Small plastic and glass pieces in compost

10 years ago

I bought a couple yards of "planter's mix" from a local landscaper supply shop. The worker said it was an organic compost with added nitrogen. $46/yard.

I chose this company because they are within a mile of my house and very convenient. Other options are not closely located.

I got home and ran my fingers through the compost mix and noticed numerous 1-2cm sized plastic and glass pieces and some small wire and fishing line chunks.

My questions are:

1. Is this common or expected in what companies sell these days?
2. Is this debris harmful when I add the planters mix into my raised beds?
3. Is it worth hand sifting to get the debris out?

Thanks in advance.

Featured Answer

TXEB

10 years ago

I don't buy compost. But there have been a number of reports in these forums from folks who have who reported finding debris similar to what you describe. One even reported an old shoe, along with bits of glass, plastic and wire (see link below). My SWAG is that where you get compost like that, it probably came from municipal waste disposal where the contributors are rather indiscriminate about what they toss into their collection bin. If it were me I'd go back with whatever I still had and raise .. well .. I'd make a big fuss. You got something far less than what you paid for. In my world that's called a rip-off. If they balk, tell them the internet is a great way to let the world know what they (by name) are selling, and that they will soon be famous for the crap they sell. That will often get their attention.

Here is a link that might be useful: Contaminated Compost Thread

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (10)

User
10 years ago
We've had a few threads about this in the past that de-evolved into what it should be vs what it is in many real-life/real-world practices.

There are a lot of soil places selling scraped top soil. A lot of this scraped soil comes from building lots where the soil is removed so builders have a solid/stable foundation to build upon that won't shift/sink. Soil places (and some municipal composting/soil programs) get this top soil.

You're likely to find small pieces of "trash" in this soil.

That said...it's usually not worth the trouble to try to remove it and unless the chunks are extremely excessive in amount or excessively large. The plants/roots will grow around them without trouble and there's not any danger to the health of the plants.

This post was edited by nc-crn on Mon, Sep 9, 13 at 21:47
Related Discussions
What To Use For Gluing Wood, Glass, Or Rocks TO Plastic?
Q
Comments (13)
GE Silicone II - the sealant for indoor/outdoor use. I've used it to adhere glass to plastic, rocks to wood and plastic and glass, glass to glass, ceramic and porcelain to wood and plastic and metal, etc. You name it, I've used it! I used it on a piece which I mosaiced and placed outside and forgot to bring in for the winter. The porcelain pieces are still stuck to the wood, but the wood warped and the grout has broken in some places. Tried to pry some of the pieces off yesterday, but they are on there for good!
...See More
Education and plastic in compost
Q
Comments (14)
Well, I like my grass. I don't feed it steroids and don't waste fuel other than my own and DH's to cut it and I certainly won't use water to keep it going. If I'd have to do that, out it would come and in would go some xeriscape gardens. In the past couple of weeks I've used 5 wheelbarrows full of UCGs and a bit of ashes to wake up the worms to aerate the lawn and help me out. My daughter (12) loves to fling the stuff and so do the neighbourhood kids. During the flinging I get asked a lot of questions. The result has been a few visits from parents who are asking what we are doing to make the lawn so green and to get it through the dry periods in great shape. They tell me they've heard things from their kids who came home smelling like coffee. So I talk while we walk through the gardens, and while doing so they begin to notice the birds and the butterflies which are plentiful. I got a visit today from a lady and her daughter up the road who asked what kinds of plants she needed for Monarchs because her daughter was here last week and one landed on her shoulder and she wants butterflies. I have a lot of extras so I gave them to her on the condition that she not use herbicides and pesticides in her gardens - if she has a problem, she has my phone number. They were so happy as they walked away with plants enough for an army of butterflies. Our municipality has gone a long way in becoming somewhat 'organic' and environmentally responsible. There are bans on pesticides/herbicides, our compostables are picked-up every second week, and regular garbage every other week, all recyclables must be separated into categories, there are depots for batteries, paint cans, and the list goes on. Yet there is much more that can be done and educating the young ones is where we need to speed things up. That's where the key is. Bravo! to anyone who does so in the smallest of ways as it all counts.
...See More
plastic laundry bins for composting
Q
Comments (6)
Gena - Others have commented in the past that the supposed (bad-rap) "stink" of compost piles really does not have to be a part of the compost process at all (some would even say "shouldn't be a part of it").*(see PPS below) There is no minimum size to avoid "stink." It is not size-related - it is ratio-related (enough browns mixed in w/the nitrogen; the N is usually the cause of the alleged stink). So, if your goal is to make "stealth" compost without anyone detecting it from aroma or looks, then you'll do great. I've been doing it in the back of my townhouse in a rubbermaid for almost a year, and no one has noticed. In addition to getting a good brown/green ratio, adding leaves on top usually stops any fresh aromas that might temporarily exist. I just add the leaves to kill the aromas that the raccoons might pick up on, although I don't. Also, I have no flies issue whatsoever. Sometimes if I've had the lid on a while and there's tons of N & very little brown, little tiny gnat-like things float out when I open the lid, but a brief amount of fresh air & they disburse. When the cover's off, no insects hover over it (maybe in it, I'm sure, but not over it). What are the dimensions of the baskets? Even if it's smaller than the supposed min size of 3 feet cube, it'll still work - just eventually b/c it might not be able to heat up well, etc. Truly, my rubbermaid is smaller than 3 feet cube, but it's not tiny by the time you average out the dimensions. So, if you do something in a "less than ideal" size, just know that it might be slower, that it'll work better if the pieces you put in are smaller, that it'll work better if you have access to & put in high-heat items, e.g. grass clippings, alfalfa, bloodmeal, etc., and that it'll work better the more you turn it (in my opinion) b/c it counteracts the moisture that seems to accumulate quickly in a small bin. Hope this helps, All the Best, Tree PS If it were me, I'd give it a try - flies/odor won't be a problem - getting it to reduce to compost in your timeframe - whatever that is for you personally - will be your biggest challenge. I happen to like challenges, and I like the habit of getting outside to "do" something w/it (add to it or turn it) - so I have fun with it! :) *PPS In fact, there's a recent thread about the non-issue of the odor of a pile.
...See More
Plastic, paper or glass dishes?
Q
Comments (8)
I agree with the others. I don't like paper plates or cups, and they cost almost as much as inexpensive glass ones -- glass is even less than paper once you have used them a few times, and it is more earth-friendly. I agree with chase -- your yummy menu and hard work deserve better than paper, not to mention styrofoam (the worst). Besides, you may not even be saving yourself any clean-up work in the end -- a mess on the furniture or floor from a collapsed paper plate will be a lot more work than washing a few dishes -- they only take a few seconds each, even by hand -- not that much longer than collecting and throwing away disposables. And you won't have to remember to go out and buy them next time. Chase is also right about renting. I have a friend who has plenty of dishes but always rents dishes, glasses, and flatware at Xmas time. The company comes and collects them still dirty!
...See More
toxcrusadr
10 years ago
I think for that price you should be getting a better quality product. As nc-cm said it could be coming in with the soil they used, but also from the organic matter. Just looking at my local city-operated yard waste dropoff/mulch sites, there is plenty of debris mixed into the limbs and leaves and grass clippings, from hardware to plastic bottles and bags. They try to separate it out before shredding but when you're scooping with a front loader, it's too much trouble to pull out the odd piece of trash. So crap gets into the mulch.

