skip to main content

Positive mold test results, but no mold or moisture!

17 years ago

We recently had a mold inspector test our attic (at the request of a prospective buyer for the home) and although he saw no visible mold, no moisture and no other indicators/conditions that would imply the presence of mold, the results from his air sample tests were positive for several types of mold, including some of the more toxic. The inspector seems to think the mold spores are dead/dormant and just kicked up by the recent activity in the attic.

All of the information we can find about remediation assumes that there is actual mold to remove. What can be done if there are spores in the air (again, probably dead/dormant spores from some moisture long, long ago) but nothing to remedy?

This is a 65 year old house and we just put a new roof on it about 8 years ago. We never had the house or attic tested for mold before and have never experienced any mold-related problems or concerns. Our contractor friends have told us that most homes of this age have mold somewhere, but despite all the bad press, the odds of any mold-related health problems arising are actually very slim.

Regardless, this is a home we need to sell - and very soon. Anyone ever have this problem? How did you solve it? I'm afraid that we could go through some very costly work to possibly install a ventilation fan (including new electrical service) and/or replace the insulation, and the problem could remain just because it's an old house.

The house is in otherwise immaculate condition and this is just killing us! We do have the inspector coming back to test the inside air, but as for now, we're assuming that the "bad air" is limited to the attic. Will know more about that next week.

Anyone with similar experience - would love to hear from you.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (3)

pjb999
17 years ago
For very little money you can have "whirlybird" type ventilators installed in the roof space, you know the types that spin round....they are very effective in removing stale air (and keep the roof space cooler in summer) and should reduce, if not eliminate the mould count, by changing the air frequently.

I had a house in Australia with a mould problem (roof was a tiny bit leaky til we fixed it) and these ventilators made a huge difference.

They're not expensive.
gw:garden-guy
17 years ago
In my area the market has exploded with "professionals" who will (for a fee) do: mold anaylsis, home inspections, home appraisals, etc. Not sure if this is your case but I would be suspect of an analysis that doesn't seem logical. If it were me, I'd ignore the findings (there is a discloser risk) or I'd hire someone who has extensive training at an accredited school.

Additional recommendation: doing inspections at the request of a potential buyer seems unusual. I'm assunming you paid for for the service (not the potential buyer) and now you have to deal with it (is the buyer still around?). I'm not suggestiong that you hide or fail to disclose anything. I am suggesting that results can vary from inspector to inspector and the field is new and not yet a science.
Related Discussions
Using Silicone Caulk as a Mold Material
Q
Comments (72)
Greetings! I've been browsing the net for tips on just this subject and your thread has answered a lot of questions - thank you! I just have one more inquiry - do you know of a way to make the end product of one-part self curing silicones (after curing) softer and stretchier (lets say more like human skin, goal hardness is 10-30 shore A)? The reason I'm asking: I am a resident in heart surgery and I'm trying to make practice models of parts of the human heart and tissue to use for training outside the operating room. As you said the platinum cure silicones are used for this purpose but the price difference is tenfold and they're a bit too expensive for us.
...See More
Help with Soil Test Results
Q
Comments (31)
Peter, Again, I am disagreeing with you about the need for phosphorus but for the sake of discussion: phosphorus rapidly reacts in soil forming stable compounds that are for the most part unavailable to plants. Over time added phosphorus becomes less and less available although a certain amount of phosphorus is always in solution. As it is removed by plants more P goes into solution and maintains an equilibrium. Note that plants can only utilize the P in solution. Measuring how much P is in solution is not very useful because what really needs to be known is how much is going to be available to plants throughout the season, that is how much P is going to go into solution as the small amount that is available to plants is taken up through the roots. Soil tests try and estimate this by digesting soil is various acid solutions (ÂBrayÂ ÂOlsenÂ ÂMehlichÂ etc.). Although these estimates are useful, as I said before they are by no means exact. So what I am saying isnÂt that the 26lbs is wrong and that there is really another 124lbs, what I am saying is that there is probably something like a ton of phosphorus per acre in the soil and the guess that 26lbs is going to be available is just that , a guess and there very well may end up being 200lbs available. Or it could go the other way and there could be less. There are a lot of factors that influence how much P is going to be available including things like pH and michorizal fungi. Fertilizing P in bands or clumps helps with availability because it takes longer for the P to react and become insoluble. So again, I am not disagreeing with you that some P should be added, I am just saying that I wouldnÂt lose any sleep over the results of this soil test. If the pH was 4.5 or 8 or something like that, then I would panic, but of all the things on a soil test you should take with a grain of salt, the P numbers are at the top of the list.
...See More
Options for testing for mold behind drywall?
Q
Comments (1)
Let your nose be your guide. If it smells ok and the carpet isn't getting wet any longer, I would just leave it alone. If there's no longer a source of moisture then any mold on the backside of the drywall isn't going to do much of anything. If you were really curious, you could remove the baseboard, then cut out some drywall behind it. You'll probably find some staining, but if it's not soggy (i.e. dried out), leave it alone.
...See More
Mold test - positive - but NO MOLD!
Q
Comments (7)
After some specialists came to test - 30% humidity inside - and no signs in the house anywhere - they were shocked! BUT - they might have found a source - loose HVAC parts in the crawl space under the house causing condensation and then blowing up into the house. They will have to fix that, clean up down there and then ionize the air in the house and HEPA Vac - also possibly wipe down the flat surfaces with some kind of stuff to mitigate. Hopefully this is the cause and solution in one simple pass. Just hope it's not too expensive to treat as they say insurance probably won't touch it since it's not caused by a "sudden" event.
...See More
perel
17 years ago
I'm willing to go a bit further.

