How big should I let rosemary get?

13 years ago

Hi folks,

I have a "problem" that I've never had before. I have a rosemary plant that I've successfully over-Wintered for two years, and as we begin on the journey of its third Winter in the kitchen, I realize that it's become quite large.

This rosemary lives in a terra cotta pot. It spends its Winters (as brief a time as possible, usually mid-December to mid-March) on the kitchen counter, and in the Summers I sink the pot into the ground in the herb bed. I have been re-potting into a larger pot in the Spring.

At any rate, this lovely plant is now quite large and living in a 12" pot. When I pulled it up from the garden, a reasonably sized root was coming out of the drainage hole (but not as big as the one from the 8" pot last year). This makes me think that it would still be happy to to into a bigger pot in the Spring and just keep going (I really hoped that I'd get 2 years out of this pot!). Looking at the plant and the pot, my gut says the plant could probably be half again as big and still be reasonably happy in this pot, escaping roots notwithstanding.

Nevertheless, I'm starting to wonder whether I should call it quits on the annual pot upgrades, so that I'll still be able to lift it in future years. Until the last couple of years, I had never successfully over-Wintered a rosemary, so I can't claim to have considered how to handle this situation.

So tell me, wise gardeners in northern climes...how big do you allow your over-Wintering rosemary to get? How big of a pot do you keep it in? What kind of pruning do you do, for branches or roots? What does long-term rosemary over-Wintering look like? Etc., etc.

This is additionally complicated for me on an emotional level, because this year I acquired an Arp rosemary that I've planted in the garden, which should be Winter-hardy in my zone. If this succeeds, I do have wonder how much energy I'll be willing to devote to hauling pots in and out every year.

Thanks, all!

Featured Answer

Bourbon Milkshake

6 years ago

Here I replace rosemary every few years. Even with frequent and hard pruning, eventually the base will get woody and unsightly.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (10)

CA Kate z9
13 years ago
I would suggest rooting one of the trailers in a seperate pot to start a new "inside" plant. Then plant the older one outdoors in the ground in a more protected location.

Rosemary wants to be a big plant, but by both root- and top-pruning you might be able to keep this one smaller.... sort of like bonsai.
leira
Original Author
13 years ago
Westelle, regular rosemary will NOT survive a Winter outdoors in my zone, probably not even in a protected location (which is moot anyway, since my yard offers either "protected" or "sunny" but not both).

There's nothing I'd like more than to just leave it in the ground, but that's not an option where I live. This is why I acquired an "Arp" rosemary, in the hopes that it would survive the Winter here. I'll know in the Spring whether this was successful.

So...given that this particular rosemary plant must come indoors for the Winter months, and therefore it must remain in a pot, I'd like advice about about managing this long-term.

