Plants for the most impatient hybridizers (i.e., students!)

15 years ago

I posted this message on the house plants forum before noticing this hybridizing forum, which is much more appropriate for my query. IÂm looking for a good subject for a simple genetic variation/artificial selection lab, in which we can start the semester with two blooming varieties that the students cross-pollinate, then collect the ripened seeds, then grow these out long enough to see the traits in the offspring. All in one 15-week semester! IÂve used Brassica rapa "Fast Plants" for a similar lab in the past, because you can (barely) get through two generations in a semester, but they have become both prohibitively expensive and increasingly unreliable (bad combo!). I'll be happy to start with mature parents and finish with mature offspring.

Unfortunately, although patience is obviously an essential virtue for the serious hybridizer, I need to find those plants that are best for the most impatient hybridizers! Can anyone recommend a cheap, easy-to-get plant that could meet these requirements? One that springs to mind is portulaca: 40-50 days from sowing to blooming, but I donÂt know how long it takes for blooming plants to set seed and seeds to ripen. I also suspect that it would take longer in the fall than in the heat of the summer, and those dang dust-like seeds might be too much for my students to handle.

It occurs to me that foliage varieties would work just as well, and perhaps better, since you wouldn't have to wait until they were blooming to see the results. However, I've seen even less information on the all-important (for me!) time between pollination and seed maturation.

Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated!

Cheers,

Alan

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (9)

farmfreedom
15 years ago
They have been breeding late maturing spinach for years . It should be easy to reverse the process they go to seed in about a month. Radishes can mature in 19 days but it takes them longer to go to seed . There is a type of cress that matures in 5 days but I do not know how long it takes to go to seed. Bok choy is another posibility . also borrow Kent Whealey's book "seed inventory" LET ME KNOW HOW YOU MAKE OUT .
maineman
15 years ago
Alan,

Some zinnias are rather quick to bloom and, if you cross pollinate them promptly, they will set seed that, while still green, could be viable after three or four weeks after pollination. One possible candidate would be zinnia Thumbelina. They can start blooming when they are only about three inches high and their plants are also quite compact, so they wouldn't take up a lot of space in the lab. It would be cutting it close, but I think you could have your hand pollinated Thumbelina hybrids blooming in 15 weeks from the first planting, provided that you used the "green seed" technique. They come in many different colors, so there would be a large number of combinations of crosses to make.

For some background information, see It can be fun to breed your own zinnias and the follow-on Part 2, Part 3, Part 4, Part 5, and Part 6. Those are all in the Annuals forum.

