skip to main content

Help! My shallots are still green and small...

15 years ago

Just for fun, I tried planting out store-bought shallots in my garden last fall. Only a couple sprouted, but they are doing great. Unfortunately, they have apparently grown WAY too slow... although the original bulbs have split into lots of "babies", they are still very small, and all the leaves are still green and fresh. And we are starting to get freezes here! What should I do? Pull them and use them like green onions? Leave them in the ground over another winter? Mulch them?

I had expected to have mature bulbs by now. What did I do wrong? Is it possible this variety just isn't suited to my area? Do shallots need a lot of fertilizing? More than 6 hours or so of mid-day/afternoon sun?

Lori

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (3)

makalu_gw
15 years ago
It sounds like you didn't do anything really wrong: it's just that shallots are different from things like garlic. It's a bit strange that the leaves have stayed green all summer though ... mine usually die off by August and start back up in late October.

To get large shallots, what you want to do is plant the small ones - they have many fewer growing points so that they produce only a few big shallots. They do take a fair amount of fertilizer and they'd like as much sun as you can give them for best results.

What I'd do now would be if the "babies" still have a bulb, I'd dig them, carefully separate them and replant 6 to 12 inches apart. Since you're going to have a bunch of them left over, I'd use the ones that have sprouted as green onions and also keep any that didn't in the pantry until early spring so that you can put another few in the ground at that time to see the size difference and replace any that got winter killed. I'd also go back to the store and get a couple of more of the large ones and plant them too ... that way you have the large ones making many small ones for next year's planting while the small ones are making big shallots for eating.
garlicman2
15 years ago
Some shallots only grow well from seed and others will grow well from offsets.Fertilize well and early.My guess is that your 'store bought' shallots have no variety name.
Related Discussions
Shallots bolted... Will they still divide?
Q
Comments (2)
Thanks for the reply. I've seen them divide from little bulbs when first planted and taken good care of, but since they've been so stressed and then bolted, I didn't know what to do or expect. Most of the bolted shallots are still doing good, growing a lot of leaves... Some of the broken off scapes even shriveled up as if they were never there, which surprised me. I'll wait until they are truly ready to harvest, like you said... We've had some weird weather in the last few months, high 90s last week and a couple of the bolted plants went dormant. All they had left were the big broken scape stalks so I pulled them. I may do an experiment and cure/hold those two instead of eating for as long as I can. Then, replant them before they rot and see what they do. Thanks again...
...See More
why are my shallots soo small
Q
Comments (35)
Plant some of both, the smaller to medium ones to size up for cooking and enugh of the larger to divide into next years planting stock. Cook mainly the larger ones. Except always plant back the very largest, hopefully to select for increasing sizes, and make sure to mark those when you plant so you know the resulting daughter lines next year. Some strains produce larger bulbs than others so there is some room for selection to improve bulb size. Small size bulbs are a common complaint about both shallots and potato onions. This is a different growth pattern than with garlic, where you always plant the largest cloves to produce the largest possible bulbs.
...See More
what's still green in my yard post freeze
Q
Comments (3)
I'm glad to hear your front yard is in good shape. You had it looking really nice and evidently you used all the right plants for the right place! You are lucky your tropicals came through. The painted fingernail broms I got from you came through the freeze with flying colors for me. My bamboo did well also. I have Multiplex "fernleaf", yours were "Alphonse Karr"?? Sounds like those are plants to use more. Kay
...See More
It's freezing at nite and the tress are still green...HELP!
Q
Comments (11)
Hi everyone. Here at the Homestead in the North Georgia Piedmont (Zone 7b) all our figs are in ground, even the new ones. We even start our cuttings in ground. We mulch the base of all figs (they were mulched in the summer too), and this year for the first time (because we have so many new figs) I am going to use some plastic tubing to cover the youngest whips when the leaves drop for some extra cold protection. But mostly, it's tough-love out here in the country: If a plant isn't tough enough to make it on it's own, we plant something else the next year. We have looked for mostly proven cold-hardy figs, and so far they are making it through the cold, snow, and ice just fine. It can get down into the upper teens ocassionally, but usually normal winter lows are upper 20s and lower 30s. The new ones freeze back to the ground the first year or two, but once they get a solid hardwood base they really take off. Best wishes to all. John
...See More
vikingkirken
Original Author
15 years ago
Hmm.... I'm thinking that my biggest problem was probably that I didn't fertilize. I planted these in soil amended with compost, but then didn't do anything more with them.

Garlicman2, you say that some varieties grow well from seed and some do well from offsets... my shallots did divide, quite a lot actually, but only very late in the year--almost a year after planting! And so they are not mature enough to harvest for anything but green onions right now... does this suggest I have a bad variety for growing from offsets, or just that I don't know what I'm doing? =)

And can I plant shallots in the spring, or is that too late? I am loving trying out the different alliums, so I may order some in the spring if that would work. I'm guessing it's too late in the year to plant out now... I would like to try a variety that grows well from offsets, rather than seed. Can anyone recommend one?

Lori

Related Stories

GREEN DECORATING 8 Questions to Help You See Through Green Hype

By Laura Gaskill

With the ecofriendly bandwagon picking up some dubious passengers, here's how to tell truly green products and services from the imposters

REMODELING GUIDES How Small Windows Help Modern Homes Stand Out

Amid expansive panes of glass and unbroken light, smaller windows can provide relief and focus for modern homes inside and out

REMODELING GUIDES Home Styles: Why Postmodernism Still Matters

Playful mix of history and irony helped pave the way for today's headline-making buildings

GREEN DECORATING Easy Green: Big and Small Ways to Be More Water-Wise at Home

By Laura Gaskill

These 20 tips can help us all make the best use of a precious resource. How do you save water in summer?

KITCHEN COUNTERTOPS Kitchen Counters: Granite, Still a Go-to Surface Choice

By Ivon Street Studio

Every slab of this natural stone is one of a kind — but there are things to watch for while you're admiring its unique beauty

STORAGE Downsizing Help: Shelve Your Storage Woes

By Becky Dietrich, Interior Designer

Look to built-in, freestanding and hanging shelves for all the display and storage space you need in your smaller home

KITCHEN DESIGN Shaker Style Still a Cabinetry Classic

By Elements of Style

The Shaker profile stays true to its generations-old square simplicity but can adapt to any modern taste

MIDCENTURY HOMES Houzz Tour: Small Changes Earn a Top Green Rating

Remodeling for energy efficiency and sustainability within a quaint town's codes wins LEED platinum certification for a midcentury home

LIGHTING Help! I Need a Light!

Help Me Design My Wine Cellar - Please!

Sponsored

EK Interior Design

5 Reviews

TIMELESS INTERIOR DESIGN FOR ENDLESS MEMORIES

More Discussions

Walking Onions Pollination

0

comfrey tea overwintered

1