Please educate me on range hoods!

14 years ago

I'm having custom cabinetry made and my cabinet maker says he can build a wood cover to go over my range hood but that I first need to give him the specs for the "guts" of the hood. Who knew this would be so complicated?

First off, I'm on my own here having fired my builder mid-way thru my build. It's a long story but you'll quickly understand why...

My range will sit against an inside wall about 6 ft from the nearest exterior wall. However, my stupid builder ran the vent duct nearly 25 feet (yes, TWENTY-FIVE FEET) to another exterior wall altogether! Why? Because instead of using open-web trusses between my two floors as indicated on my plans, he decided to save himself some money by using i-beam trusses which he ran parallel to the exterior wall thru which my range hood should have vented. Then, when it was way too late to replace the trusses, he apparently "discovered" that he could nor cut holes thru the i-beam trusses large enough to accomodate the vent duct without compromising the structural integrity of the house! So, ex-builder ran the vent duct 25 feet to the next nearest wall instead! GRRR.... And that was just one of about a hundred things he screwed up before I finally got fed up and fired him.

But to get back to the issue...

I've selected a 30" wide freestanding gas (propane) range. (Kenmore model 77489) with 53,200 BTUs total. I've read that you need a vent that will draw about 10CFM for every 100 BTUs so that would work out to about 550CFM IF it weren't for that 25 ft long duct. On the plus side, I know I won't EVER use all the burners at once however. I'm a decent cook but no Julia Child and beside, most of the time I only cook for DH and myself and since we're both on low-fat diets, I almost never fry anything.

I think the vent duct ex-builder put in is an 8" diameter piece of flex duct. It might be 10 inch diameter. (I need to go measure it to be sure.) I do know that, except for a 90 degree turn at the ceiling, it runs straight.

My original plan had been to get a custom copper hood but that is totally out of the question now b/c my budget has been so totally blown fixing (or trying to fix) all the issues my ex-builder saddled me with.

Plan B is to have a wood hood made to look something like the one in this pic:

My cabinet guy says he can build a wood surround but he doesn't really know what to advise me to get in the way of "working parts". Help! I need to keep the cost down as much as possible. Any experts out there willing to give advice?

Model names and numbers that would be appropriate in my situation would be really nice.

Many thanks. Gardenweb is the only thing that has kept me half-way sane throughout this whole build.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (3)

guadalupe
14 years ago
First problem you have is that he used flex duct, that is not for ventilation, that is for air conditioning or heating. Cooking produces grease and flex duct will trap the grease in the creases and cause you problems and maybe a grease fire. Cooking ventilation requires solid round or rectangular duct.
That being said there are a million different power pack inserts for wood hoods and they probably range in price from $250.00 to $1000.00 depending upon what you want to do. Most of the better units would be 500 cfm or better and they will all work with your circumstances They have units with mesh filters and with baffle filters and vent-a-hood uses a magic lung if you like spitoons. Baffle performs the best over all because it scrubs the grease out of the air and cleans up in the dishwasher. they range in widths from 20" to 58", you could use 20, 22, 27, 28 in your hood and they do install easily. They should be recessed into the hood at least 3" stndard is 4" and that will create the proper capture area that you will need. Some units are also remote control and some will allow for seperate wall switch control is you so desire. If you stay away from the cheap mesh filter units that are probal between 300 and 450 cfm you should be ok. Your biggest problem is the flexable duct that was installed.
davidro1
14 years ago
Ditto. "... solid round or rectangular duct. "
-- Go to a big hardware store and ask to see "galvanized" duct. It's steel, zinc-coated to be anti-rust.

Ditto. "... power pack inserts ... and they will all work ... with mesh filters and with baffle filters...."
-- I have a Fantech FG6 which is INLINE, i.e. inserted into the duct somewhere along its length, not down in front of your ears!

Ditto, "... recessed ... create the proper capture area that you will need...."
-- Think of it as a sink, turned upside down. The bigger the sink, the better it is at doing its main job of capturing smelly greasey smokey air before it gets sucked outdoors.

----

"... low-fat diets, I almost never fry..." "8" - 10" diameter "
Good! You have a clear idea what you don't need a vent for. You don't need to go to the highest CFM exhausts, which cause problems since they need Make-Up Air to replace the air being blown out of the house. You also don't need to insist on a baffle filter: mesh work too.

----

"... an inside wall about 6 ft from the nearest exterior wall. ... ran parallel to the exterior wall thru which my range hood should have vented. ..."

What is your ceiling height? What about a header box under the ceiling? That is where you run a (e.g.) 4" by 14" duct. Total less than 6" header. If not that, what about soldering steel support on the I beam, at the place where you will Cut The I Beam, to let the duct through to the exterior wall. I would do that. then the duct goes through the I beam. Consult someone else first.

"... build a wood cover to go over my range hood but that I first need to give him the specs..."
see thread below as one example.

