Thank you I had not thought of that one as these hips were very large compared to the red (pink) Rugosa I have seen. If it is I guess I need to find a white rugosa as it was very nice looking shrub and had a lot of hips on it so must have had a good bloom.

Here is another shot of it.

You are posting in the tropical fruit forum so you may not get much help here. From the picture you posted it is a: Pereskia grandifolia Common Name(s): Rose Cactus Synonym(s): Cactus grandifolius, Rhodocactus grandifolius, Pereskia tampicana, Rhodocactus tampicanus http://cactiguide.com/cactus/?genus=Pereskia&species=grandifolia http://cactiguide.com/graphics/p_grandifolia_a_600.jpg

Oh good, larger pictures. Yellow Lady Banks puts on a floriferous spring display here and has no thorns. Grows beyond 10ft (here z9 CA). Very little fade. Ditto for the white version. I've not seen Rosa canina 'Creme' in person but sure does look the ones at this link. http://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.18046.3&tab=36