skip to main content

New wood/old wood... will the new wood blend with old in 6-8 mont

14 years ago

Help!

Just had my 100 year old floor refinished (sanded and stained). One area needed repair 4-5 boards. The new wood is noticeably different. If it wasn't for a piece that was cut abnormally shorter than the rest of the floor AND it has a distinctive grain pattern and color from the boards adjacent, I could live with otherwise slight mismatch.

The wood floor guy says that the new wood will change color and blend with the old wood in 6-8 months. Is this true?

Also, he could have used wood from the closet to replace the wood and put the new wood in the closet to be less conspicuous. He offers to do this now (spot repair) and split the cost of materials (charging me $500 for correcting the mistake and having to re-stain the entire floor with one additional coat). Shouldn't he have to pay for this? I am worried that the spot repair will cause the a blending issue with the stain, although the closet wood should match perfectly.

Final issue is that this repair was done due to the wood turning black from repeated dog urination. He sands away the black, but the stain seems to bring the black back up in small spots. I fear the black will continue to progress like it did to begin with.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (3)

organic_nick
14 years ago
Cost of what materials ? the boards he is taking up from your closet .The floor will amber has time goes by , But blending with the new floor it depends on a few things .
Did you ask him to ude product from the closet ?
He should replace the bad board for free , Better yet he should have never installed it . Once the wood has urine in it , I remove it and install a new one .
glennsfc
14 years ago
Very difficult to match new to old, but it can be done. $500 for materials to recoat the floor after the spot repair can be a realistic figure if what is being applioed is an expensive finish and the area is large. However, in my opinion, most spot repairs can be done without having to recoat the entire floor; done that successfully many times.

Did one floor with horrible dog urine damage where the customer agreed to give it a go without board replacements. I applied the dark stain and the urine stains appeared as much darker areas. The result was not up to my standards, but she was pleased with the result.
Related Discussions
New Wood DOESN't match old wood
Q
Comments (2)
A hardwood flooring expert could probably have given you a seamless match. Boxers is correct about color changes as wood ages, however...if the GC matched species, sawing and grading, I don't understand why your repair would "stick out like a sore thumb"...it shouldn't.
...See More
Boo...have to get new wood floors. What looks good old house?
Q
Comments (8)
We have the same situation (oversanded floors) with our 1916 home. It has standard oak floors so we don't have your issue. We're also doing a small addition--half of which is kitchen--and we need to specify our floors (in the new part) next week. (We'll do the old part later, so we have a place to move our stuff into!) A question: Is Tung Oil usable/advisable in a kitchen? Or should we stick with poly? (We have little kids and really use our kitchen!) And does Tung Oil always yield a dark floor? We'd like it fairly light. What we don't want to end up with is one of those really shiny finishes -- but can good floor guys yield a more traditional finish with poly? Any other ideas? Thoughts please! I know that some people say that pre-finished floors are the best for a kitchen, but we really don't like that beveled-edge look.
...See More
New Old House, Marvin Next Generation VS Custom Wood Windows
Q
Comments (6)
If you were going to be truly historic, you shouldn't have air conditioning, but I am going to guess you are going to opt to put that in. Just trying to make the point that being that historic is great, but if you can save $13,000 and make the home considerably more efficient with only the slightest offset in visual (non-detectable to everyone but you or a window professional), why not go that route?
...See More
Make new wood floor look old? Wide plank wood floor.
Q
Comments (22)
We lived in Florida. Wood moves with the seasons, so glue would not allow the movement. Since we laid the floors ourselves in 1997, am working from memory here. We had plywood subfloor down then stacked the flooring in the air conditioned house for several weeks. We face nailed only. I really wanted an antique look and we used cut nails. All those are hammered in by hand. After all the flooring was installed, I mixed two colors of MinWax stains, Puritan Pine and one other ( memory fails me) in a one gallon paint can (new empty cans are sold by paint stores and Lowe’s) so my color would be consistent. No one else can be in the house for over a week while the staining and oiling are being done. Authentic Pine Floors gave me a formula for the finish I mixed in another unused gallon paint can, but I think I would use straight tung oil now. Tung oil must have five or six applications with sufficient drying time between coats. This cannot be rushed. We used tung oil on the cherry floors we laid two years ago in the kitchen of our current house and love it. Our Florida house had carpet upstairs for noise control, so I estimate we had over 2000 square feet of pine floors. My sister used the same material for her house in the Midwest 16 years ago and the floors are still beautiful. My daughter has about 3000 square feet of the same flooring, finished the same way. We all have dogs and active lives. Some people age their floors by dropping chains onto the surface, spreading sharp gravel on the floor and walking around with work boots to scratch the floors, or you can (with extreme caution) roll burning logs onto the hearth area to put a few scorch marks. Then stain and oil the floors. We did none of that at any of our three houses, preferring to let the floors show our history. All wood moves with humidity. It is not much, though. It certainly is not huge gaps.
...See More
Billl
14 years ago
It is pretty easy to get a decent match on older wood - if you are willing to pay! There are numerous companies that specialize in reclaimed lumber. They would be able to match you up with some planks from the same time period and mill them to match yours. We just did that with heart pine in a 1912 house. It is not cheap though. Lumber, milling, installation/weaving, sanding and finishing came in over $25/sq ft. Fortunately it was just a few small patches.

