SHOP PRODUCTS
Houzz Logo Print
kokomo_jb

Question: How the Sabal Palmettos are doing in VA,NC and SC?

Kokomo-JB
10 years ago

Given how bad this winter has been on the East Coast I would say that VA, NC and SC are experiencing a "normal average" winter that we usually have up in the NY Metro area. That said, I always wanted to bring up Sabal Palmettos to our area and the winter they are currently going through in VA, Nc and SC would be a good indication of what they can take. If you are from those states, I'd love to hear from you. Thanks!

Comments (100)

  • Beach_bums
    10 years ago

    I walked down there the day of the fire, the damage was confined to pretty much to the game room. Of course the fire department probably caused more damage than the fire but that's a necessary evil. Jungle Golf is still open, but the inside area is closed. Thanks for the current picture of the sabal. The trunk tells the whole story. Looks like it struggled for a few years before it took off. Makes sense because we had some bad winters back then.

  • Plant1truth_teller
    10 years ago

    Lago Mar, that palmetto in Sandbridge is great. I see a lot around here that look like that. They do just fine. Another place to find great looking palmettos is at Capn George's Seafood on Laskin Rd. Drove by tonight and saw lots of excellent healthy palmettos with full heads (and NO plastic).

  • Related Discussions

    What causes Sabal Palmetto to wilt after planting?

    Q

    Comments (12)
    Thank you for your advise. I do have a copper fungicide, but the palms are 19 ft. tall and my ladder and me will not reach them. If I climb with a tall ladder there is a chance that the palm tree will fall. I contacted the nursery yesterday and today and am waiting for their answer. They say they got decades of experience with palms yet they told me to not water them and they did not tell me these are problem palms nor how to treat them. Being unable to reach to inspect the bud (the nursery dd not respond yet whether they will come to inspect them) my only option is to get a refund and let them have these two palms back at their disposal or get them replace them with other palms. I was also suggested by a professor in Florida to not plant Florida palms in SC in spring, but wait until summer. Well, I did not know that and the experienced nursery did not tell me that. The palms cost me about 25% more than could have bought elsewhere. Really not a good deal with this nursery.
    ...See More

    How to cut down dead Sabal

    Q

    Comments (6)
    I am in Upstate SC. I have not seen a Sabal Birmingham. I will look into it. I planted a Windmill in the Sabal Palmettos place. As far as cutting the Sabal,the palm definately had crown rot. We hooked up a chain to the palm and to our tractor. It pulled out with little effort as it had not grown any new roots since it had been planted. We cut the tree into sections and it smelled horrible like fermentation. It also had black sections like rot. I am really bummed about losing it as it was about 16 feet tall and cost quite a bit. We splurged to buy it. LSST
    ...See More

    Help finding container grown Sabal Palmettos

    Q

    Comments (21)
    "perhaps there are many millions still in the wild?" Id say thats a safe bet! They are EVERYWHERE down here....growing in sidewalk cracks, against telephone poles, etc, etc. One can buy any size Sabal they want for around a hundred bucks. The catch (for the average homeowner) is that the installation costs are alot more than the palm. I planted a couple of harvested Sabals at the end of my driveway (about 15 ft of trunk each) and, due to the weight of these palms, after I rented the Bobcat and trailer, it cost about $600 total for both palms, plus my own labor. (The palms were about $200 for both). In retrosect, I should have had a landscaper do the job, as most of them just charge $250 a palm installed :-) Also, unless they have about 3-4 ft of trunk, they do not transplant well. I learned this the hard way with three Sabal yapas.
    ...See More

    Good Source of Sabal Palmetto

    Q

    Comments (32)
    Thanks Jim! Have you seen any of the palms in the area? How close to the Atlantic are you? I have Butia bonnetti (in pic) and Butia eriospatha. Eriospatha has done really well: much better than the bonnetti. The Sabal minor has doubled in size since last year. Not many leaves come out but each one is much bigger than the last. I've purchased palms from Gary's Nursey, Chilly Palm, Triple Oaks, Bethany Beach Gardens (I think thats the name of the nursey), and three different sellers on Ebay. The nursery in Bethany had huge Trachycarpus fortunei and Butia capitata along with Sabal minor, Rhapidophyllum hystrix, and Chamaerops humilus. Here are two more pictures of a few more palms including eriospatha:
    ...See More
  • LagoMar
    10 years ago

    Oh yes, Captain Georges is outstanding! Someday the city should ask the folks who did Captain Georges and Hiltop Plaza to line Atlantic Ave for them.

