Can I tap into existing ductwork for basement heat?

18 years ago

We just finished roughing in our basement. Everything is DIY. This is our third basement. In our first house we installed electric baseboard heat. In our next one we used the existing heat pump and just added additional duct work. That house was 1800 sq ft and the basement increase it to 2700, all on one heat pump. We didn't have any problems doing this. All three floors were comfortable and our electric bill was not astronomical. This house is 3000 sq ft and each floor (1500 sq ft) has it's own heat pump. The basement will add another 1500 sq ft and we would like to do the same thing. Used the furnace that's currently down there and just add additional duct work. The basement is a walkout on one side with the three other sides below grade. We also plan to use the radiant floor heating pads under the flooring in several rooms down there.

Is this okay? Do you think 3000 sq ft will be too much for one furnace to handle? Will it reduce the amount of heat that gets to the main level requiring the furnace to run longer and harder?

I plan to ask the building inspector these questions when he comes on Monday to do our roughin inspection. I considered calling a hvac company but figured they would just try to sell me another furnace whether I need one or not.

Your thoughts would be greatly appreciated. DH is on vacation next week and we hope to drywall then.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (6)

blue_fastback
18 years ago
Depends on the rating of the furnace. An honest hvac company would be the one to ask,
rumble_s
18 years ago
Heating systems are designed to replace heat lost to the outside under normal operating conditions. Will the heat pump run lnger and harder if you pipe the heat to te basement? Of course it will. Will this be catastrophic? Probably not. Basements are not a major heat loss, provided they are insulated. Make sure you have cold air return as well as heat inputs in the basement area.