I think your main complaint is price related. Shoot, I can get trash contaminated compost for free!
wayne_5 zone 6a Central Indiana
10 years ago
I have gotten some leaf compost at $10 yd. It is high quality, but contains 10% small rocks..1/3 to 1/2 inch diameter. I think that a one time application of those rocks would be ok for heavier soils, not for repeat applications.
Lloyd
10 years ago
Having dealt with yard trimmings from a small town for more than six years now, I can state unequivocally that some people are incredibly inconsiderate when it comes to ensuring there is no trash in the yard waste bags. I get everything from garden tools to construction debris to every kind of candy wrapper imaginable. A lot of this 'stuff' screens out but smaller bits get through and there isn't a lot that can be done about it. I know it sucks and very frustrating but unfortunately it's reality.

Lloyd
uscjusto
Original Author
10 years ago
Price might be high but this place is very convenient. I could buy the bagged stuff at Lowes or HD but that's pricey too.

Guess I'm SOL. I can't return this stuff bc the alternatives are not convenient and gas costs alone would be high.
toxcrusadr
10 years ago
You might consider at least giving them some feedback about their product, and tell them that you'll be very careful how you choose products next time. If they're smart they might make some changes.
Kimmsr
10 years ago
1. As more and more gardeners want "compost" many people are getting into the manufacture of it, often people will no scruples. Junk in compost, therefore, is becoming more common. The only way to control that is to find out which companies are doing that and do not buy the junk they sell.
2. It may be. The presence of this type of junk might also indicate the manufacturer was not very picky of the inputs and there are other, less visible and more toxic, bits of junk in that "compost".
3. It may be or the bits and pieces might be too small for you to screen out. The place to screen this garbage out is before the material is prepared for composting.
Always remember, "Caveat Emptor", let the buyer beware.
seysonn
10 years ago
Some municipalities process household trash into compost and give it away free to the residences and local landscapers. And they dont make no secrecy about this. One is COBB COUNTY in GA. It is possible that there is such a municipality in your area and the landscape supply guys get the stuff free and mix them with other material and sell them.

Then there are other municipalities that strictly process yard wastes that the residences bring to the dump site. They sell composted material at a minimal cost to the residence.
Case in point: Westport, CT. I have lived and gardened in both places and I know the information first hand.
toxcrusadr
10 years ago
What exactly do you mean by 'household trash'? I assume you mean residential yard waste, but when I hear household trash, I think of everything in the residential waste stream, which would be a complete mess if you tried to compost it.

Small plastic and glass pieces in compost

TXEB

Comments (10)

User

Related Discussions

toxcrusadr

wayne_5 zone 6a Central Indiana

Lloyd

uscjusto
Original Author

toxcrusadr

Kimmsr

seysonn

toxcrusadr

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Small plastic and glass pieces in compost

Comments (10)

Related Discussions

uscjustoOriginal Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

uscjusto
Original Author