House finch taking over

14 years ago

How do I prevent house finch from taking over. I feed only BOSS. I have 5 feeders, from tube, to hopper, no no feeder which is like mesh clinger, clinger only feeder and covered squirrel proof droll Yankees.

I have a variety of birds in a large open area about an acre bordered by mature trees. The hf come in droves and allow very few other species to feed.

Thanks

Featured Answer

lindaaholt

6 years ago

Sounds like my yard. Today is day four of not filling my squirrel proof perch feeder I have a screened Nyjer feeder only. I also took down a nest in my soffit but there are still many crooks and crannies in my 1945 clapboard cottage. Don’t know what else to do. They even try to guard the birdbaths. I don’t want to harm them just push them to new area. I was starting to get Bluebirds but saw house finch chase it ☹️

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (14)

GoldfinchGuy
14 years ago
I would suggest using whole peanuts and an upside down thistle feeder. House finches wont eat whole peanuts, but birds like woodpeckers, jays, and nuthatches will. You can offer these on a tray or platform feeder, or you can simply scatter some on a table or fencepost. Upside down thistle feeders are designed specially for goldfiches and chickadees because they can feed hanging upside down whereas house finches cant. Just be mindful that thistle seed will cost you a bit more than other seeds.
feather_z9_ncacoast
14 years ago
what's wrong with feeding house finches? Why not set up a feeder just for the finches and use other feeders designed for a variety of birds as suggested above? Now House *Sparrows* I would understand, but why not house finches?
Related Discussions
Will slime molds multiply and take over my house?
Q
Comments (12)
That doesn't look like anything I've ever seen in a pot or on the ground before, like more slimy than slime mold. Is there any possibility it came out of the watering can, like something fell in there? Pic enlarges to great, huge size, but unfortunately that part is not in focus. I can't picture how this went at all: "I started to water this small snake plant and a glob of goo popped up to the surface." But I am curious to hear more. I'd have to pull that plant out of the pot and see what's going on, curiosity would demand it. Do you want to do that? Take pics? Can you add a pic of the stuff in the peace lily pot too? If it really did come up from inside, I'm thinking it was already still quite moist in the pot. Sans that aren't baking in the heat/sun outside really need to dry out between drinks of water. It looks like the pot is sitting in a larger bowl or bucket. If water stays at the bottom of that, the roots of the Sans could rot. I would water at a sink so excess water has dripped away, then set on something that protects furniture (and/or sanity) if needed.
...See More
Will a Father House Finch feed nestlings?
Q
Comments (3)
Rachell, Thanks for your comforting words. I was SO worried! This morning, two were on the edge of the container they are nested in, preening, and trying out their wings ... just 'flpping' to see how they worked! Soon, the mom and dad flew in together and fed them. The biggest one is ready to go. The other two, a bit littler. I quietly shut the 'peek space in my door', came in ... raised my fist in the air .. and said "Yeeeesssssssss!" I love these little buggers SO much! ....The WONDER of it all! ;) PS: What was really funny, as I watched these little babies stretching, and preening, and checking their flying gear ... Dr. Wayne Dyer was on Public TV (in the background) ... talking about 'Don't think you can't do it!" (chuckle!)
...See More
finches vs. hummers ..
Q
Comments (2)
I haven't seen house finches try to use hummer feeders here. I use to have that problem too Rachel concerning the thisle feeders. I'd fill them up waiting for the goldfinches to find them. When they would I'd get to enjoy them for a few days until the house finches would take over. I got sick of that so I bough some of those upside down thisle feeders. They work great, the goldfinches have no problems using them. I also get indigo buntings, pine siskins, and carolina chickadees. But not a single house finch. I don't think they can hang upside down.
...See More
Do house finches flock with house sparrows?
Q
Comments (6)
Do not be too quick to dismiss the lowly sparrow. I grew up on a dairy farm in N.E.Ohio and I have always had a passing interest in bird watching, however like most people I erroneously thought a sparrow is a sparrow, is a sparrow and lumped them into one of two broad categories, song sparrows and house sparrows, all of which were often considered at best a minor nuisance. Last June I officially retired and took up nature photography as a retirement hobby. Over the summer I spent most of my time hiking the woods, meadows and swampy areas, but when the summer birds migrated last fall I then set up feeders and turned my attention to the birds that i could attract. I typically set my camera on a tripod zeroed in on a feeder or a ground feeding location, then I sit motionless with a remote shutter release in my pocket and snap pictures of the birds as they come in. In the course of taking 2 or 300 pictures a day, it goes without saying that I get a lot of shots that contain sparrows as well as the more desirable birds. Later while editing the photos I began to notice that many of the sparrows had what i thought were strange or unusual markings. In early October my Mother presented me with a book called "Birds of Ohio" by McCormac & Kennedy, published by the Lone Pine Press (ISBN 13:978-1-55105-392-9)). From this book I discovered that their are over twenty different species of Sparrows common to Ohio, two of which have red heads such as you describe. I then got another book called "The Sparrows of the united States and Canada published by Princeton University Press (ISBN 13:978-0-125-9897-1) in which they list over 62 species of Sparrows native to the U.S. & Canada. In addition, i learned that the House Sparrow is not native to North America and is officially not listed as a Sparrow, but rather they are listed as "Old World Sparrows" which includes another 37 species that have been introduced to North America, primarily from Europe. From my personal experience I would challenge everyone, rather than seek ways to discourage the lowly Sparrow, take a closer look and you might be amazed at what you see, and if the Sparrows are consuming all the seed in your feeders, do as I have done, put up more feeders because all of God's creatures gotta eat. Currently I am going through 5 30lb bags of wild bird seed a month, not to mention another two bushels of corn that i put in chicken feeders out in the meadow for the wild turkeys but then when i consider how many hours I spend watching those birds, it is really rather cheap entertainment.
...See More
creekgirl
10 years ago
House Finches are a non-native, invasive species outside of the US southwest. Having been foolishly introduced to the northeast, they have since spread nationwide, displacing native finches and sparrows:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/House_finch