Normaly you will not see much of a problem when it's not real cold. The bigger the heat pump (tons), the more likely it will be able to handle the full heating needs at sub-freezing temperatures. If it cannot keep up in heat-pump mode it will use resistance heat to supplement. (That is the same as baseboard).
Related Discussions
Heat Pump Ductwork/Trane XR14
Q
Comments (2)
Also just an owner/DIYer, although I have a day job as an engineer. Garyg has it right on rigid duct being preferable to flex. If you can, you want to limit flex duct runs to the 5 feet or so at the end of each run. I don't have any experience with rigid fiberglass duct. I'd also go for several more returns to get full coverage. Since you're investing in a new system, you want that system sized properly. The gold standard for sizing is ACCA Manual J for the cooling equipment and Manual D for ductwork. I'd be concerned about anyone who was just going on square footage to determine AC tonnage. The other thing I'd want done is a duct blaster test on the installed system. Basically this determines how leaky the ductwork is. If the contractor has the capability to DIY the test, that'd be a great sign. If not, there are 3rd party testers who'll do it for a couple hundred bucks. But, and this is a big one, if the contractor hasn't had his ducts blown before, I'd have him talk to the tester before starting to understand what kind of extra steps he may need to take that he isn't accustomed to. A good leakage rate for a newly-installed duct system is 0.05 cfm/sq ft- that's cubic feet per minute per square foot of your conditioned space. My perspective is that we used a contractor (existing house, new system in attic) who said, "yeah, I put in tightly sealed duct." It tested at over 1-ton of leakage on a 3.5-ton system. Even though I thought we'd made it clear up front what we expected (and that he had the opportunity to adjust pricing accordingly), it turned into a big mess. And I inherited the job of going back and finding the leaks and patching them. If I had it to do over, I'd still want the system sized properly and installed with minimal leakage. And I'd have hired someone else. Here are some resources: http://www.southface.org/web/resources&services/publications/factsheets/22blowdoor.pdf http://www.southface.org/web/resources&services/publications/factsheets/2duct_q&a.pdf http://www.southface.org/web/resources&services/publications/technical_bulletins/HCES-HVAC-selection%2002-779.pdf http://www.southface.org/web/resources&services/publications/technical_bulletins/DD-Air-sys-design%2002-0782.pdf http://www.southface.org/web/resources&services/publications/technical_bulletins/DIS-Air-sys-install%2003-0783.pdf
...See More
Limits of existing ductwork
Q
Comments (6)
If you have the actual dimensions of the ducts and access to the plenum (main trunk line from the furnace/fan-coil), they can be calculated from dimensions. When possible, I usually oversize ductwork to reduce air velocity and noise, BUT in cases where the ductwork's insufficient I've then modified systems to produce colder / warmer air than normal. There are a few caveats and limitations to this method, which a competent HVACR engineer can handle and work around. No matter what you do, you're not going to be able to move air below freezing through ducts without problems, similarly you're not going to be able to cool a 20x20 room with a single 4" duct without making substantial amounts of noise. I've had many arguments with various contractors about this over the years, but I've yet to have one of these modified systems have problems due to the modifications. I usually end up hiring a refrigeration contractor since most HVAC guys only sell boxes and aren't into tampering with things. The refer guys actually understand how this stuff works in a carnal nature and are understand how to modify equipment for the desired results.
...See More
Hide Ductwork for basement addition
Q
Comments (4)
The best way is to run the duct work parallel to the ceiling joists. You may have to cross a over a joist. In that case the joist can have a 6 or 8 inch diameter perforation if it is done properly and follows the rules. If the basement is mostly underground, you won't need as many vents as the rooms above ground. The vents are mostly for heating. The cooling load is typically very small.
...See More
Unconventional ways to vent range hood--tap into other existing vents?
Q
Comments (7)
Normally, the street sewer to which one's DWV plumbing is connected has a clear air path from under the street to the residence roof via the house DWV. Through this path, and the many others in the development, toxic and/or odoriferous gasses pass. The gasses are kept from the household air by water traps at the points of use. To have any chance that the gasses would not get into the kitchen hood and thence the kitchen when the hood system blower is off, a set of well sealed and powered dampers interconnected with the hood blower would be needed. I doubt even that would pass modern building codes, but it could function. Other houses' DWV would potentially be part of your venting system.
...See More
sierraeast
18 years ago
If your heating system was properly calc'd and designed for your layout, you could jeapordize the system rendering it less efficient. I would go the hvac route and get a professional opinion.Ask around for someone who is reputable, and you might want to get more than one opinion on this.Same as estimates, should be free of charge.Building inspector should be good to advise as well, but i would still get more than one opinion.
woodinvirginia
17 years ago
Where do you live ? Climate & conditions will most likely provide you with an answer. Most HVAc guys are looking to SELL you another system; not tell you how to save $$$ on your existing unit by bypassing them. Check with Housing Inpector to see if it is NOT a code violation to tap in first.Then check to see how many BTU your furnace produces.
Most sytems are OVERSIZED when they put them in. But they try to bamboozle most homeowners saying they have to do a LOAD CALCULATION to tell you whther you can do this and that. Most College 1st year engineering students can tell you that answer in 10 minutes w/o involving the HVAC guy.Plus you get an answer from some one NOT trying to sell you something.
funnycide
17 years ago
How well does your heat pump heat your house in the winter? If it does fine then you probably will be okay. What flooring are you using over the electric radiant pads? ceramic tile? You probably need very little heat. The problem with using the heat pump is typically a heat pump does not put out very warm air. You are then blowing it from the ceiling so the temp at the floor might be pretty cold. Putting a low return will help this.
legardhome
Original Author
17 years ago
Thanks for taking the time to answer. We actually are in the final stages of our basement. Carpet ordered today. We did end up checking with several hvac companies because my builder said he didn't think the unit was large enough to handle the additional space since it was broken into several rooms. Had it been one large space we would have been okay, but we put in a bedroom, bath, media room, gym and playroom all opening off a cental hall. So the basement now has it's own 1 1/2 ton 12 seer heat pump at a cost of $3500. We are in central VA. Just thought I'd post this info for anyone out there who might be in a similar situation. We also paid a drywall guy to mud/tape the drywall. Everything else has been diy. Will post pictures soon.

Can I tap into existing ductwork for basement heat?

Comments (6)

blue_fastback

rumble_s

Related Discussions

sierraeast

woodinvirginia

funnycide

legardhome
Original Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Can I tap into existing ductwork for basement heat?

Comments (6)

blue_fastback

rumble_s

Related Discussions

sierraeast

woodinvirginia

funnycide

legardhomeOriginal Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

legardhome
Original Author