Older leaves yellowing and drying. Fungus or over-watering?

9 years ago

I have some heirloom beefsteak tomato plants that I grew from seeds planted in mid-February. I started them out indoors in a 6 pack, and then 6-inch pots. Now 3 of them are in a "city pickers grow box" which is about 2ft by 1.5ft with a bottom-self-watering and wicking system. They are in Miracle Gro potting mix and have been fertilized with a few tablespoons of organic 5-6-4 (or something) fertilizer. I did top up the box with an inch of Miracle Gro garden soil, but I don't think that should be an issue.

Also another one of these is in a tomato grow bag, also with a bottom-self-watering system.

I've been finding that ever since the 6-inch pot phase, on to today, the older/lower leaves of the plants turn yellow and brown and develop some spots. I've looked at pictures of blights and septoria and I can't say with any certainty that my plants match the pictures. I could also just be over-watering and should perhaps let the soil dry out a bit between waterings? I don't water from the top, only fill the reservoir and let the wicking happen on its own.

The tops of the plants all look green and lush.

I've gone ahead and trimmed off the ugly looking bits, but I've not tried much to remedy the issue. I haven't used any fungicide yet.

I have a second grow box with a newer set of the same variety (seeds planted March 25). These seem to be doing okay, but I'm seeing hints of the yellowing on the first real leaves while the second set of leaves look good.

I'm in the SF Bay Area, so the air is moist and the temperature is generally between 50-70 degrees. The plants get about 8 hours of direct sun a day.

gallery: http://imgur.com/a/HKDgI

Here is a link that might be useful: Gallery of yellowing and such

This post was edited by nss213 on Tue, May 13, 14 at 2:52

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (5)

digdirt2
9 years ago
First, MG Garden Soil in any container is a problem. It says right on the bag "not for use in containers". It compacts and retains too much water.

Second, yellowing of leaves alone - any leaves - is not a fungus infection indicator and I don't see any signs of anything else fungus-wise in the photo.

But it is a very good indicator of over-watering and insufficient nutrient problems.

Container plants require regular feedings - weekly - and organic fertilizers, unless they are liquids suspended in water, don't work in containers since there is no active soil food web there to convert them to a form useable by the plants.

Trying to grow in containers using only organics requires a very different approach than organic gardening in the ground.

Your plants need less water and more nutrients.

Dave
2ajsmama
9 years ago
I don't know if the top inch or so of soil is causing a problem if the rest is potting mix, but did I understand correctly that you have 3 plants in a 1.5ft x 2ft (by how deep?) container? That will be a problem as they grow, even if it's not now. How is the one (?) in the grow bag?