They mob my feeder and take up all the perches. Not only are they messy eaters, they plant themselves and sit there taking up space whether eating or not. Polite native birds that fly in to take a seed and fly off, like Chickadees and Titmice, don't have a chance, until/unless a Red-Bellied Woodpecker lands and scares the House Finch mob away. These gluttonous, noisy and impolite House Finches are costing me a fortune in bird seed, moreover they spread conjunctivitis.

I read that a screen feeder helps with the House Finch problem, as they are supposedly perching birds that won't cling to the side of a screen. I bought a tubular screen birdfeeder of a size to hold my usual black sunflower seeds. Hope it helps.
Pat Z5or6 SEMich
5 years ago
This news about House Finches is incredible. I thought I knew a lot about my feeder birds but I truly forgot that HFs are so menacing. Sure is good to go through these older posts to learn new things. I had so many HFs this summer and it never occured to me they were the reason I had not much else. Thank you so much, hokle and other commenter above.
Pat Z5or6 SEMich
5 years ago
Do you now if House Finches like SAFflower seed?
lindaaholt
5 years ago
I think they like everything
Pat Z5or6 SEMich
5 years ago
I want to bump this post up. Has anyone come up with a successful way to discourage House Finches? hokle? creek? linda? Did the screen-only tube work?
Pat Z5or6 SEMich
5 years ago
Bump
HU-918750892
5 years ago
I just tied safflower. They can crack them open easily, which surprised me. I used to use it to get rid of grackles in GA because grackles can't eat it. I think the house finches were laughing at me. Sigh.
Pat Z5or6 SEMich
5 years ago
me too.
HU-325872446
2 years ago
I’m reareally shockshocked at this post. Love my house finch! they they’re very friendly have a beautiful song, but most importantly they will keep house sparrows in check.
HU-412229094
2 years ago
4 weeks ago I was getting a good variety of birds to my platform feeder and I though the Carolina wren was pesty then the house finches showed up. Cardinals can chase them off when they’re feeding but nuthatches, blackcapped chickades, titmouse, blubirds, really have a problem with these aggressive feeders.
HU-633607594
last year
last modified: last year
House finches suck. If you don't think so fine but obviously lots of other people think so and that's the point here. If you love HF's don't waste space on this string by trying to convince others to change their mind!

House finch taking over

lindaaholt

Comments (14)

GoldfinchGuy

feather_z9_ncacoast

Related Discussions

creekgirl

Pat Z5or6 SEMich

Pat Z5or6 SEMich

lindaaholt

Pat Z5or6 SEMich

Pat Z5or6 SEMich

HU-918750892

Pat Z5or6 SEMich

HU-325872446

HU-412229094

HU-633607594

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US