  • Beach_bums
    10 years ago

    In my dreams, the city replaces all the bradford pears east of Great Neck with sabals.

  • islandbreeze
    10 years ago

    Might not be a bad idea to replace more trees with sabals in VB, or at least with trachycarpus. I'm sure the palms in VB help with bringing more vacationers and tourists to the area. In the summer, it's like Florida but closer to home.

    BTW, nobody mentioned the needle palms in VB. The first mature needle I saw was at a put-put golf course in VB. Probably the only reason I still try to grow them. They are really nice looking palms when mature even though they don't trunk.

  • tropicalzone7
    10 years ago

    I agree, I think replacing a lot of the overused and underqualified trees (like Bradford pears) with palms like Sabals and Trachys would be great for the city! VB relies a lot on tourism and tourist love palms. Plus Sabals and Trachys are a lot less likely to cause problems during storms than bradford pears which are guaranteed to lose branches even during minor wind events.

    And I agree islandbreeze. Needle palms in general don't get the respect they deserve. They are beautiful palms and extremely cold hardy!

    -Alex

  • chadec
    10 years ago

    You should have more than just sabals looking good in Va. Our pindos look good as far in as Rockingham, far from a coastal town. Raleigh area pindos are burned, mature sabal at PDN looked good as did all minors and trachies. Coastal towns saw damage to dates, washies and sagos.

    This phoenix is at an abandoned building, which is why none of the palms have been pruned yet. The only one I was able to photogragh, all others are just stumps.

    Trachy on the left is the Trachy 'Takil' taken last Sat. at PDN.

    If your sabals don't look like these then maybe you should drive to that place in Newbern and get you some real palm trees instead of telephone poles.

    Chad,

  • dixieboy
    10 years ago

    Oh come on now Chad, surely your not say'in those Myrtle Beach sabals look as good as these sabals in SE Virginia.
    {{gwi:1115489}}

  • LagoMar
    10 years ago

    Shame on you, Dr. Cornelius! You know better than that! You should leave that pettiness over on the other board where they are used to that kind of thing.

  • dixieboy
    10 years ago

    The photo taker said there use to be butia planted there but when they died windmills replaced them, shame VB, shame, you need to stick to bradford pears!!!!
    {{gwi:1115490}}

  • LagoMar
    10 years ago

    Those Windmills in that last pic are not doing well either. Virtually zero watering and being grown in raised concrete beds like that (that isn't the ground they are in and it is facing away from the prevailing winds under an overhang for pedestrians) will kill any plant they try out there. They are welcome to try Bradford Pears since I could care less if Bradfords die. The fact of the matter is, its the Hilton, they have money to burn. Those are annuals in those pots. Bradford Pears are quite prolific in VB and only suffer during high winds. I guess that is a problem? Oh well, as long as Palmettos grow great here I'm cool with it.

  • dixieboy
    10 years ago

    Breath tak'in sabal beauties in VB, reminds me of Myrtle Beach, NOT!!!!!
    {{gwi:1115491}}

  • chadec
    10 years ago

    I wish the sabals in my yard looked half that good. After 1F 6 weeks ago there is barely in any green left in the spears. Pindos look worse even with a frost cloth and Christmas lights this yr was too much. My sabal Birminghams are the only palms that have not shown any damage. Louisianas have some tip burn and Brazoria is a let down. All non hybrid minors are bullet proof of course.


    During winter the fronds were tied up. Box opened because of outside temps.

    Carl, I remember buying that palm as a minor. You telling me it was a sabal long before it ever started forming a trunk. Good call!

