Tree Collards are DYING !

9 years ago

Hi,
I already have tree collards, and they were doing extremely well.
I planted them from cuttings last fall. They did well over the mild winter, without any damage from the one cold spell we had.
I planted them along the side of the house in a raised bed where they get full sun most of the day. Irrigation is via Netafim drip tubing that wraps itself well through the planting area with (0.9 gph @ 12" spacing) emitters running twice a day for 10 minutes a day.
Soil is moist, but not saturated. There is good drainage at the bottom of the bed so there is no standing water there.
They were planted in a mixture of commercially available planting mixes. The planter depth is about 2 1/2 feet deep.

They were about 5 feet tall, when there seemed to be a die back of the lower leaves,
first yellowing, then browning and falling off. The problem progresses upward, killing
off more and more upper leaves.

Downed leaves, extremely dry, have the consistency of rice paper, disintegrating when crushed.

This is the first summer they encountered. Since it's Las Vegas, the temperatures
reach well over 100Ã¯Â¿Â½ daily with night time temperatures in the 80Ã¯Â¿Â½s. Almost no humidity.

Could it be that they were getting too much sun?
I have looked and don't see anywhere how much sun they need.
Could it be just too hot for them to survive?

I am going to salvage a few cuttings to root before whatever is affecting them kills off the entire plant.

My question would be, will they do well in partial shade? I have some areas that are
tree shaded part of the day.

Any help you can offer is greatly appreciated.
Randy

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (6)

aniajs
9 years ago
I've never heard of that plant, but if they are indeed related to cabbage as a quick google suggests, your climate might be too hot for them, especially in full sun. You might try reposting (pictures help to diagnose environmental stress vs. disease) on the vegetable gardening forum (http://forums2.gardenweb.com/forums/cornucop/), which is more active and has a lot of collective experience.
0
Reisod
9 years ago
Hey Randy,

I'm not sure if you explained that your soil was getting watered all the way through, from top to very bottom?

As your plants get bigger, their roots get bigger to obviously, and you should set your watering times much longer.

Normally I have heard to water for about 45 minutes, 2 times a week, so that way it waters completely through, and the roots grow deeper.

If you water just the top soil, then the roots will grow shallow, and then will require you to constantly be watering all of the time, and the growth will not be as effective.

Just my thought, that maybe the plant growing larger is not getting adequate water? Maybe you should change your watering intervals to once per day, but for 30 minutes? If the soil is still wet the next day when it goes to water again, you then would only need to water every other day, or once the soil is dried out. Living in Las Vegas, I know the soil around here drys out pretty quick.

Another thing you might want to check is what nutrients your plant requires. Generally I have heard you want to fertilize once a month, but I think once every 2-3 months is fine. So your soil could be lacking the proper nutrients....