I have made new plants by layering in the past, and I also have a small plant that I'm over-Wintering this year as well. I would prefer not to give up on the large plant, however.
Related Discussions
The big question!! How often should I water my garden
Q
Comments (2)
You are generally better off watering longer but less often. When you water small amounts very frequently, the lawn and garden stay wet on the surface nearly all the time, making an ideal environment for fungus problems. Plants also don't put down deep roots since they don't need to, so are more susceptible to drought stress if there is a gap in the watering, and if your sprinklers aren't completely uniform, you get patches that never get enough water. By watering less frequently, but with more water so it soaks down in, the surface will dry out and reduce fungus problems and the roots will go down deeper to follow the water. I water usually once a week, sometimes every 5 days during the hottest part of the summer when days are consistently in the 90's--it depends on when the grass starts to show water stress, but the water will reach a depth of 24 inches or more from each watering. My climate gets virtually no rainfall, so irrigation is all it gets. When we do get measurable rain in late spring, then I will space the watering out further, based on when the grass just starts to show some drouth stress. What I'm getting at is let the ground dry out to a depth as long as your middle finger or a little more, then give it a good watering, then let it dry to that depth before the next watering and set your timer to follow that schedule.
...See More
How many vines should I let grow?
Q
Comments (11)
I have two set ups. Most of my plants are in 35 L Pots. Just under 9 gallons. I have plenty of physical space, but obviously I'm limited by the pots. I also have a small garden with 12 plants in it. They are a bit close but they have more then 2 feet between them. My oldest plants are only about two months since transplanted into pots and one is already over 6 feet tall and while it's got a lot of unripened fruit on it, I've not even harvested one yet. Point being, these plants are looking like they will be huge if I let them. Some of the young ones have leaves wider than the plant is tall (about a foot and a half). I'm supporting things with bamboo. I have two or three poles in each pot and am starting to lay posts in the garden. I've been pruning my older plants down to about 3 vines each but have been reading a lot about growing huge yields and it seems the recommendations are to let more vines develop for the bigger yields. But I'd think a pot can only support so much healthy fruit. I'm wondering what that amount is? I've got to make some decisions about how I'm going to let my younger plants grow and I was just wondering where that balance was and how many vines I could easily support with a pot that size or a garden where plants were only about 2 feet apart. I figured there was a limit. I'm growing over a dozen varieties such as Brandywines, Ox Hearts, Aunt Ruby's, Black Krim, Big Rainbow, Abraham Lincoln, Hill Billy, and so on. Thanks in advance for any advice you might have.
...See More
Should I let her know my dissatisfaction or let it go.
Q
Comments (38)
Service was good with the sectional manufacturer, got delivered on time and is great quality. The poor service I am complaining about is from the furniture store owner only. Anyway I am working with another local store on a different ottoman, golly gee, I got a price within an hour of my email today, that is what you call service! I went in and brought home 3 red fabric samples. None are exactly the red I am looking for but I think I may have to comprise some.
...See More
How long should I let collard greens grow?
Q
Comments (14)
Here we plant collards year round. If planted in early spring, they grow all summer and you can crop off the leaves from the bottom of the plant to eat. As you harvest the leaves, the soil is hilled up around the main stalk. The plants will continue to root along the stalk. They will grow through summer, fall and most usually grow right through winter. We usually add a bit of 10-10-10 and compost every so often during the hilling process to feed them. They can get huge. Around April or May they will send up yellow flowers and make little pods full of seed, which you can save. By planting in spring you can have collards all year. I usually harvest lots for my chickens as well. They LOVE them! You can also plant them late summer, early fall and they will grow through winter but you will have smaller plants. No matter when I plant here, they make seed April or May. They really can take the heat and cold. Tough plants. BT will take care of the cabbage worms that also love them. Here's our collard patch. Plants were started early spring and this pic was taken 6-24-17. Good luck with your garden!
...See More
fatamorgana2121
13 years ago
I could not get "arp" for overwinter for me. Some gardeners in my area can do it but I've failed 3 times (my limit). Sometimes it's all about the microclimates you have. Obviously I don't have the right ones. If your "arp" doesn't make it, don't despair. Try another location and see if that works better.

As far as your indoor giant, perhaps you can take a page from the bonsai or topiary books. Manage its size and shape. It is a woody plant and so you should be able to use some bonsai techniques to keep your plant a manageable size for indoors. Obviously you don't want a 6" tall plant but the overall bonsai ideas of how to prune, shape, and keep to a certain size would be applicable.

FataMorgana
CA Kate z9
13 years ago
leira: I guess you might want to learn to do Bonsai. The basic technique will keep your rosemary in bounds.
lindalou
13 years ago
what is an "Arp" rosemary? ;)
fatamorgana2121
13 years ago
A particular variety of rosemary that is the most cold-hardy one commercially available.

FataMorgana
User
13 years ago
I would try to get Arp and give it a try. I never had luck with rosemary in the house. I started planting Arp and other unnamed varieties in the ground, and they went through the winter fine--even after this last horrible winter with sustained cold and deep snows. And after a winter where the deer ate everything green, they don't touch the aromatic rosemary.--I'll be planting hedges of it in the Spring! Good luck.
winnjoe
13 years ago
I didn't worry about bonsai techniques, I just kept trimming it and using it to keep it small and fairly open in the middle. For me they have maxed out at about 2 ft.
Cat
6 years ago
I talked to a guy tonight how to pull his out because it was 8 ft tall and taking over his space.

How big should I let rosemary get?

Bourbon Milkshake

Comments (10)

CA Kate z9

leira
Original Author

Related Discussions

fatamorgana2121

CA Kate z9

lindalou

fatamorgana2121

User

winnjoe

Cat

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

How big should I let rosemary get?

Comments (10)

leiraOriginal Author

Related Discussions

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

leira
Original Author