Looks like overwatering and underfertilizing to me.
Related Discussions
Yellow leaves on older fig tree
Q
Comments (1)
With out seeing the fig, I'd have to guess that the tree is showing stress from lack of moisture. I'd try deep watering the tree a couple of times a week and see if that helps.
...See More
Drowning tomato? Fungus? Yellowing leaves.. help!
Q
Comments (2)
They'll survive, Julia... they'll probably suffer a bit more damage, but you'll still have plants next weekend. It looks like a classic case of Early Blight to me, which is a very common fungus (Alternaria). I don't know whether it came as an airborne spore or splashed up from the soil in the pots, but now it can spread from leaf to leaf by rain splashing on them. If you can protect them from overhead water by putting them under cover, it may help a bit. What else should you do? First, pick off all of the spotty leaves you can find, or slice off the portions that have spots if that seems too drastic to you. That'll slow it down. Mulching might be good, in case it came from the soil in the pots. Between those measures and possible protection from the rain, they shouldn't take too much more damage before you can get to them. Daconil is the old name for Ortho Garden Disease Control, a fungicide. As the "Ortho" part suggests, it is not organic... but it has very, very little toxicity for people and animals, and the only concern I know of is with aquatic invertebrates. Chlorothalonil, the active ingredient, is much less toxic than many things we use every day. If you're strict organic, you'll have to do without, and try to find some organic fungicide -- I think Gardens Alive has one, but it's nowhere near as effective as daconil. If you're a low-impact, sustainable gardener, chlorothalonil is pretty much harmless and fits in with the "no harm" gardening style some of us have. So you should decide which school you're following, and choose a fungicide accordingly. The catch is that no fungicide is going to work if it immediately gets washed off by rain. So you'd need to wait for a break anyway, should it come before you all get washed away. :) Good luck. --Alison
...See More
Cactus has yellow fungus-looking spots and the base is drying out
Q
Comments (1)
Being woody at the base is normal, its a process called corking. Those scabs though, arent. Could be fungal, but im not sure. Overwatering and sunburn may be a cause, or the cause of fungi. Initially though it was scale from your description, but it could not* be scale. If it turned black, im guessing its either rotted (water, damage, frost etc). The cacti you own, myrtillocactus , are among the more durable ones in all aspects except cold hardiness. I dont know exactly where you live, but people tend to misjudge their zone, or their precipitation. It is also entire possible to be damaged by birds or other animals, but ive not seen damage myself, on this plant or a similar one to compare...
...See More
Older leaves yellowing
Q
Comments (2)
I'm pretty sure Callirhoe triangulata just has long leaf stalks... I don't think it's because of lack of light. I have it growing about 6" below an Agrobrite 4-bulb T5 fixture. "Leaves are egg-shaped to triangular in outline, straight across to heart-shaped at the base, 2 to 6 inches long, 1 to 4 inches wide, on stalks up to 12 inches long." Overwatering, maybe. I make sure the soil is dry and the container feels light. It only gets watered about once a week. The original soil I used to sow the seeds was reused potting soil I had outside, so I imagine it already had some algae in it. I didn't even think the seeds would germinate, so I just stuck them in whatever. I'll be more conscientious when watering. I don't see the speckling that you mention. I've seen spider mite damage on outdoor plants, but the speckling was pretty obvious. I can take a closer look when I get home. For what it's worth, I also have a few micro dwarf tomato plants growing right next to this one, and they seem to be doing fine. Under side of a leaf: Neighboring micro dwarf tomato, in case there's an issue I'm overlooking
...See More
nss213
Original Author
9 years ago
@digdirt would you please take a look at the gallery i posted with other images? http://imgur.com/a/HKDgI

The yellowing alone isn't concerning me so much as the spotting (perhaps I should've posted one of the other pictures)

The plants will probably outgrow the growbox, but this just my first attempt to see if I can even keep something alive. (also the growbox instructions said to plant 2-3 tomatoes... but perhaps it was intended for a smaller variety)

Here's a picture of one of the younger plants still in the 6-inch pot.

Here is a link that might be useful: Gallery of my tomatoes
digdirt2
9 years ago
nss213 - Spots develop on the older tomato leaves for all sorts of reasons, some bad, but are most no problem other than to indicate tissue death due to stress.

But it is the over-all health of the plant that should be the focus so that it can resist disease and pest problems. And with your plants the severe yellowing should be the primary concern as it indicates a more serious problem than the spots I see in your photos.

While it is possible that some of the spots in your photos could be signs of Early Blight it is not possible to say for sure from any of the photos. Removing the affected foliage and spraying them with a fungicide sure wouldn't hurt them, but it is the nutrient ad water issues that really need to be addressed.

They are growing in a somewhat stressed situation already from the over-crowding and the appearance of the soil condition in your pics so providing them with sufficient nutrients in a form the can use will go a long way to improving their situation.

When one is new to growing tomatoes and a problem develops the inclination is always to jump to the conclusion that it is a disease. But 8 out of 10 times the problem is actually related to the growing conditions rather than any disease issue. When the growing conditions are less than ideal to begin with then those odds go up even more.

Hope this helps.

Dave
nss213
Original Author
9 years ago
Thanks!
Can you elaborate a bit about the appearance of the soil condition in the pics? What looks wrong with the soil?

Older leaves yellowing and drying. Fungus or over-watering?

Comments (5)

digdirt2

2ajsmama

Related Discussions

nss213
Original Author

digdirt2

nss213
Original Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Older leaves yellowing and drying. Fungus or over-watering?

Comments (5)

digdirt2

2ajsmama

Related Discussions

nss213Original Author

digdirt2

nss213Original Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

nss213
Original Author

nss213
Original Author