Critique these plans! Tell me whats lacking!!
9 years ago
Featured Answer
Sort by:Oldest
Comments (16)
- 9 years ago
- 9 years ago
Related Discussions
help me critique this plan (visbeen)
Comments (12)thanks to all of you for your help - it is much appreciated! I never thought finding a perfect plan could be this frustrating! bigkahuna - you are right on both accounts - this plan doesn't really fit our lot of 10 acres (pretty much wide open space - no slopes) I just liked some of the features. I almost wish our lot did provide some issues - then I wouldn't have so many possibilities & options to consider! oicu812 - thanks for posting that house. It definitely has some features that I'm looking for - love the home office, big pantry & playroom upstairs. I've looked at Fuller's designs before, but I will go back and take another look. The only thing is - a lot of his plans seem fairly narrow & boxy and I'm looking for something at least 70-80 ft wide (or wider) and I'd love for the great room to have windows on at least 2 walls if possible. As for the 3rd floor, I'm not really sure. I'd say in a perfect world, I would keep all 3 kiddos bedrooms on the 2nd floor and then maybe the playroom/rec room could be on the 3rd floor. Or maybe my mom cave/art studio? wishful thinking, ha! :) I'm in the process of drawing up my own plan with Chief Architect and will post soon for some feedback. thanks again - it's so nice to be able to shoot around ideas with others going through the same thing!...See MoreFloor Plan Modifications - Help me Critique
Comments (12)Young-gardner - It's so hard to try to shrink things - esp when at the same time you need to add things. Not sure it's going to be possible but I am trying! As for the kitchen - that is what I was thinking 19' is HUGE. My current kitchen is a tight 10x10 which is small but 19' - I have no idea what I'd do with all of that length - seems to be awkward being so long and narrow. Thanks for the pics, that helps since I am a very visual person! I did some more modification like you suggested and then again another way in that area and it is just an odd shape to try to adjust I think. :( I haven't given up yet. I do really like having windows facing 2 sides in the kitchen (even though part of them are really in the dining area). Kelhuk-thanks for your thoughts. I was wondering that very thing about the living room. I definitely do not want to get into that type of situation since I basically have something similar now. It has so many openings at opposite ends that you have to literally walk through the middle of living room to get from the hallway to the kitchen. There is no way to walk a perimeter. Makes for awkward furniture placement too. Thanks for you comments - hoping others will chime in a well. I am wondering since the 1st plan (which was really the second picture) will be easier to modify since I need to add a 1/2 bath but in it's current state I have a little bit of wiggle room with sq footage. Any ideas on how to add a screened in porch on that first one? Back to the drawing board. Every time I feel like I'm 'close' the more I look at it not so much. Good thing I'm starting early....See MoreAnyone willing to critique this plan for me?
Comments (44)I do hope you can get your husband to think about finding an architect. Maybe do some research here on the boards and reach out to one of the architects on this board? Also I was thinking about what he said about feeling uneducated regarding building after sitting down with one architect. When you think about it, if you go to the doctor, you don't expect to be immediately educated if the doctor comes back and tells you that you have a condition. You realize you'll need your doctor to guide you and then of course you also go home and do research, so that you understand your options better. It's the same with building a house and hiring a good architect who listens to you and your needs. It's a collaborative process. You need to find the right professional to guide you....See MoreGive me some hard love! Floor plan critique
Comments (24)This is really long and will boggle your mind with possibilities... but I did some thinking about your laundry room space. I can't make everything all fit perfectly, so I'm throwing a bunch of ideas out so you can see what could get traded off and/or sacrificed according to your own priorities... By the way, keep in mind I'm working off assumed/guessed measurements. If my assumption about the position of your existing bathroom is off, it changes how much fair-game space exists between the you-can't-touch-this existing bathroom wall and the front entry wall of the house. (BTW, I have it drawn as 27'3") So here's version 1 (aka Smallish Laundry) Shower in the bath, access to laundry room from front door or from bedrooms, but smaller laundry room, with only 3 feet of counter space, and your son gets a pretty small closet. Here's version 2 (aka No Shower) Laundry room much bigger, access to laundry room from the bedrooms or the front door (hubby can at least drop his muddy clothes in the laundry room), but no shower in the front bath. (BTW, this laundry room should be flipped, so the washer/dryer are on the bath wall instead of the closet wall - that would consolidate the plumbing a bit, and also reduces the noise to your son's bedroom a little.) Here's Version 3, aka Small Bedroom laundry room has space, shower in the front bathroom, access to the