SHOP PRODUCTS
Houzz Logo Print
stripped_threads

disapointed with B&D

stripped_threads
16 years ago

I have a Black and Decker 7 1/4 circular saw and the bushing on the arbor is totally worn out. The saw is 4 years old and got used no more than twice a year light usage. Mayby 30 minuts a year!

So anyway, I need a new one but want a fairly good one. But since it doesn't get alot of usage I don't need a super high end one. I figure a 150.00 Makita or Dewalt will suit me fine.

Any suggestions, or sucess stories with a certain brand?

Thanks.

Comments (12)

  • canguy
    16 years ago

    You need to pay more to get the better saws with ball bearings instead of bushings in the motor and arbor. Do you have a neighborhood hardware store with knowledgeable staff? I know they are scarce. Home Hardware has always treated me well.

  • masiman
    16 years ago

    I like my PC with left side motor. ~8 years and a little more use than yours per year. It is no where near to having any problems.

    Quality can pay over time.

  • den69rs96
    16 years ago

    Makita and Dewalt make good saws. I have a Dewalt and love it. Been using it for over 6 years and no problems what so ever. I used it to help my brother build a deck and I've used it to to build my shed. However, my friend has a Makita and swears by Makita. I didn't care for the feel of the Makita so I choose the Dewalt. Take a trip to the homedepot or sears and hold the saws. A $150 will get you a pretty good saw no matter what brand you choose, but you should get the one you feel most comfortable with. I would stay away from B&D, Ryobi etc and the lower end stuff with bushings instead of bearings and no blade brakes.

  • stripped_threads
    Original Author
    16 years ago

    How do you know if there are bearings in place of bushings without dismantling it?
    I was debating finding a bearing the correct size and punching out the bushing and replacing it with the bearing. It's probably more effort than it's worth. Did I mention the grease looked more like valve grinding paste from the wear from the bushing, this excellerated the wear. As I said, the saw has no milage. POS.

  • eal51
    16 years ago

    I have no problem recommending Sears Craftsman products. My circular saw is 22 years old and I've only replaced the blades.

    This saw has built 6 decks and cut framing for the remodeling of two houses. It's now working on its third house. The next big project is repairing and then siding the horse barn.

    IMHO Black and Decker tools are not worth the money.

    Enjoy the journey.

    eal51 in western CT

  • canguy
    16 years ago

    You will be pressed to find that durability in Sears power tools today. The mass retailer stuff is built on price.

  • kubotabx2200
    16 years ago

    Some Black and Decker stuff is good. Their blower/vac is pretty powerful and their hedge trimmers are nice too.

    I have a Makita circular saw and have been very happy with it but it is about 15 years old and not sure if the new ones are as good. Hitachi used to be great too when they were all made in Japan, but even they seem to be cheapening their lineup.

  • geko29
    16 years ago

    You'll be very well served by models from Porter Cable, Milwaukee, DeWalt, or Bosch. Being right-handed, I prefer blade-left saws, which I believe only PC and Milwaukee make. Unfortunately, I think only PC has the foresight to make a blade-left saw with a brake. Fortunately, it fits your price range PERFECTLY:

    Here is a link that might be useful: Porter Cable 424MAG 15 Amp 7-1/4-Inch Circular Saw with Blade Left and Brake

  • kubotabx2200
    16 years ago

    I still own an old Craftsman electric drill from the 1960's that belonged to my late father that he bought new and used for 20 years, I have used it for another 20, and it still works fine though it is a bit noisy now. The case is solid aluminum. I will probably pass it on to my children.

  • canguy
    16 years ago

    I have a Craftsman sabre saw like that. It is all metal, heavy as heck, but my dad gave it to me in the early 70's. I seldom use it, maybe my sister's grandson will want it.

  • lee48
    16 years ago

    owners manual should say ball bearing or ball and sleeve bearings. I have an old craftsman all metal circular saw I got new about 36 years ago and has seen steady usage and still going strong. It is heavy though. I also have a makita which was used by a contractor. He was throwing it out because the level adjustment wasn't holding anymore. Took 5 minutes to fix and my son and I use it all of the time in our handyman business. It's great acurate and not too heavy. I'd definitely buy one if I had the need for another

  • tmajor_epix_net
    16 years ago

    My B&D 7-1/4" circ saw just lost the spring for the guard return. I was on here trying to get a clue ... it's so old, that the numbers are no longer there. I'll find a spring for it.

    But, the difference is: This saw is probably 50 years old, is totally aluminum, including the base plate. It has probably framed 50 homes (maybe more), built I don't know how many decks and miscellaneous other things. (I didn't do ALL of this, it was my father's) It has had a couple of switches and probably some brushes in the motor.

    A friend of mine was helping me remodel the house this winter, using his Milwaukee. I thought it was him doing a sloppy job on his cuts, but when I grabbed his saw, I had the same problem. The old B&D just does a better job, probably because it weighs a ton.

    So, they weren't always junk.
    My advice, if you need a new saw, buy an old one.