Sheet vinyl vs porcelain tile in hall bath?

12 years ago

Debating sheet vinyl vs porcelain tile for hallway bathroom.

We are redoing all 3 bathrooms at once so cost is important but not the only consideration.

We will be using porcelain floor tiles with radiant heat in the master bath. It will get daily use, so we are willing to spend more in this room.

We also will use porcelain floor tiles in the main floor bathroom. We use it daily in the daytime, and it also serves as a powder room for guests. In anticipation of "aging in place", we plan to install a curbless shower now, but we hope not to use that feature for a long, long time. We are not sure if we will install radiant heat in this room or not.

The one place where we could save money would be to use sheet vinyl rather than porcelain tile in the upstairs hall bathroom. Our son and his family live in Japan and visit for just a few weeks each year. Other overnight guests visit only occasionally, so this bathroom gets infrequent use. That room has the original sheet vinyl which is still in fairly good shape after 30 years, but we would like to update the color. Actually, it is not just for color. We will be moving the vanity and a wall to give the master bath another foot, so the floor will be torn up in at least one area. We do plan to replace the tile in the tub/shower enclosure, but we are not sure whether we should replace the floor with tile or just a better color of sheet vinyl.

Any thoughts?

Should we absorb the higher cost of putting in tile now while we are doing all three bathroom? Are we being pennywise and pound foolish, and will we regret staying with vinyl when the rest of the rooms will be getting tile? On the other hand, does vinyl have some benefits of its own besides lower price? Would it be more comfortable underfoot for kids and visitors? If we opt for tile, are we also going to want/need to install radiant heat at the same time?

I will welcome your opinions. Thanks.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (4)

treasuretheday
12 years ago
There are some really nice and fairly inexpensive tile options available so I wouldn't let the cost keep me from putting it in the third bathroom.

I have never been a fan of sheet vinyl flooring, especially its ability to hold up over time. In both our basement bath and my parents' kitchen, both of which were professionally installed, it seems to have shrunk away from a threshold and now has an ugly curled edge. When that happens, I think it looks really cheap. If your 30 year old vinyl has held up well, maybe this is an example of "they don't make things like they used to."
dibgar
Original Author
12 years ago
If we go with vinyl or some other resilient flooring, we want to avoid cracks or seams. That is why I am considering sheet style.

We did have curling with the vinyl that previous owners put in our kitchen (on a center seam, not around the edges). but we won't have any seams in this smaller room.

This room will not get frequent use most of the year, but I wonder if there would be advantages to having something like vinyl when our granddaughter does visit. She is just 1 year old and I'm thinking about the potential for things dropping on a harder floor.