  • williamr
    10 years ago

    Oceana NAS is in VA Beach (rather than Norfolk) and did get to 1F, so despite the conflicting reports, it doesn't surprise me to see photos of many Sabal palmettos looking rough at best. I am glad to read that the seed grown ones are mostly doing well. Even the hurricane cut planted ones here tend to look skinny and haggard for years, if not permanently. A significant percentage of these die here after planting, too.

    Bradford pears (temperate trees) should be suitable to the climate of VA Beach, even if not the most interesting or elegant landscaping choice. Kind of like silver maples in the Midwest. We even have a few that I know of here in northern Orlando. These few do okay, but never bloom due to lack of winter chill. One near me did actually have some flowers after the extended chilly winter of '09-'10.

  • dixieboy
    10 years ago

    Chad, sorry about the latest round y'all went through out there, this winter has been rough stuff for sure. Except for sagos get'in toasted, we are thankful here in our area.

    Williamr, i've found that start'in from seed or small containers is the best bet, in my case the cold hardies do great.

  • Plant1truth_teller
    10 years ago

    Dixieboy, get a life.

  • Plant1truth_teller
    10 years ago

    As a mater of fact, Dixieboy, I live in eastern NC, not tellin where, an know quite well your area. Not 5 minutes away from you inland palmettos often look skimpy and thin -lots of new ones and even ol' ones- so you and your easten NC area are not immune from bad lookin palms. Why you pick on Va Beach? They grow some beautiful palmettos. Who also fills me in is that fella in New Bern who confides in me that your little area is but a tiny are of decent palm growin, but inland just a few things start to take a rough turn.. He tells me you might be stretchin the truth a spell.

  • Plant1truth_teller
    10 years ago

    And this is what I found last spring in the Va Beach area for palmettos. Most palms in the area looked like this, even norfolk.:

  • Plant1truth_teller
    10 years ago

    And here's another from Norfolks botanical gardens someone sent me:

  • Plant1truth_teller
    10 years ago

    and another from a fella I found in norfolk from that botenical gardens: Why you make fun of Se Va palmettos??

  • williamr
    10 years ago

    In reference to your pic of the palmettos planted around the sunny street corner, most of the Sabal palmettos in the northern Panhandle of FL do not look that good. I used to travel to Southern AL frequently and would take the Defuniak Springs exit. The Sabal palmetto there looked skinny and sparse and definitely like they were not growing in conditions that are ideal year round. I suspect that this is at least partially related to the hurricane cut issue too. Still, many of the Sabal palmetto you see from Lake city north in FL just do not look like the ones further south.

    The native range of Sabal palmetto does not include most of the FL Panhandle. Hard to believe that Bald head Island, NC is part of this species native range, yet Tallahassee, FL is not. This is interesting since average temps for extreme SE North Carolina are lower than those of Tallahassee, and all time record lows are similar.

  • LagoMar
    10 years ago

    Thank you for sharing those pictures, truth teller. I will have to follow up on that store that looked so beautiful. Hopefully they didn't hurricane cut and wrap. By the looks of your picture they haven't been in the habit of doing that there.

  • dixieboy
    10 years ago

    Williamr, a illustration of Bald Head island NC in pic #1 & then there's pic #2 in SE Virginia.
    {{gwi:1115497}}
    {{gwi:1115499}}

  • williamr
    10 years ago

    I don't know how anyone possibly thinks that plastic wrap will help at all. It can do the opposite actually, and as far as I know, it provides no off-setting benefit.

  • Plant1truth_teller
    10 years ago

    Dixieboy, I see the plastic wrap but I have to say that from Carolinas to Se Va the only places I seen plastic wrap is on the Va beach beachfront, no where else -really jest along the street along the beach. As you go in a few blocks you see no plastic. Im amazed sometimes what palmettos I see growin in SE va.

