped up. Our entry was tile. Get a really durable tile here. Without a mud area this small place takes a beating, as will wood stairs leading up into your kitchen area. (Before we moved out we did a quick sand and refinish and they looked great!)

We had electric baseboard heat in our bedrooms over an unheated garage. Since our heaters were at floor level the wood floor wasn't terribly cold, but if your heat comes in from ceiling registers it will stay up there and your wood flooring will be freezing. Oh wait, did you say it's a heated garage? That makes a difference.

I kind of miss having heater controls in every room. :)
Related Discussions
Plan feedback for split-foyer, please!
Q
Comments (109)
I'm attaching (I hope) a picture of a typical split level in my area. The entrance is in the "main part" of the house, which is usually the living room -- but you could make it the music area. Typically there's a family room "downstairs" and all the bedrooms "upstairs". Yes, it is essentially half a two-story house connected to half a one-story house -- and the stair cases are only "half staircases", meaning that they're shorty-stairs because of the way the house is joined in the middle. Several additional thoughts have occurred to me -- some very basic questions: - You say you don't have children yet. Why build a four-bedroom house, especially since budget is a concern? Build a standard three-bedroom house (good for resale), and future small children can share a bedroom without any problem. - Do you really need a separate office and music room? You say your husband works away from home, and you cannot use both rooms at once. I understand that for a large instrument like a harp, you need floor space, but could not the office be built into one space? - In one post you allude to the idea that at some point in the future you won't need to teach music anymore -- did I get that right? I'm assuming this means that at some point you'll only be performing -- not teaching? If you're working towards working your way out of this job, does it make sense to spend the money to build a custom room for teaching music? This seems, again, to indicate an office and music room could be combined. - Is a garage an actual need? I know, I know, it's something pretty much everyone wants, but you're looking at sacrificing your living area -- why not cut out keeping your car indoors? If you were to cut out some of these items, you'd be down to a smaller square footage, which might allow you to build all on one level -- and then you could have a door on the side of the house for students /a main door for your friends. Comments on other parts of the house: - I definitely like the idea of changing the island to a simple rectangle. It'd be more cost-efficient and then would provide more storage in the space. - Your master bath has some problems: the door and the linen closet door are going to knock against one another, the door will hit a person using the sink, and a bathroom this size really can't support a toilet-in-a-closet. You have plenty of space, but this particular layout isn't working well. - Closet doors need to open "out". As they're drawn, you'll have to enter the closet and close the door to access the clothes on one side. Carol, I do hate that type of entryway. Apparently so do most people. I was under the impression that she hadn't yet started building this house, and she still has the choice to build something much better. I do agree with the poster who says that when essentially EVERYONE things the same thing, sometimes you have to ask yourself if you're on the right track -- especially if it's a house that you eventually want to sell. Even if your idea is dead-on for you, yourself, it may not be popular at resale time. And a comment on considering possible handicaps when building a house: Don't neglect temporary handicaps. For example, pregnancy makes it tough to go up and down stairs. I remember clearly that in my 8th and 9th month I'd walk into the school building and stop to rest before starting up the stairs to my classroom. Many -- if not most -- people will consider a house that has some bedrooms upstairs, bedrooms that might one day become inaccessible, but ALL the essential parts of the house are upstairs, and that does cut out a large percentage of your future possible buyers.
...See More
can you pull of cherry floors in a split foyer?
Q
Comments (7)
I live in split entry/bi level/split foyer. The only thing I can think of is that your REA is thinking of resale value. In some areas split entries are hard to sell because it is not a popular style, but in other areas they sell like any other home, it seems to be regional. IMO they are usually considered a "starter" home for whatever area they are in, and subsequently priced less than a two story or a ranch of comparable square footage. Split entries are hybrids. They are "ranchy" in style, but instead of the long run of stairs into the basement, they have the stairs divided. Essentially, it was a way to fit more house into less space. They were cheaper than regular houses to build, because the excavation for the basement was not done as deeply. Building them on hilly or slopey lots is understandable, but here in MN they were built en masse on absolutely flat lots. Like I said, cheaper to build. So...will brazilian cherry floors work? Of course! Higher end finishes are always welcome and beautiful. And it will look gorgeous. But will you get your money back? That is really hard to say, and depends on so many factors. I wouldn't count on it. I believe that your house would sell faster than a similarly-priced split entry with laminate or carpeting, but honestly, price is what's selling houses right now. Updates? That will make more people interested in your house, but it usually comes down to the right ratio between price and location. Good luck in your decision. I put in hickory floors, I love them and know I made the right decision for me. I also put bamboo in the foyer and on the stair treads. I don't expect to get more money than someone in a nearby split entry who did laminate or carpeting. When it comes time to sell, I'll get as much as my home is worth and move on, but in the meantime, I have thoroughly enjoyed my pretty floors. Joanna
