Based on your description of the other materials in the bathroom, my favorite is the RH Hutton Espresso console. Though I am not an architecture expert, I do wonder how such refined materials as dark walnut hardwood, carrara marble, and polished nickel will fit in with a craftsman. So maybe the weathered oak would work better. Would you consider sharing pictures of your kitchen or other parts of your home including other bathrooms?

Hi pricklypear - thanks for your input! Well, it's a new build with craftsman details...so I've selected more modern (but classic) finishes. Since it's a new build in the process, I don't have pics of completed bathrooms/kitchen available right now. But, there are espresso shaker cabinets in the master and main bath as well. One with brushed nickel hardware and granite vanity, the other with polished nickel and marble vanities. Kitchen has creamy white shaker cabs with espresso island. My initial thought is that the RH parson sink will have the same general look/feel as the other bathrooms and kitchen and provide some consistency. While the weathered oak vanity would provide some contrast/interest and just a different look? What do you think?

With the description of the other bathrooms in the house, I think I too would go with the RH Hutton. I personally prefer a more consistent (with some variation) look between bathrooms and kitchens in a house. I don't think it would look bad to go with one of the other vanities, but the RH Hutton espresso seems more consistent with your other choices, and it's a really lovely console.