Just discovered newbie mistake- can I fix it?

11 years ago

Three years ago I built my first raised bed with help from all the advice I got here. I dutifully bought and screwed together cedar boards, rounded up the ingredients for Mel's mix, and began to plant and enjoy my garden bed.

The bed has always been extremely quick draining and I was surprised at how quickly it would get dry even after long, soaking rains. I chalked it up to the fact that I plopped the bed on top of a pre-existing sand patch that the former homeowners had put down for a swingset.

Well today I figured it out. It is not the sand below the bed. It is my stupidity. I just finished building my second bed. While at the landscaping place, the guy told me "one thing with peat- make sure you wet it REALLY well before you mix it up with the other stuff." I thought about it and did not remember getting this advice or doing this step with the first beds. I asked the guy what can happen if you don't wet the peat before mixing. He told me, "oh, well if you mix it in dry, the particles of peat in there basically repel water, FOREVER."

Hmmmmm. My "quick draining" bed is starting to make a lot more sense now.

Here's my question: is this fixable? My bed has settled some, so there's room to amend. It's a 14' x 4' bed and I'd say there's like an inch or two of space to the top of the boards I could play with. Trouble is, that bed is for all my early crops. So it's full of lettuce, peas, radishes, swiss chard, kale, and spinach.

I had some leftover wetted peat from the project I just did with the new bed. I used some of that to top dress between the rows of little seedling plants. Do you think that will help? Essentially I feel like it's like I just put a little sponge down between all the rows, to hopefully help the mix retain more water. But I'm worried it will just be at the surface and not do any good.

Help or advice on how I might fix the situation would be appreciated! Feeling like a big dummy!

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (5)

keski
11 years ago
In my experience, it takes a winter to get the peat moss wet. I've had to use it dry in the mix, and it eventually does get wet. It is best if you can wet it first but then it is so heavy, it's difficult to handle. I do remember that my first year, the beds were drier. It does not stay dry forever.
Keski
agmss15
11 years ago
Well your guy gave you sort of good advice. Peat is water repellent when dry - it has a high surface tension. It is a really good idea to moisten peat before mixing it with other amendments. And when it dries down it can be a huge PIA to get it moist again - it makes a water repellent crust. BUT there is NO way that your peat mix from three years ago is repelling water because you mixed it wrong - unless it hasn't rained in 3 years.

It sounds like you have a very light mix in your raised beds. I wouldn't really put a new layer of peat on top - that too will be water repellent when it dries. If you have compost/composted manure I would mix some into your bed every year before planting. Maybe some top soil too. Since you already have some crops in your garden - top dress wherever you can and scratch it in well. You can mulch with chopped up leaves and/or grass clipping too.

There are also products like 'soil moist' that help your soil hold moisture. Use very lightly - when I first used it I had some amusing volcanos of gelatin globs. I would only use SM where the soil is always very dry.
Related Discussions
What Can I do to Fix this Container plant mistake?
Q
Comments (8)
If the mix is 3-4 years old, there probably are no nutrients left in it. If all you did was yank the tree, and didn't empty the container & refill, there probably is a soil compaction problem too, and perhaps the roots aren't getting any oxygen. This can be quite possible, especially since you think you get enough water. A container plant can almost never be overwatered if the soilmix is good. You should be able to see the water coming out the bottom. I grow more than half my tomatoes & peppers in 4 & 5 gallon buckets, and the years I don't remove/ammend/refill my containers, plant growth and production SUFFER GREATLY. Ands I water 2x a day if it didn't rain, more than 2L each time. You need to ammend the soilmix yearly, at least with compost or aged manure. I remix my containers with 30-50% compost. Also, because of frequent waterings, you need to fertilize regularly. Hope this helps.
...See More
How long before you discovered your first major mistake?
Q
Comments (35)
Hi all, Oh, the mistakes! We've never built a house before but had a pretty good idea of what we wanted. Like many here, I want to say, if there's a mistake going in, STOP IT before it multiplies! I came up to our house site one day and they were starting with the window trim. They had done two, and they were mitering the corners instead of doing square corners with a little overhang. I thought, "well, they've already started..." I really dislike them. I can live with it, considering, but they irk me every time I see them. Mistake two was my fault: granite tile on the bathroom counters. I really like granite tile, but even though this looked great with my cabinet and tile samples in the showroom, I absolutely HATE the way it looks in the bathroom (could be because I--and everybody else) LOVE my ceramic tile on the floor and in the shower. This granite is coming out and DH is going to tile (his first job) the counter with the ceramic. I AVOIDED mistake number three, getting the wrong kitchen counters! I was SOOOOO lucky I couldn't find the Uba Tuba color I wanted, then I couldn't find a Tropical Green in the right size...what I really wanted all along was soapstone. Thanks to this forum I am assured it is the right choice. Even though we'll have to travel quite a distance to get it and DH will have to fabricate it himself (and we'll have to find strong friends to help), we'll actually SAVE money 'cause we'll do it ourselves. I'm not sure he's too happy about it, but I think he'll go along if I do all the legwork. - Magpie
...See More
How do I fix my mistake?!
Q
Comments (14)
I get it, you wanted a more crisp bright feel. One option is to make KD take the cabinets back and replace them with what you really wanted, and proceed with your original plan. Otherwise, it is fixable. The colors are relative to each other. There is no pure white. The cabinets only look dingy to your eye because they are next to the white trim, which is a white whiter than they are (and next to the stark awful drywall compound, as Val said). If you put an even creamier white next to the cabinets, THEY might very well look very white and crisp in comparison. So, assuming that you did make a mistake and the trim is too bright and is making them look dirty (which may be the case), you will need to re-paint the trim, and select a different blue for the wall. I do think the blue is too pastel now for the cabinets, it needs to be brought down some. How does the granite and backsplash go? Don't you worry, it is going to look beautiful. When we were having ours re-done and custom painted, I spent a whole afternoon crying because the color they promised was not the color that went on. But when it was over, it was just beautiful, and it all ended up very well. That will happen with your kitchen too, fear not.
...See More
Drywall "mistakes"... demand a do-over, or just fix with mud?
Q
Comments (8)
fair enough. I wasn't "inspecting" anything though. I came in to measure something and saw it on my way in. remember, my reaction was to have a chuckle and then ask in a forum. it isn't like I berated the guy and demand he start over. :)
...See More
bananastand
Original Author
11 years ago
OK, this is good to hear- I suspected as much, that over the winters and many rains it would have to EVENTUALLY absorb water. I did top dress the whole thing in wetted peat, and I can add more compost at the end of the season. Any other ideas or perspectives still welcome.
mandolls
11 years ago
The wetted peat that you added on top will dry out (its in the sun) and form a crust. Buy some compost now if you arent making any and just lay that on top of the peat. It will keep the peat from drying out.

I tried using peat as a top mulch one year and it made it very difficult to get any water to the plants in the beds. On the other hand it sure kept the weeds from coming through - it was like a layer of concrete.
bananastand
Original Author
11 years ago
AHHHH, you are right! It's all hard now. SHOOT I am still a newbie, it seems!! Hopefully I can wet it again, then cover in compost. I work all weekend though so I hope it doesn't dry out completely. Sigh.

Just discovered newbie mistake- can I fix it?

Comments (5)

keski

agmss15

Related Discussions

bananastand
Original Author

mandolls

bananastand
Original Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Just discovered newbie mistake- can I fix it?

Comments (5)

keski

agmss15

Related Discussions

bananastandOriginal Author

mandolls

bananastandOriginal Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

bananastand
Original Author

bananastand
Original Author