Kahrs oil finished floors- a good choice for variable climate?

10 years ago

Hi all!
I've been stalking these forums for months and I've finally decided to start asking some advice!

My husband and I are beginning the remodeling process on our 1960's bi-level home. It's our first house and while my husband and I are definitely handy, we're both nervous about starting major renovations and making big decisions. We've been debating flooring options, considering practicality for our lifestyle, price point and the variable indoor climate we have. The floor will be installed in an entryway (concrete subfloor on ground level), kitchen-dining-living open concept area, and in a hallway to the bedrooms on the main level, on an above grade plywood subfloor. We will have a professional install them.

We have a swamp cooler for the summer and our humidity level gets around 60%+, but during the winter we have electric baseboards and our humidity levels plummet to between 10-15%. Some installers we've talked to express concern for the huge swings in humidity for hardwood, saying that we need to find an alternative or install a whole home humidifier (not an option... too much $$ to run ducting!).

We finally settled on the idea that we needed to look for an alternative to wood and looked heavily into luxury vinyl tile, specifically the Mannington and Karndean lines. We ended up being excited that they seemed so low maintenance (we have a large dog... and let's be honest, I spill. I walk through the house with wet shoes or high heels. I don't make guests take their shoes off. I'm not perfect, and I like being able to LIVE in a house, not constantly worrying about the floors.)

However while shopping, the sales associate introduced us to Kahrs engineered wood flooring-- I mean she RAVED about them-- saying that it would be good for our issues with humidity. She also strongly recommended the oil finish for a lower-maintenance finish (as far as scratches and that sort of thing).

I suppose my questions are: 1) Does anyone have an opinion about putting hardwood in at all with the swings in humidity that we're seeing and 2) Is Kahrs really as wonderful as this lady claims? It's pricey, but pretty much in the same range as the high end luxury vinyl planks we were looking at. 3) Is the oil finish the right choice for a lower maintenance option?

Once I looked at the Kahrs, I got excited again thinking that we could have wood-- but I'd hate to spend a ton of money on something that will gap and swell and look terrible in a year or something that is high maintenance to care for! I'm feeling SO LOST!

Thanks for any thoughts!

(The picture I included is just a preview in a virtual showroom on the Kahrs website of the finish I like.)

Here is a link that might be useful: Why Kahrs Claims to be Good for Changing Climates

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (6)

User
10 years ago
That's a wild swing ... vinyl or tile would be my choice.

Engineered floor might handle it, if it's multi-layered and meant for wide swings. Kahrs is not the only one that uses basically plywood as flooring.

You can do a lot with a few room-sized humidifiers to get the humidity up to the high 20s or low 30s. And turn the heat down to as low as you can stand with a sweater and wool socks on.
User
10 years ago
Youu NEED a whole home humifier for your own comfort as well as any wood products in the home. That is much too much variance, even for engineered or even pieced vinyl. Sheet vinyl could deal probably deal with it.