Here is a link that might be useful: exhaust hood, custom covered in: Finished White Kitchen
Related Discussions
Please help me decide on range and hood!
Q
Comments (5)
I like the Cafe unit and haven't had many complaints at all from my customers. It adds the second oven/warming drawer. Five burners, griddle, self-cleaning oven racks, and the look of a pro range. You could buy a Viking 30" all gas (VGCC5304BSS) on special. We're selling it for $3999 plus a $750 mail-in rebate plus another $150 facebook rebate from Viking, making it $3099 after rebates. The burners are all solid brass and all go to 15K and simmer very well. I also like the Capital GCR305 for $3899 less $500 mail-in rebate. Five burners, four of them at 19K and the 5th center burner at 25K with a reversible wok grate. All burners simmer at 140 degrees. The Viking and Capital are pro-style ranges, are all-gas, do not have self-cleaning, and don't have warming drawers. Gas ovens are more moist but are not quite as precise as electric convection ovens. I have a Bosch gas convection range and a Dacor electric convection oven at home. The Dacor does do a better job - but it's not night and day. Just slight differences. The Bosch slide-in range is dual-fuel, has the warming drawer. The grates are a little tall because of the gas-on-glass design, but overall a solid unit. The Bertazzoni is very nice, but the all-gas model will be pushing out heat between the control panel and top of oven door. You can hear the fan as well. The oven temp goes no lower than 275 degrees, so no warming feature. But for $3000 to $3500 a good unit. In my opinion, the Capital and Viking units on special are better units for the same money. The Dacor ER30G is the only gas range with new electronic technology controlling the temp inside it's gas oven. It performs as well as an electric convection oven. It can be purchased in free-standing or slide-in for $3599. The "Love you back" promo will get you a free 7-piece pots and pans set. 18K max burner. Have you considered an Induction range? It will perform just as well as gas with less heat and better distribution of the heat to your pan. The GE PHB925 runs around $2200 and has a warming drawer and convection oven. The Zephyr hood is nice, and so is the Kobe. I also like Vent-A-Hood. We have more service issues with Electrolux than other brands, but they have nice options. The BlueStar and Capital culinarian are nice choices for around $4000. Both with the open burners 22K or 23K distributing power more evenly and great for wok cooking.
...See More
Please recommend a range hood for me
Q
Comments (7)
seattleCraftsman, I don't do a lot of grilling on the range, but I do occasionally sear things. My biggest ventilation issue is with the long, slow cooking foods like chili or spaghetti sauce or roasts. Since I don't have a good hood, I end with a house that smells like onions for days! kompy, thank you for that link to the Zephyr. That looks better to me than some of the other under cabinet hoods I've seen. There are some pictures on houzz where the hood was flanked by 2 cabinets but had no cabinets above it. Then all 3 pieces were topped with a filler and the same crown. I have 8' ceilings so that might work for me. I will have to investigate the recommended height for installation on the various under cabinet hoods out there. Maybe once I see it mocked up on the architect's super-snazzy software, I can get a better idea of what it will look like. I want it to function well, but I also want the scale to look appropriate.
...See More
Please show me your glass range hood
Q
Comments (1)
How invisible do you want it to be, and how modern? I have the Zephyr Europa Genova pictured here. It's an under-cabinet mo del, with a glass part that slides out to activate the fan and light. Mine is recirculating and works great (for a recirculating fan) so I can only imagine that the real vented one would be terrific.
...See More
Please help me decide which range hood to buy
Q
Comments (6)
I can't recommend hoods I've never used, but will comment on general requirements and how particular hoods seem to conform or not. The blurb under each price for the two Best units describes the differences -- baffles vs. mesh filters, for example, plus the (somewhat unneeded in my view) automatic blower control for the more expensive. I would go for baffles, but the flow rate into the hood aperture should be capable of around 90 ft/min, which corresponds to 90 CFM/sq. foot of aperture. The Best baffle hood's aperture area seems to be under 6 sq. ft., so a flow rate of 540 CFM is desirable. Unfortunately, this hood has a 600 CFM blower. Because blowers are rated in open air, and the baffles and other parts of the ventilation system (including MUA) cause pressure losses, it likely won't actually pull more than 400-ish CFM through this hood. So you might be a little under served. An 800 CFM blower would be better. (I wouldn't be surprised if within the myriad Best offerings there was a more powerful hood of this size, with or without the auto feature.) Mesh filters (if kept religiously clean) likely collect grease better than baffles at lower air flows (from the air that gets by them) but these lower flow rates may not be sufficient to keep the rising cooking plumes from partially reflecting from the metal surfaces and escaping out of the hood. This depends on what you cook, as it is a function of rising effluent velocity, which is related to pan surface temperature plus, where applicable, gas flame heat content. For more background, review the many hood threads on this forum. kas
...See More
aprince
14 years ago
Wow. flex duct for ventilation is a BIG no no. I like Dividro's idea about supporting your I-Beam so you can cut through it.
Broan has an RMPE7004 Power Pack. Liner to match would be RML7030S and then you select an external or in-line blower. 600CFM would be best.

For easy installation Broan also has a hood, E6430SS that a loval cabinet maker loves to use as a built in unit.

Another model would be the Best CP35I309SB. This is a built in but includes the pack, liner, and blower.

These are all under $1000 and would woork fine.

Replace the duct though!!

Please educate me on range hoods!

Comments (3)

guadalupe

davidro1

Related Discussions

aprince

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US