...See More
Sad split foyer needs front door help and curb appeal
Q
Comments (43)
Okay, let's see if I can catch up on all of your helpful posts! I met with a landscaper and we were pretty much on the same page but there were a few things that I didn�t agree with. Maybe I just have no clue what I'm doing and maybe his recommendations are truly better than the picture I have in my head! I'll be meeting with another designer on Monday to get his take on it. The first guy was free and we just talked about what the plan would be. The second guy charges $50, but will draw up a whole design. They also do driveways, which the first company does not do. The one thing that I really didn't like about the first guy was that I felt like I had seen all of his ideas in my neighborhood already. I don't want something crazy that doesn't fit the house or neighborhood, but I also don't want the same thing everyone else has. How do you get your house to stand out from the others but still "fit"? Just because everyone else has "x" number of garden beds and "x" amount of front yard grass doesn't mean I have to, right? I did read over our HOA docs and they simply state that no more than 20% of the yard can be raised garden beds or container gardens. I would really like to make maintaining the lawn easier and to shade the front a little more. He wasn't on board with that. As I said before our yard is quite short, only 25 ft deep from the sidewalk to the front brick. So that will definitely play a big part in the design. The front tree is a cherry tree (with fruit) and I have been told that it will grow large enough to provide cover for the front window, not too sure about the door. Every arborist and landscaper that I have talked to seem happy with that tree and tell me not to touch it. The shutters have actually done quite well with all of the sun and heat that they get exposed too. No warping or anything. Considering the roof color is a good point. I think the wrought iron color would look great. I still don�t know what I want to do with the door. I have been playing with pictures of the house for days now. I've cut and pasted so many different designs I'm stuck. I think that there are some styles and looks that definitely work, some that definitely don't work, and then there are the in-between ones. I don't mind having my house look a little different then the neighborhood. I have two tri-levels on each side of me and three true 2 story colonials across the street from me. From my mock-ups I think can get away with some different looks that neither of the other two styles could pull off. And that is why I'm stuck. Too many ideas. I think a designers eye is what I need. The other challenge I am having right now is prioritizing what to do with the house first. The inside still needs to be painted. I could use some new furniture too. If I did do painting I would want to update the lighting while the ceilings are getting a fresh coat. As far as the outside goes, we obviously need landscaping. But we could also use new gutters and soffits, possibly a new door, and new hardscaping. My husband would also like to close in the carport. There is just so much to do and I don't know where to start. The changes we have already made to the inside were easy because they were done out of necessity. Really none of these other things have to be done. I think that I would like to focus on the outside simply because I have a 4yr old and 1yr old that make it a little harder to maintain the inside versus the outside. And I can handle the inside myself. I obviously need professional help with the exterior. So, any ideas on how to prioritize my projects?
...See More
Remodeling a split foyer,
Q
Comments (31)
We're doing a remodel + addition of our split-entry / split-foyer to move the kitchen downstairs. The reason is because we need a multi-generational home in a very aggressive housing market (metro Seattle). In most cases this may not make financial sense, but the ability to cook and serve food on the ground level is a key consideration for us due to accessibility concerns. By tying in to a new addition for a full bath and bedroom, we get the desired outcome for a fraction of a new construction equivalent. A new construction home would also be on a much smaller lot and require a change in school districts so everything considered, this changes makes sense in our scenario. Unlike the original poster, we will not be relocating the front entrance and I echo the thoughts of others about the costs outweighing the benefit of doing that. Our existing garage and new addition are at grade, so we will simply add entries via both of those locations to gain access. We'll see how much, if at all, this changes our market evaluation. Home buyers will certainly be expecting the kitchen and dining areas on the upper level. But having the kitchen downstairs means that a homeowner won't be carrying (1) groceries up, or (2) trash, recyclables, and compost down. I believe a good listing and proper staging can highlight this change. We'll further tie-in the downstairs kitchen and new addition via an outdoor kitchen and eating area. Given the current change to remote working due the pandemic, the upstairs dining and/or kitchen areas are now available for remodeling to a dedicated home office which is now desirable. By making the addition and downstairs ADA compliant, we also open ourselves to that market. My only concern is that the house may stay on the market longer until it finds a family in a similar multi-generational situation as ours, which seems to be increasing in demand.
...See More
westiemom
Original Author
13 years ago
Sorry to not have responded earlier...I've been trying to post... but when I hit "preview message"...I keep getting redirected to the GardenWeb home page!