  • dixieboy
    10 years ago

    More of the same away from the beach, 'prince' charming!
    {{gwi:1115501}}

  • chadec
    10 years ago

    OMG, anything but plastic. They are trying to kill the palms. Has nothing to with the sabals or location. Mummy wrap just does not work. Kevin can't remember his screen name had his windmill for 20 yrs in zone 4. Till last yr he switch to mummy wrapping. And guess what, it didn't make it.

  • JohnnieB
    10 years ago

    Interesting that "plant1 truth teller" joined this discussion (and Gardenweb!) immediately after I posted a link to this discussion on the Hardy Palm & Subtropical discussion board, and sounds suspiciously like a fellow from Norfolk who quit that board not long before that. Oddly enough, first he claims to be from SE Virginia, then from NC and now even his grammar and spelling have changed so not sure just how much truth this guy is telling or who he's trying to fool...

  • JohnnieB
    10 years ago

    So can anybody post any RECENT photos of any of these palms, showing what they look like AFTER this winter?

  • dixieboy
    10 years ago

    John, i posted this older VB pic on the other board with the question of if these SP's had the ability to fill back out as they do farther south, a resident of the area said he would go there to take a pic of the same angle there, i strongly suspect that he did & didn't care for what he saw.
    PS i knew who 'plain truth' was from the first letter he typed!!
    {{gwi:1115503}}

  • LagoMar
    10 years ago

    Hey Dixie, thank you for your sincere concern about palms in your pictures. I have been posting pictures of gorgeous palms in VB all over the place. I also mentioned that I DID revisit those palms in your pic and indeed they had been hurricane cut and wrapped. Disgusting. Anyway, here is one I took TODAY, just like many others I've posted on both boards.

  • dixieboy
    10 years ago

    Hey, Lago, your palms up that way are beautiful!!
    {{gwi:1115504}}

  • Loveplants2 8b Virginia Beach, Virginia
    10 years ago

    Here is my before..

    This winter right after the 12 inches. Then the freezing cold settled in...
    (Planted 19 years ago...)

    I'll post another pic of the after when I get home for this trip..

    Those pictures from the oceanfront have always had issues.. They can't handle the wind and they keep replacing them so they will never get established. The problem is that it is just to windy..

    Now they have planted alot of Sabals at hilltop last year which look wonderful. I am Happy to see them thrive!! It. Makes the whole shopping center more inviting ..

    Great thread!! I loved seeing all of the trees..

    Mine are in VB near Great Neck...they have been planted for 19 yrs

    Take care,

    Laura

  • Loveplants2 8b Virginia Beach, Virginia
    10 years ago

    Summertime..

    VB

    That is my 23 year old son.. Working!!! ;-). Right

    Laura

  • LagoMar
    10 years ago

    Gorgeous, Laura! What an amazing yard you have! Thank you so much for posting these!

  • yeehova
    10 years ago

    My sabals in NC have some leaf burn and a few fronds broke due to heavy ice accumulation, but all three survived a 4 degree low which seems like a 25 year low for this area.

  • Plant1truth_teller
    10 years ago

    those are great palms Laura. It shows how good palms grow in Va Beach -espesialy those not on the ocean front. I have saw the ocean front palms and they take a beatin. Inland these same palms look 100 time better. I have also seen the new palmetos at Hiltop and they look great. The area in SE Va is thrivin with new palms, espesialy those planted inland away from ocean -where so many people think palms grow best, but wher we all know they do not grow well. The palms I seen also thru Norfolk, Portsmouth Cheasapeke look great, much better than the the ocean front. Inland VA Beach always has great palms too.

  • Loveplants2 8b Virginia Beach, Virginia
    9 years ago

    Hello Everyone....

    Time to report the damage.. ;-(

    Lagomar... Thank you, It's law us nice to hear kind words Nd I appreciate you telling me to hold on with mine. I also grow many plumeria and when you talk about " patience". I have it!! Lol. I have been working with my palms for about 20 years here in my area of VB and I honestly can say that its been the coldest winter I have seen in a long time. I'm a native 757 lady oh has been here a long time!! ;-)

    Truth teller... Thank you. Inland is much better because we have a micro climate verses the constant winds that cause those trees at the oceanfront to have issues. I like to see the " tide" turning around here with the planting of palms here. I just hope it will continue and that they will be well cared for.