laundry from the bedrooms - but, your son's bedroom starts feeling pretty cramped. By the way, an aside about entry cubbies. All three of the versions above have a little less cubby space than your original plan because of the entrance to the hall. Version 2 (No Shower) has the least - Versions 1 and 3 get a few more inches by turning the cubbies sideways, which might also mean the entry feels a little less cramped - especially if you could move the door to the left so it doesn't crowd the cubbies behind the stairs. And on the cubbies themselves: in these drawings, they're set up as 21" deep, split between hanging space and bench space (10.5" each). So versions 1 and 3 look like this the way I've drawn them: I did a version 4 that sacrificed access to the laundry room from the front door, but realized that if you're not able to access the laundry room from the front door, placing it in that position doesn't make sense. It makes more sense put the laundry room next to the existing bath (plumbing is more consolidated this way), like this: So this is basically the plan you already have, but with a shower in the front bath. My reasoning for wanting to shift things around in the first place was that the master suite felt really cramped trying to occupy the space between the front of the house and the bathroom, and you had to choose between a walk-in closet and a walk-in shower - you couldn't do both in that space. So lets step away from the entry way for a moment and visit that master suite: I realized I hadn't added a closet to your daughter's room, and doing so meant I had to make that room a little bigger, which decreased the space I had thought existed for the master bath. At first glance, pass-between closets to the master bath jumped out at me, so I drew it that way. At 3' deep, the one on the north wall could be configured as a shallow walk-in (6' total hanging space down both sides, plus wall space on the north wall) or just a really deep reach-in (5'10 hanging space as drawn here) - in either case, you end up with a little more total closet space than your proposal (looks like about 8' as proposed). There's a ton of other options for how to configure the back of the house - but the point is, I think enough space exists there to give you better layout choices than trying to jam the master between the bath and the entry - as long as you shift the proposed laundry room across the hall the the west side of the house. Again, though, keep in mind I'm working off guesswork measurements. You'll need to tweak/rearrange based on the actual measurements of your house. Back to the entry/laundry/bath: You could keep the laundry room up front but nix the access from the bedrooms to the laundry room to eliminate the need for the hall: I personally don't like this one: you have to lug all your laundry back and forth through the kitchen. Bu I included it for the sake of being thorough. :-) Then I started thinking about different ways the entry, laundry, bath, and hall could interact - would getting the bathroom door out of the entry help?I personally don't like this one largely because there's nowhere in the bathroom to put a window - even with two outside walls, you still end up with a dark bathroom. I'm sure there's other ways to configure this space to fix that - maybe with a smaller shower stall instead of a full-sized tub? But I'm not going to take the time to look at them right now... I think this is enough confusion for a little while! :-) Thanks for letting me play with your house! :-)...See More- 9 years ago
- 9 years ago
- 9 years ago
- 9 years ago
- 9 years ago
- 9 years ago
- 9 years ago
- 9 years ago
- 9 years ago
- 9 years ago
- 9 years ago
- 9 years ago
- 9 years ago
Related Stories
LIFETell Us: What Made You Fall for Your Kitchen?
Show the heart of your home some love for Valentine’s Day
Full StoryFRANK LLOYD WRIGHTWhat Frank Lloyd Wright's Own House Tells Us
The buildings dreamed up here changed the course of architecture — and Wright's home was no less a design lab than the studio itself
Full StoryREMODELING GUIDESContractor's Tips: 10 Things Your Contractor Might Not Tell You
Climbing through your closets and fielding design issues galore, your contractor might stay mum. Here's what you're missing
Full StoryLANDSCAPE DESIGNThe Garden Gate: A Preface to the Story Your Garden Wants to Tell
Setting the tone for your garden starts with the right entry
Full StoryLIFETell Us: Do You Know How to Live With Your Parents?
If you've tried multigenerational living under one roof, we'd love to hear the details
Full StoryFUN HOUZZHouzz Call: Tell Us About Your Dream House
Let your home fantasy loose — the sky's the limit, and we want to hear all about it
Full StoryARCHITECTURETell a Story With Design for a More Meaningful Home
Go beyond a home's bones to find the narrative at its heart, for a more rewarding experience
Full StoryFEEL-GOOD HOMEGuys Tell Us About Their Favorite Places at Home
For Father’s Day, Houzz men show us the places in their homes where they like to hang out
Full StoryVALENTINE’S DAYTell Us: Why Did You Fall in Love With Your House?
What was it about your house that made your heart flutter? Share your photo, and it could make the Houzz homepage
Full StoryGARDENING GUIDESWhat Are Your Spring Gardening Plans?
Tearing out the lawn? Planting edibles? Starting from scratch? Tell us what you plan to change in your garden this year
Full Story
sheloveslayouts