Many "mold experts" are basically scam artists. Not all of them, but many. Just like "duct cleaners".

Every house has mold spores in it. Including "toxic mold". Did this "mold inspector" tell how *much* mold there was in the air? If there's a lot of airborne mold, that would be an indication that you might have a hidden water problem.. but if there's just a small amount, it's perfectly normal and NOT a problem. Do you know what the *outside air* mold counts for your region, in the summer, when it hasn't rained recently, are? If not you can't make a valid comparison with indoor levels.

Attic ventilation can help. If nothing else, it will dilute the air so it tests better, which should calm your buyers down. Shouldn't cost too much to put some "whirlybird" ventilators in as pjb recommended.

Related Stories

DISASTER PREP & RECOVERY How to Combat Mold in a Flooded House

Before you rebuild or restore your water-damaged home, take these steps to keep mold at bay

COLOR Speed-Dial Color Selection to Get the Best Result

By Kimberly Collins Jermain

You’ve belabored your color decisions and are still stuck. Here is how to evaluate your space and make choices that are right for you

DECORATING GUIDES Small Ideas for Big Results

By Erika Ward - Erika Ward Interiors

8 easy changes that can makeover a room, from clearing off the mantel to choosing a new light

GREAT HOME PROJECTS How to Bring Out Your Home’s Character With Trim

By Steven Corley Randel, Architect

New project for a new year: Add moldings and baseboards to enhance architectural style and create visual interest

KITCHEN DESIGN Kitchen of the Week: Pushing Boundaries in a San Francisco Victorian

By Mary Jo Bowling

If the roll-up garage door doesn’t clue you in, the blue cabinets and oversize molding will: This kitchen is no ordinary Victorian galley

THE ART OF ARCHITECTURE Architect's Toolbox: Rain Screens Up House Health

By Bud Dietrich, AIA

To thwart unwanted moisture and poor air quality in your home, think rain screens and drainage planes

Kit Houses Stand the Test of Time

By Bud Dietrich, AIA

See how these mass-produced catalog houses have made their way into the modern day

GREEN BUILDING Houzz Tour: See a Concrete House With a $0 Energy Bill

By Mitchell Parker

Passive House principles and universal design elements result in a home that’ll work efficiently for the long haul

HOUSEKEEPING How to Clean and Care for Your Mattress

By Bonnie McCarthy

See what the experts recommend to protect your mattress from dust, moisture and stains

HEALTHY HOME What's the Deal With Radon?

By Laura Gaskill

Get the facts on testing for this cancer-causing gas — and how to make your home safe if it shows up

Sponsored

More Discussions

mitigation charges

17

Quartz Countertop issue after 3 attempts to get it right.

12

Real quartz or faux?

7

water found in soil sample

7

Granite countertop help

3