idrive65 - Unfortunately no hardwood floors under the carpeting. When we moved in years ago...we "temporarily" replaced the lovely orange shag carpeting with a cheap beige carpet...now 17 years later, dh has finally agreed to replace it. We are still arguing over his "Hunter Green" carpeting downstairs...he doesn't see anything wrong with it! lol I do worry about wood on the steps but it has to be better than carpet...right? I do like the individual room controls...I wonder if there are updated controls? Ours still function well but are straight out of the Brady Bunch...along with the intercom system...thermometer(dh Loves this)!...and central vac!

art teacher mom - I love the look of hardwood! We live out in the woods and it just makes sense to bring the wood inside. We want to do both sets of stairs, foyer and all of the upstairs rooms to start. I'm glad to hear that the floors wont be cold!...Now to convince dh! lol

Thanks!...Sandy
echoflooring
13 years ago
I am going to take the opposite approach here from the rest as I understand we are in a struggling economy. Nafco makes a beautiful product at about 1/3 of the cost of real tile for that foyer. Extremely real looking, wears well(Not as well as tile)...I have a showroom that displays it on the floor and people with a budget goes bonkers over it. I would remove the railing, Pick a fashion conscious carpet that has great value yet will lst and definitely be warm and your pets will appreciate the traction. You will be able to afford this, it will be very fashionable and in many peoples mind in this world is easier to keep looking clean than a hard surface. Then have that wood railing with spindles (Which is fairly expensive) installed.I am only taking you in this direction as I know there is a budget here, and this will be affordable to you, look absolutely beautiful, and should allow you to do more improvement in your home than anticipated at this time. Besides, carpet is now making the gigantic comeback that I had predicted one year ago.Carpet once again, is overtaking hardwood for replacement products unlike the last two years as it people are becoming even more value conscious and they have been waiting long enough for the flooring through this economic crunch. By the way, Grey is number one color this year followed closely by chocolates, then beige's...Just a Little info. If you were close to our stores, I would be able to show you all the options. Hardwood treads, etc, will be nice...but it will be big bucks and that is not for everyone and I truly understand it...and your dogs will love you more...Ps/I am not anti hardwood by any means and there are tons of options, but hardwood anc ceramic rival one another for the highest price per ft....to place products in general in the order of cost....Tile..Hardwood...laminates..Luxury vinyl...vinyl...carpet There is exceptions to all of these and this list but this is just a generalizations which is usually right on the mark..This list presumes material labor and prep transition....Good Luck..
westiemom
Original Author
13 years ago
echoflooring - Thank you so much for your expertise! We Definitely will be replacing the the railing. Let me run buy one quote I have gotten so far...Hardwood installation of Brazilian Cherry 4-3/4"engineered by Bruce...includes tear out and disposal of old carpet...replace old baseboard with 5" primed baseboard in the living room/dining room/kitchen/hallway (approx 700 sf)... and cement board and slate for foyer...$9800.00
I see Lauzon, BR-111 and Mirage mentioned here a lot...would there be a big difference in price points?

I think you can tell I'm pushing for hardwood/engineered...but my husband likes carpeting. Are there any specific carpet brands I should be looking at?

Thanks!...Sandy
echoflooring
13 years ago
You've got to figure the foyer at close to a thousand dollars..maybe a hundred or two less..so that put your 700 sq ft of engineered Brazilian ch at around 9 grand...that is just shy of 13 a ft installed with rip out and the base..I mean every area is different..Around here an engineered like you are mentioning would be less money. There are different calibers of engineered. the three that you mention as alternatives will probably not save you money from the Bruce. I will be honest, Bruce is my least favorite of the 4 you mentioned as their quality control at times is terrible.it sounds like a lot of money for 800 f of flooring, but you are talking about top end cost points because of it being Brazilian cherry and ceramic I think you mean...Or is it really slate? Carpet wise if were me it would be either Anso or Smart Strand..both will give you performance...It's really hard to ridicule the price on the hardwood, as areas are so different. Also a good hardwood installer is worth more. We did a new house last week and were crunched with our crews...so we put a b quality crew in this home for 5 inch wide oak with a brand new builder that we acquired and we did not do a great job, so I now will be scrambling this week to get it corrected or replaced...No every store takes that approach either, but damn it , i ahould have made the customer wait an extra week and put an a crew in there. i should have known better. I will say that Home Depo and Lowes have very few what AI call craftsman working for them. let me say this, when you install new hardwood in an existing home, in can not be any tom dick or harry that installs it. It needs to be a carpenter..not a carpet layer.. There are few carpet layers that can be a craftsman with hardwood....but a lot of them think they are...So you must know what you are getting for an installer of hardwood or ceramic for that matter. Just some words of wisdom...You got my email..let me know if I can be of any more help to you. Thanks and good luck...Sorry for the lack of caps and spelling ...its late and I do not want to correct them all. Let me know.
Bellgirl
3 years ago
Following

70's Split Foyer... Flooring Update

art_teacher_mom

Comments (8)

westiemom
Original Author

idrive65

Related Discussions

westiemom
Original Author

echoflooring

westiemom
Original Author

echoflooring

Bellgirl

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

70's Split Foyer... Flooring Update

art_teacher_mom

Comments (8)

westiemomOriginal Author

idrive65

Related Discussions

westiemomOriginal Author

echoflooring

westiemomOriginal Author

echoflooring

Bellgirl

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

westiemom
Original Author

westiemom
Original Author

westiemom
Original Author