What do people prefer for a bathroom used by children?
Related Discussions
porcelain tile directly over old vinyl tile, with radiant heat?
Q
Comments (4)
I would peel up whatever vinyl sheets are there. Then scrape the rest with a scraper. Tile needs a good substrate or the tile could crack, your grout break up, or tiles become loose. I would use something like Schluter-DITRA (Mike Holmes uses it constantly) orange waffle. I used a blue mat I found in the tile section of HD. It's intended to quiet tile for upstairs flooring, but it had a sticky tar like backing that made it ideal for laying over old laminate that wouldn't come up. Here is a link that might be useful: Schluter-DITRA orange waffle
...See More
Sheet vinyl flooring vs click lock vinyl tiles
Q
Comments (4)
Wow. Ok. Where to start. First and foremost the SHEET vinyl is the only one that can brag about water proof. If you have leaky pets or leaky people, this is the go-to product if water PROOF is a requirement. Sheet vinyl requires a professional install which is normally quite reasonable. The costs grow with the subfloor PREPARATION costs (where are a separate line item that may not have a "final total" until the job is complete). The click together vinyl planks are all the rage right now. Some are DIY friendly - but most are quite picky about technique and take +++patience to learn how to do it right without breaking the click-edge. It is possible to do this yourself....but it requires an understanding that you will have a STEEP learning curve. Be OK with that. The cost to install the planks is a little bit more than laminate flooring. Again the costs go much higher once subfloor preparation is added in. Again, this is a separate line item that, as above, might not have a final tally until the job is complete. The "flatness" quotient for vinyl planks is extremely important and can be considered outside the comfort zone of many long-term DIYers who have tackled several different projects. Again, it is possible to DIY....but it takes quite a bit of time to learn the skill/trade. A professional can have most of this done before you have figured out how to work the self-leveling-compound (which is not self-leveling BTW). Is there anything else that you were looking at for information? I've just touched on the two biggest differences between the two products. I didn't know how much info you were looking for.
...See More
debating vinyl or porcelain tile
Q
Comments (7)
Is this for yourself or are you planning for resale? If the former, go with that you like - if you are only planning to sell in 10-15+ years it will likely be ripped out by a new buyer anyway and in meantime it has served you and what you want. For resale...vinyl plank can be nice, but in a higher end home I would expect tile versus vinyl for those areas. But what is higher end for you and your market? What is “expected” in that price range? I I have two separate friends who just built $550-$600k homes and both put LVP everywhere (~3000sf and ~4500sf). In some areas I know for example wood would be expected at that price range, but here laminate, LVP, etc is still suitable and even expected. They both like it as it is warm (can get cold here), comfortable underfoot, and for one of them good with their young kids and big dogs. Also, what is it next to? If next to hardwoods, don’t use a wood look LVP. Looks off. Ultimately, pros and cons to each so pretty personal. My friends are happy with their LVP (though one of them does not like cleaning it as much as she chose a dark colour so it shows everything and she can’t use her steam mop anymore) and I am considering it for when we finish our basement if we don’t go with carpet, but I chose tile for entry, baths, laundry, etc. Ultimately I just preferred the aesthetics of tile in those spaces.
...See More
Engineered Vinyl Plank (EVP) vs. Luxury Vinyl Plank vs Engineered Hard
Q
Comments (24)
@V M sorry, just seeing your post above. We are just now finally breaking ground on our home so I don't have pics of the flooring to show you from my house. I will come back and post when I do but that will be some months from now. But we are paying, I think, 15K for our Multi-Length Rigid Core SPC floors in color Sandhill. Our house will be 2975 sf and this floor covering will be throughout the home, except in 3 of the full baths and the utility room. I'm not exactly sure how many square feet that leaves but hopefully you can do some rough math. Everything goes through my builder so I don't have an exact price per square foot to provide you. I also am not sure if this includes labor to install.
...See More
jakkom
12 years ago
Sheet vinyl has made real improvements over the years. When I checked in 2003 the patterns were okay but not great. When I checked in March 2011, I was pleasantly surprised by how much better the patterns looked.

No, they are not 'perfect' imitations of stone/wood. But they are much better than they were, and they are also soft and comfortable underfoot in a way tile never is. Easy to clean, and quiet too, which were important considerations for us because of the reversed design of our house (our master suite is downstairs, not up).

This is the Armstrong sheet vinyl we chose:
brendainnj
12 years ago
We just installed vinyl tiles in our main (ha-only!) bathroom, replacing very old sheet vinyl. The difference with these tiles is that they can be grouted so they look just like tile. I think they're referred to as "luxury vinyl tile". The benefit of tile, yet without the coldness/hardness. Many of the major manufacturers carry them, ours was Armstrong. Although they're "peel & stick", a friend in the flooring business recommended using additional flooring adhesive rather than just the glue on the back of the tile. My only advice is to get the highest "grade" in the line...ours is only "better" and I can see minor scratches showing up. We purchased from Lowes so I expect flooring stores to carry better quality. But overall, it is beautiful and really does look just like ceramic tile. Very easy for the DIYer, unlike real tile it can be grouted immediately after laying the tile.

Hope this helps, as I never knew there was such a thing.

Here is a link that might be useful: Armstrong's Groutable vinyl tiles

Sheet vinyl vs porcelain tile in hall bath?

Comments (4)

treasuretheday

dibgar
Original Author

Related Discussions

jakkom

brendainnj

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Sheet vinyl vs porcelain tile in hall bath?

Comments (4)

treasuretheday

dibgarOriginal Author

Related Discussions

jakkom

brendainnj

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

dibgar
Original Author