This post was edited by Reisod on Mon, Jun 30, 14 at 18:52
0
Related Discussions
Purple Tree Collards
Q
Comments (1)
Honestly, I never heard of these, but now I'm intrigued. Maybe check with the folks at Urban Farm.
...See More
WANTED: permaculture: tree collards, comfrey#4...
Q
Comments (0)
Looking for cuttings or starts of perennial vegetables, bush fruits, and goat/chicken forage plants grown in the Seattle-Tacoma area. Would like to swap at the Spring Green Elephant on March 1. purple tree collards comfrey #4 (sterile variety more palatable to animals & less toxic) comfrey bocking #14 (sterile) Siberian pea, Caragana arborescens Currants, black Mulberry, purple gooseberry other soft fruits Open to growing what grows well for you & sharing from my gardens: red raspberries, fall gold raspberries, Ozark Beauty strawberries, walking onion, other culinary herbs & groundcovers, fresh brown eggs... Corrine
...See More
Brassicas: Tree Collards X Dino Kale (lacinato)
Q
Comments (7)
Yukkurri_Kame: How did your crosses turn out??? I've always heard the tree collard won't grow true from seed. My guess is that you will like likely have to do many many (1000's?) hand pollinations to get the characteristics you want in a cross. FarmFreedom: If you want tree collard you need to get a cutting or a plant grown from one, not from seed. I'm reposting this from Hawaii forum. the purple "tree" collard or "walking stick" kale is Brassica oleracea var. acephala. It has no oxalic acid. After reading this link,http://treecollards.blogspot.com/I realize that it might be a more accurate description if we called it a "headless cabbage tree" or a "walking stick cabbage," because it's more of a cabbage. A lot of people order the cuttings from California: Tree Collard Cuttings from Bountiful Gardens. Apparently Annie's Annuals in N. California is now also selling plants. But I got mine on craigslist from someone who already grew the cutting. Here is a good search methodology on CL. Go to the "for sale" section of your local craigslist and cut and paste: " collard|brassica collard|acephala|tree" It should pull up any ads for tree collards. The little line is like an "EITHER/OR" in search terms. If you are interested in perennial greens, here is another search term setup for craigslist: "alba|procumbens|Longevity|Malabar spinach|basella|gynura." It will search for longevity spinach and malabar spinach. This site has more information on pruning and care:http://richardsfarms.vpweb.com/Tree-Collard-Information.html
...See More
10B, S. Florida, few questions, plz? (arugula, carrots, tree collards)
Q
Comments (10)
Hi SC Here is what I experienced on some of your questions: Arugula- all the varieties do well for me, what I grow depends on taste, they do excellent in the cooler months but once summer hits they get strong tasting and full of bugs. Carrots- most of them do well for me providing I raise them in good soil for root crops and in a raised bed, keep them moist while young and harvest them at the right time also before summer hits. All the collards do well for me, depends on what you like, regular collards last a long time but again once summer comes they get buggy and diseased, that will be one good reason I would not plant tree collards even in my zone. Since you are a beginner gardener I would not recommend strawberries, they are not that easy or problem free, if you want to try anyway the best varieties with a lot of flavor are the small variety of wild strawberries. Potatoes have to grow in the cool months, easier to grow are sweet potatoes and they will grow in the warmer months. A past carrot harvest from my garden, this season I have a good variety of Parisian a small variety, Koruda, an all purple kind and a few varieties of pelleted seed from Johnny's, my favorite for easy sowing.Silvia
...See More
grannypeck
9 years ago
Go look on YouTube for John Kohler... Growing your greens... or contact bountiful gardens... They are the two experts... I also have 3 purple tree collards... got them in June 2014... just had our first few nights of freezing temps... they look okay so far... but may not make it through our snowy winters... even if mulched... best of luck...
0
mojave_gardener
Original Author
9 years ago
Two of my plants have made it through the hot summer. One is doing OK, the other is doing fantastically. They are about 4' apart, with lots of well developed side shoots off the main stalks.

I did change the irrigation, moving them from a shrub circuit, to the vegetable garden circuit. They get watered several (up to 8) times a day, for 2 minutes at a time during the hottest parts of the summer. I have scaled the frequency back according to the fall weather. My brussel sprouts, kohlrabi, & cauliflower are doing well, so I think the watering is good.

Next summer, I will set up some 50% shade cloth over them. I think it was just too much hot sun for them. (Las Vegas, NV).
0
albert_135 　 39.17°N 119.76°W 4695ft.
9 years ago
Maybe something here: Perennial Tree Collards - Perennial Tree Collards
0
grannypeck
9 years ago
Just an up date... I lost one of my three tree collards to over watering... the remaining two have made it through two light snowfalls here at 5500 elevation and have several small off shoots. Watered them for about 2-5 minutes daily from mid June to late September and nothing but a few light rain showers since. They look good purplish green and rubbery.
0

Tree Collards are DYING !

Comments (6)

aniajs

Reisod

Related Discussions

grannypeck

mojave_gardener
Original Author

albert_135 　 39.17°N 119.76°W 4695ft.

grannypeck

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Tree Collards are DYING !

Comments (6)

aniajs

Reisod

Related Discussions

grannypeck

mojave_gardenerOriginal Author

albert_135 39.17°N 119.76°W 4695ft.

grannypeck

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

mojave_gardener
Original Author

albert_135 　 39.17°N 119.76°W 4695ft.