If you are just trying to make a new board look "old" - good luck. Modern lumber just isn't going to have the same look as the old growth trees they were logging 100 years ago. If you can swap out some boards from a closet for "free" that is a better option.

As for the costs, ripping up 2 sections and repairing them obviously will cost more than just 1 section.

For the urine damaged areas - whose idea was it to just sand? If you asked him to do it to save some money on repairs and now don't like the look, expect to pay to have it fixed. If you left it up to the contractor as to which boards to replace and which to salvage and he just did a poor job, then he should stand by his work and fix it.

Related Stories

LOFTS My Houzz: Ronnie Wood’s Old Art Studio Gets a Makeover

By Natalie Wain

Check out this contemporary update of a former factory flat that survived World War II bombs and use by a member of The Rolling Stones

TRANSITIONAL HOMES Houzz Tour: The Science of Blending Old and New

By Mary Jo Bowling

An interior designer helps clients pull together modern furniture and heirloom pieces in a classic home

RUSTIC STYLE Old Southern Highlands Style for a New North Carolina Retreat

Antique woods add a sense of history to a gracious part-time home in the Blue Ridge Mountains

FURNITURE 6 Decades-Old Designs That Look Better Than Ever

After getting a few nips and tucks, some favorites from the ’60s and ’70s have made a stylish comeback

BUDGET DECORATING Budget Decorator: 8 Ways to Make Old Furniture Look Brand New

By Laura Gaskill

Learn stripping, staining, painting and reupholstering basics to make bargain-basement furniture worthy of center stage at home

BATHROOM DESIGN Out With the Old Tile: 8 Steps to Prep for Demolition

By By Any Design Ltd.

This isn't a light DIY project: You'll need heavy-duty tools and plenty of protection for your home and yourself

UNIVERSAL DESIGN My Houzz: Universal Design Helps an 8-Year-Old Feel at Home

By Becki Peckham

An innovative sensory room, wide doors and hallways, and other thoughtful design moves make this Canadian home work for the whole family

MOST POPULAR 8 Reasons to Warm Up With a Wood Plank Wall

By Laura Gaskill

The accent finds a place in every room — adding focus, coziness, definition and more

WOOD Bring Reclaimed Wood to the Landscape

By Falon Mihalic

Learn how to salvage old wood and give it a new life in the garden

HOUZZ TV Houzz TV: Cool Reclaimed Wood Projects Fill a Craftsman’s Home

By Mitchell Parker

Using barn wood, beadboard and beams, this homeowner has crafted furnishings and features for his family’s Chicago home

Sponsored

America Construction

Building Solid, Beautiful & Unique Living Spaces in Fairfax County

More Discussions

Carpet - Looking for recommendations on brands

1

Coretec ravenswood in basement?

1

Need to decide on a shower floor.

4

Need help choosing flooring

9

How do i polish my polyurethane floors

5