    Carl, chad... Always nice to see you!!!

    My Butias were hit hard. My friends down the street that have a palm business graciously cut away the dead fronds from the Butias. I will say that I was doubting their survival with temps down to 5 degrees and windchills in the -15 range. Just to cold for VB zone 8

    I think I lost one.

    The other three in the backyard have potential to make it. One is pushing green fronds and the other two are still holding on. Please forgive the pictures and the way the yard looks. I have a lot of work to do to get it back to the way it should be.

    Ok... Gulp. Here they are.. It's hard to show. but, we all need to see and learn. Jordan... Many thanks to you. Xoxo

  • Loveplants2 8b Virginia Beach, Virginia
    9 years ago

    This is the Butia in the center island

  • Loveplants2 8b Virginia Beach, Virginia
    9 years ago

    Back near the water... I see some green! Yes!!!

  • Loveplants2 8b Virginia Beach, Virginia
    9 years ago

    Sabal having issues.. I'm worried...

  • Loveplants2 8b Virginia Beach, Virginia
    9 years ago

    The last of the Butias in the back... I think they will make it. Patience.. Thank you!

    I just want them to grow and be the best they can be. I'll fertilize and clean the bed and mulch. It's time for a new season.

    Thank you all for this thread..

    Hope you all can finely get out and get some yard work done. It's crazy to start this late for us... But, ill try and not complain!

    Again... Justin, Jordan... You guys are the best. Thank you for trimming my trees. You did a great job. Now I'll get my son to trim the Sabals !!!

    ;-)

    Take care,

    Laura

  • LagoMar
    9 years ago

    So yeah, pretty obvious the majority of pindos in the area were heavily damaged. More and more of the green ones show damage as the heat increases. Still some nice ones down at Oceanfront and neighborhoods within 2 miles of the Atlantic (LagoMar/Sandbridge, Croatan). I haven't been able to check the north end yet. I am guessing that is where you live, Laura? Other than the Pindos, your palms look very nice! A slight tinge of burn on some tips is nothing to worry about. I wonder what is eating your trunk on that one palmetto? I've seen that on a couple of them around, particularly that ancient one at Jungle Golf. Thank you for the update, Laura!

  • Loveplants2 8b Virginia Beach, Virginia
    9 years ago

    Thanks Lago Mar... I live off of Great Neck... Lots of damaged ones around here, it just so sad. I have seen some that have green pushing now.. So if they would clean them up, they would look a lot better.

    I'm not sure of the damage to the big Sabal, but I did have one at our business and I did lose if after a few years. The trunk is peeling away, but it is looking green and lush, so I'm not sure what this is.

    The good news is that all of the tress in the back yard will survive including the questioned Butias.. I just need to trim the Sabals and just be patient with Mother Nature. I did have to get rid of the other Butias in the front yard. It wasn't planted very deep and was the youngest of them all..

    I'm very happy tho.. Thanks for asking.

    I hope you didn't have any losses?

    Take care and have a wonderful holiday weekend!!!

    Laura

  • yeehova
    9 years ago

    Pretty much all of my little one or two year old seedlings that naturally sprouted have survived. Only the ones I planted myself look like the polar vortex hot them.

  • Plant1truth_teller
    9 years ago

    Great palmeto in your yard- Loveplants2. It seems palmetto fared the best in SE Va, far better than meny ever gave credit for.

  • yeehova
    9 years ago

    I just noticed the beginnings of the flower stalks on mine this morning. I'll try to take some pics maybe tomorrow morning when my Palms are in full morning sunlight as they are planted on the southeast side of my house.

  • yeehova
    9 years ago

    I just noticed the beginnings of the flower stalks on mine this morning. I'll try to take some pics maybe tomorrow morning when my Palms are in full morning sunlight as they are planted on the southeast side of my house.

  • islandbreeze
    9 years ago

    Beach_bums- has your washingtonia started recovery or is it dead?