MM
Related Discussions
Recommendations for shrubbiest, most vigorous hybrid teas
Q
Comments (55)
Cynthia: you are my savior many times !! THANK YOU. In June you saved me from killing Firefighter the 4th time. Thanks to you, I took that off from my buy-list, and Roses Unlimited gave me Pretty Lady Rose instead (bunnies killed that along with acidic grass clippings in 2020). I thought about buying Firefighter as grafted since I killed the own-root 3 times, then thanks to your post, I won't attempt it as grafted. Here's how I killed Firefighter as own-root 3 times: 1) 2014 tree-root invaded the 3rd-year own-root Firefighter. I should had moved it, but left it there, so it died when cane-borers took over due to lack of calcium (trees steal lots of calcium and water). 2) Bought 2nd gallon-size Firefighter. Since it's low-thorn waterhog, I experimented planting it next to a rainspout. It died from freezing rain in winter. 3) Bought 3rd band-size Firefighter. I don't trust my zone 5a winter, so I potted it inside my unheated garage. In Feb. the temp. inside my garage was freezing single-digit. My refrigerator broke down, and I was busy storing food inside the garage and I forgot to cover Firefighter with a thermal blanket.
...See More
Local students came to our park & ripped out non natives
Q
Comments (30)
I don't know much about any of this, but IMHO, there's non-native and invasive, and it may be a bit of overkill (literally) to rip out the former when the concern is more with the latter--assuming, of course, the former is not a problem in its own right (in terms of needing a lot of water or pesticides). As humans, we are forever bending nature to shape our will. There is a greater interest in and desire for native plants, and I gather the native plant store here is doing just fine. But most suburbs are loaded up with plants that are at least not native to this area, if not even the US, because that's just what the standard has been (and in some cases, what the HOAs demand). I'd be more interested in seeing people get rid of their lawns than their non-native flowerbed plants, personally. But as someone without a lawn, it's very easy for me to get on a soapbox about it. My balcony has a number of non-native plants--on a microcosm level, nothing is actually native to my balcony, LOL, except concrete. Many are not local, like the plumerias. Others are from other countries, like the mandevilla and perhaps a succulent or three. But then I read that mandevillas aren't even found in their original habitat now. Still, as some note, things move around whether you like it or not. The gecko is now found everywhere in the world, traveling about on ships, and largely fits in nicely wherever it goes. Of course, the Chinese rat flea did the same thing hundreds of years ago and was nowhere near as welcome. :-) Meanwhile, the invasives in Hawaii and Australia destroy ecosystems in a heartbeat. I guess my two cents about the OP's situation is this: If they were ripping out non-natives that weren't causing any issues on the basis of some philosophy that non-natives are inherently evil and must be destroyed, I think that's a bit messed up. On the other hand, if their goal was to create a native garden (and more or less bill it as such), it's fine. In other words, I'm looking at motive--is it to *destroy* the non-natives or is to *create* natives? For some reason, that matters to me.
...See More
Waiting impatiently for my new order
Q
Comments (35)
Fred - thank you for you generous suggestion. I lost my The King - managed to sell all my babies - but probably I can a leaf from one our Master Judges. Janet Reimer sent me "Frankie" which is supposed to be Max Maas blue of choice. "Sashah" is unkillable, "Becky" is lovely as well a "Tina". But my beloved is "Maas' Janet". I am saying "wow" every time it blooms. I do not have Maas' Memories anymore - in my conditions it grows XXX-large and it drops the bloooms immediately. It is highly floriferows - but what i see mostly - is the bare bloomstalks whith no flowers. For whatever reason all Rob's trailers grow fabulous for me, some of his semis too, but not all, some get eversuckery, and Ma's varieties are never spectacular for me. I just love Rob's Boondoggle - and it is always in bloom and it always super floriferous and holds flowers forever. It seems to me that the closer to your conditions the hybridizer lived - the better the violets do for you. I got some standard Russian trailers - and they superperform for me - and for my friends in Florida - who are beter growers than me - they barely grow. Irina
...See More
I.E. Cukes, Melons, & Summer Squash
Q
Comments (9)
Well it looks like the nice weather has everyone off the computer and out in the garden. That is the way it should be I suppose but it has put a damper on the numbers for this swap. I will give it until Tuesday night; if we don't hit ten swappers ( we have five now) I will pull the plug. I have received two packages already and if the swap is cancelled, we will have to work something out.
...See More
farmfreedom
15 years ago
you may wish to use cornix or Japanese quail . They become sexually mature in 6 weeks . Not a plant though .Check out
http://www.grcp.ucdavis.edu/publications/doc20/ch2.pdf
charbonnet
11 years ago
Mustard might be good. It's easy to grow, doesn't require vernalization like bok choi and radishes often do, produces seed easily, is reasonably easy to cross, and there are red and green varieties. You might try something like 'Red Frills' or 'Crimson Tide' which are frilly and red, and 'Florida Broadleaf', which is green and not frilly. And mustard seed's cheap.
weedyseedy
10 years ago
It might be easier to use fruit flies than plants as almost no common plant I know is that speedy----though, come to think of it you might get two mature blooming foliage plants and at least get seedlings big enough to see variation-------------------------------Weedy
zen_man
10 years ago
Zinnias are more colorful and easier to see than fruit flies, and bloom in about 6 weeks from seed.
yukkuri_kame
10 years ago
Necroposting on this ancient thread.

Funny first thing that popped into head was purslane before I saw you mentioned portulaca. Never tried to hybridize it, but I have 2 varieties growing in garden, so maybe will have a hybrid soon. Not sure how easy it would be to emasculate or hand pollinate.

Very quick to germinate, flower and set seed and produces tons of easy collect seed - but also easy for the seed to get everywhere!
farmfreedom
10 years ago
Probably the best bet would be pansies as they are both perennial and treated as annuals .You can keep successive generations from previous classes to illustrate the generations and get several generations per year . also there are many traits and a wide variation in the species .
farmfreedom
9 years ago
By the way pansies can cross with violas, violets, johnny jump ups . They come in: small, regular, large ,and giant Swiss ,blotched or penciled faces , regular and ruffled petals . You never let us know how you made out !

Plants for the most impatient hybridizers (i.e., students!)

Comments (9)

farmfreedom

maineman

Related Discussions

farmfreedom

charbonnet

weedyseedy

zen_man

yukkuri_kame

farmfreedom

farmfreedom

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US