I've been wondering

14 years ago

can plants get oxygen on a separate portion of their roots than they get water from?

I have the old version of the aerogarden, and it doesn't seem like there's an airstone. There's a water pump that pumps the nutrient solution through the little holes where the plants sit, and I guess this would oxygenate the nutrient solution a little bit, but it doesn't seem like it would do much. I'm wondering if the plant gets most of its oxygen through the top portion of the roots, which is open to the air (the gap between the lid and the surface of the nutrient solution).

I'm curious whether anyone has tried a completely stationary hydro setup like this. I understand that for best production, you'd want to add extra oxygen to the nutrient solution even if the roots take in oxygen from the air, but am curious about this concept for small-scale stuff, like keeping a plant at the office, and growing on my deck next summer (has to be low-budget, and there's no electricity hookup outside).

I may have to give it a try, but thought I'd ask for advice first, in case anyone has tried and failed.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (5)

lifesagardendigit
14 years ago
not an expert here but I believe with aerogardening the pump acts more like a sprayer than a circulator in the nutrient solution... the spraying effect creates an oxygen/h2o/nutrient mix which gives the roots what they need without too much of any one part.... i would imagin that the nutrient/water res with no oxygenation would be too much and possibly harm/kill the plant... the exposed roots in the air might dry and again harm the plant.... haven't done it but that is my guess... i use dwc and have had air pump failure with bad results. just my thoughts

good luck
jessicavanderhoff
Original Author
14 years ago
Thanks for responding!

It sort of drips on the roots. (On about 5% of the roots-- most of the root volume has grown down into the reservoir).