The only fooring material that really fits your needs is tile. You can probably DIY that install if you don't go too large in size and the subfloor is pretty flat.
Related Discussions
Advice on white oak flooring grade choice
Q
Comments (10)
I agree with PPs - your best bet is going to be a local mill. Also, regarding grades, sometimes "character grade" can be a mix of all grades. Mostly they refer to it around here as "character and better" meaning you get some top grade, mostly character. Also, I'd look into how much expansion and contraction those 7 and 8" boards actually go through - you might end up with some gaps if they move at a different rate than the other narrower boards. I'm currently contemplating 5", 4", and 2" hickory for our house and this is a concern of mine. i haven't found an answer yet but its something to be considered. I will say for character grade oak - it's wonderful and warm but veeeery busy so you should consider that when choosing your other finishes. Regular hickory is even worse - it's almost calico looking once its laid down. We have 3" character grade red oak in our current house and it looks gorgeous and rustic, but I'm already kind of tired of it and I'm worried it'll look dated in another 10 years (I have the same concern with all the grey staining happening these days). Also, with all of the other texture we picked in our cabinets backsplash furnishings, etc., the house feels a little schizophrenic. Unfortunately I had to do all this site unseen, so we didn't realize how everything would look together. Word to the wise. Our next place is going to be variable width blond (clear grade - no heartwood) hickory which I'm hoping will give us the light, uniform appearance we're going for in the Scandinavian/modern style. We're doing Pallman's magic oil which I think will give it a golden appearance over time which will match the existing honey maple cabinetry in the rest of the house. If you do go with character grade, keep a close eye on which boards your installer is using. We had to replace a couple of them because the knots broke out. Anyway - good luck on your choice!
...See More
Debating flooring choices for high traffic FR
Q
Comments (29)
I would compromise and install a very good prefinished real hardwood floor. No one wants the mess & aggravation of refinishing a floor in a house that's occupied. With the extremely durable factory finishes available that are treated to limit being affected by sunlight & abrasion, and the limited availability of skilled tradesmen claiming to be able to install a wood floor from scratch, especially a wide plank, I'd want to select a product and know exactly what I could expect the finished outcome to be. You can check the Flooring Forum and read all the posters complaining the stain color on the floor was not what they expected when they hired guys to install a from-scratch wood floor. Any type of premium vinyl flooring is not stable. Over time, with changes in humidity, the vinyl will shrink and the seams will open. In addition, it's a soft material that can be cut by a stone on the bottom of a shoe or ripped by a high heel missing an end cap. In addition, light colors tend to permanently stain from asphalt driveway material (petrol-chemical) that can be tracked in the bottom of athletic shoes. The only vinyl flooring I would ever consider installing is referred to as VCT (vinyl composition tile as opposed to solid or luxury vinyl) and is used mostly in commercial installations.
...See More
Struggling with engineered wood floor choice, please help!
Q
Comments (11)
R S, yes it felt smooth, but not "slick" smooth. It does have texture, but nothing like hand-scraped. You can feel the texture of the wood through the finish. I had the Lauzon wire-brushed sample and a sample of the Hamptons series "natural" white oak here at the same time. The Hamptons sample is not wire-brushed and has a semi-gloss finish. I could not feel the texture of the wood under that finish. They definitely felt different underfoot and Hamptons flooring was smoother feeling. The wire-brushed is really beautiful. I would not order a whole house full of flooring based on the sample, though, because I'm not quite sure it's a true depiction of the actual flooring. I've always believed that flooring companies use their very best material for the sample boards, so I'd want to look at a full box before committing. If you do get a box, be sure to post what it's like!
...See More
Engineered hardwood flooring brand - oil-finished and long planks
Q
Comments (7)
What are your HVAC capabilities? Do you have a humidistat built into/onto the unit? Can you add/subtract humidity with the push of a button on your thermostat? The HVAC is the deal breaker for wood in a 1960's home. Without climate control (humidity control) wood is going to have a very hard time. Right now the oiled floors are more in the mid-width range 4" and wider (10", etc). Anything narrower and you might have to look at site finished solid or engineered that has been specifically made for you. What is your budget for the materials?
...See More
trufolsom
10 years ago
I love the look of these floors, too. As a matter of fact, I have samples of their Original Harmony line sitting by me, and someone from a local flooring company will be here this morning to take some measurements and give us an estimate. What did you choose?
User
10 years ago
The advice about the humidifier is correct. In other flooring forums there are occasional inquiries about cracking and splitting floor that can be attributed to low RH.
Jordan E
Original Author
10 years ago
I'm so sorry I never replied here-- like I said, I'm a newbie to posting and I didn't have the right settings to get notified when anyone replied and I just assumed no one ever responded! Anyway, thank you so much for your responses.

I know it was months ago, but if you could believe it, still not one major renovation has started. When I finally made the decision to go with the luxury vinyl plank, specifically Mannington Adura Heritage Buckskin (if you are curious!), we started shopping quotes and ohhhh man confusion set in. It's so funny how you go into something so convinced you know what you want and where to start, you talk to a contractor, and then suddenly it seems like everything you previously knew is out the window. We had cabinet contractors telling us to get the floors in first, flooring guys saying floors go in last and we needed to do cabinets first (which we weren't budgeting for yet)... Not to mention we found out we'll be only living in this house part time because my husband's job is now going to split time in another city... EEK!

Needless to say, it got put on the backburner for a little, but we figure that with the split time, it'll be a perfect time to have a construction zone for a house... Since we won't be living in it full time! Hopefully we'll find some contractors we like and trust so we can get this renovation moving!

PurpleDot, how did your flooring decision go? I'd love to know!
skeezix05
9 years ago
Hi, I too am considering the heritage buckskin. As I have read on so many forums, choosing flooring seems to be a daunting task. Have you started the floors yet? Would love to see pictures as all I can find is their ad photo. Hope your transitioning is going smoothly.

Kahrs oil finished floors- a good choice for variable climate?

Comments (6)

User

User

Related Discussions

trufolsom

User

Jordan E
Original Author

skeezix05

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Kahrs oil finished floors- a good choice for variable climate?

Comments (6)

User

User

Related Discussions

trufolsom

User

Jordan EOriginal Author

skeezix05

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Jordan E
Original Author