Maybe I will give it a try with a plant that I'm not too attached to, in something small and disposable, like a Styrofoam coffee cup with a lid, and see how it does.
Related Discussions
Madame Alfred Carriere
Q
Comments (5)
MAC was hybridized in 1875, which is antique enough for me. Here is the pic I think kittymoonbeam was talking about - we have three MACs growing 20-30 feet up trees - this is one of them, taken out a window of our house. All of the white roses in the background are from one plant of MAC. I have never pruned it except when branches fall off the trees in storms, which has only happened a couple of times in 20 years. All I can tell you is, unpruned they bloom here in the No SF Bay area 11 months of the year. Yours is gorgeous! Since it does not appear to have anything to climb on, it is making a huge bush. If it were mine I would just prune it to keep it off any paths or humans walking by. Jackie
...See More
Is Your Taste/Aesthetic Influenced by Your Childhood/Parents?
Q
Comments (50)
Absolutely!!! When I was 11 and saw the carpet color my mom had chosen for my bedroom in our new home, I cried and cried. She liked it and some designer had suggested it, so she didn't even consider changing it. I STILL hate that color with a passion (a dark rosey mauve). The rest of our house was cream and peach and grey. We had a living room with ultra plush cream carpet that we were not allowed to enter, except for photos. It had to be carefully vacuumed with perfect lines (like a baseball field). We had built-in laminate desks in the office and master bedroom that never opened or closed properly, and were always getting chips. We had cream laminate with oak trim kitchen cabinets. And of course, unimaginative art show 3-D artwork whose only merit was that it matched the pillows. When my parents had to replace their grey carpet last year, my mom chose a very light cream plush (this was for the stairs too). And when they renovated their kitchen with granite and stainless, they thought it perfectly great to leave the hideous laminate cabs. More than that, though, I just never could understand their purchasing decisions. They always went with cheap quality (not necessarily cheap cost)/immediately available. So everything was always breaking and needing to be replaced - the garbage disposal, the garage door, our cheaply made clothes purchased at full retail. My father still brags about the amazing deals he's gotten on his new unheard-of brand camera or MP3 player (which are predictably never working 2 weeks later). Thankfully, my husband and I are of one mind and always carefully search for the right item, well-made, and if we can't afford quality (paid for in cash), we wait. Quality is always cheaper and less effort in the long run. I search Ebay, Goodwill, and Craigslist. I don't pay retail for anything except groceries. And of course, my mom hates my house, with its British Colonial/Spanish design, antique furniture, wood floors, hand-knotted rugs, and rich colors. My husband and I aren't wealthy, just patient and determined to have things that last. Life's too short!
...See More
ole frugal joyful's ... current dilemma (long!)
Q
Comments (64)
Hi Lindy Lu Who ... ... well, a WA-HO-O-O (not a boo-hoo) about that one! Thank you for making such a wonderful addition to this discussion! I have some Hanes ... and they're blue, too! But ... I've never seen them configured like that! Or ... so occupied, either, for that matter. Also, with elastic still intact - so they're not available for this purpose. Yet. Isn't this a wonderful idea? No more worries about the shortcomings (or, more accurately, long goings) of the elastic: in fact, if it were even somewhat tight, it might cause a problem. If any of you would like to use my old undies in such a fashion, I'd be glad to spring for the postage, even trans-border, to help the ancient briefs find some useful things to do throughout their retirement! Or, more accurately, delay their retirement! I can guaratee that I'll not send holey ones ... and you don't need to worry about the "baggy" that someone referred to, as the only part that's stretched is the elastic (possibly due to not having large body parts to ride herd on). And no stained or dirty ones, either ... solely ones that look to be only in slightly used condition. Then, with these still-useful things having their remaining useful life taken care of, I can go buy new ones with a happy heart!! Adding it as an extra errand when going to town to take care of several needs at a time ... ... and turning off the engine and coasting downhill, and as approaching signal lights when they turn yellow, half a block away ... to be passed by people pushing the gas pedal ... then hitting the brakes about a hundred feet before the "Stop" line. I staked a couple of rows of peas and picked some of the regular and of the edible pod kind. Took them to a nighbour who treats me well, and their daughter and SIL were there, playing cards. Daughter loves peas, I gave her several of the edible pod kind ... and she shelled them and ate them. En route home, I thought that I should have taken the edible pod ones back and given her some of the regular kind ... if she was going to shell them, anyway. Had some of each kind for supper - second picking - delicious! I hope that you had an enjoyable weekend ... and are looking forward to the coming week with anticipation. ole joyful
...See More
Whose roses have been blooming recently?
Q
Comments (37)
The first time I saw Augusta Luise was at a rose show and someone was exhibiting a whole bunch of this rose - probably more than 20 flowers in the vase. At first I didn't really notice it but it was one of the prize winners and many people were standing around it and commenting on its strong perfume so I stuck my nose into it and WOW it was beautifully sweet and I knew I had to get one. I found one at a rose nursery the next day. They have grafted a whole heap of these on fortuniana but only a handful were successful grafts. The owner told me that this is one of those varieties that's really hard to graft onto fortuniana. (Hence the premium price you pay on roses grafted onto fortuniana). I was just happy that they still had 3 plants left so I grabbed one and it has done very well ever since.
...See More
growmaters
14 years ago
Aero gardens are self suffecient the biggest concern is to make sure the drip or sprayer nozzles are not getting plugged up with mineral salts. Also you have to be careful to use nutrients that have no organic matter in them it results in plugging of system components. Aerogarden does make their own nutrient tablets that also work very well with no mixing.

Good luck!
jessicavanderhoff
Original Author
14 years ago
Aerogarden is working fine, thanks. I was asking in general.
lucas_formulas
14 years ago
Hi,
Any water, even without supplementary oxygenation has a certain content of dissolved oxygen. This content depends on the water temperature and/or if organisms draw oxygen from water. The use of clean and 'cool' (19-23Â°C) water is recommended if no oxygen is produced by air-stone or other device (recirculation,etc.)
And yes, plants can derive oxygen either from AIR or from water (nutrient solution). Some plants are able to better survive in oxygen deficient or stagnant water, but most species need an adequate content.

In case oxygen content is inadequate, the plant growth will slow down and general metabolism will be much slower. The lower the oxygen content, the lower the concentration in nutrient should be. In case there is no supplementary oxygen source, nutrient solution should be replaced frequently, as the plants absorbe the O2 content quite quickly. Obviously, small plants with little root mass survive (thrive) much longer in stagnant, yet cool water. The use of pre-oxygenated water with each water change is recommended as well.

I've been wondering

Comments (5)

lifesagardendigit

jessicavanderhoff
Original Author

Related Discussions

growmaters

jessicavanderhoff
Original Author

lucas_formulas

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

I've been wondering

Comments (5)

lifesagardendigit

jessicavanderhoffOriginal Author

Related Discussions

growmaters

jessicavanderhoffOriginal Author

lucas_formulas

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

jessicavanderhoff
Original Author

jessicavanderhoff
Original Author